Nick: Hey Clem, you're gonna pick me right? Remember the moonshine? That stuff was great weren't it? Like, like how we really bonded and sh… moreit?
Clem: I don't know, you were drunk and depressed and it scared me. Besides, nothing you say is going to really change my mind that much if Luke has chocolate like he always does...you, do have chocolate right?
Luke: Fuck sorry, I'm out. Got some gum though.
Clem: Hmmm...mint flavored or sugar-free? -.-
Luke: Uh, mint?
Clem: ...okay, that'll do.
Nick: OH COME ON! He led you across a bridge of lurkers and nearly got you killed!
Clem: =.= and who was it exactly that nearly shot my head open like a watermelon, twice?
Nick: ಠ_ಠ....fuck.
Yeah, you know my answer
And they lived happily ever after, where Luke became an awesome daddy for A.J and him and Clem went on an excellent sibling adventure in a time traveling phonebooth.
Meanwhile Nick bumped into Molly and that ship set sail like the Titanic, epic yet heading for disaster.
I just don't get he point of the whole long thread title it could have easily been titled Luke or Nick but whatever. I choose Luke. Despite Nick having a better back story and harsher time in the ZA I liked Luke's chemistry with Clementine in earlier episodes and thought his character was sadly ruined after episode 3
Well the whole "Pizza or Ice Cream" thing started around the time Season 2 was still being made, and that trend started by a Telltale staff. People back then referred to the Kenny/Jane choice as "Pizza or Ice Cream" after Episode 5, so I made my title an eye catcher to get people away from the Kenny and Jane War bullshit. This thread is pretty old anyway.
I just don't get he point of the whole long thread title it could have easily been titled Luke or Nick but whatever. I choose Luke. Despite … moreNick having a better back story and harsher time in the ZA I liked Luke's chemistry with Clementine in earlier episodes and thought his character was sadly ruined after episode 3
To me Luke had lack of development over the whole season. Nick was probably the most developed character and that was just from the first two episodes.
That was Season 2's issue. No characters developed at all, which means my care towards these characters had no develop at all.
tbh would have been better than what we got, on my first playthrough it felt like I (clem) was basically trying to keep the peace between everyone, and frankly that made it repetitive, and arguing for arguing sake does not make for good character development. However, making an emotional choice is much better, than a heat of the moment decision, which is ultimately what arguments that get out of hand boil down to.
Which ever way it was set up, it would have been better to take this route than the kenny vs jane route. That being said, I did hear in an interview somewhere that TTG wanted to remind us that Clementine is still a child and cannot control the adults around us, and that she could only intervene the only way she knew how i.e. shooting them. This decision is what screwed the ending for season 2 imo.
I don't see how a Nick v. Luck decision would be set up though... if it was in the same way as Kenny v. Jane choice had been, I would've gone with Luke. Not because I dislike Nick, but because... c'mon... it's Luke we're talking about hur!
In this case, I think Nick would be pissed you saved him, and then Luke would tell you its okay and just be sad Nick didn't make it. It's kinda like with how the Pete v. Nick choice was, they were both like, "Why'd you choose me!?"
Comments
Gimmie, become a writer!!! Lilac, is it you that has an obsession for chocolate? Or is that just an on-going reference? :P
bad Tobi! :<
Funny, but wrong lol
Headcanon from a fic. I have a habit of sticking to them >.>
hahaha ongoing reference it is then
Nick.
I'd go with Luke.
Nick. Yeah Luke was more level headed, but he never actually got anything done when you think about it.
Luke
this might be just me but I had honestly no care for Nick. No offence to Nick fans I just dont get why you liked him so much tbh.
UPDATED COMMENT ON 2-24-15
Replayed S2 and saved nick over Pete. Still didnt think the world of him. And told Walter hes like everyone else...
SUNGLASSES
Neither, I'd shoot them both.
The name of this thread sounds stupid
Nick any day. He was the better shot and wasnt as clumsy as Luke.
Got nothing better to say, huh?
Nick.
Because it's Nick.
He has a bit of Kenny in him. I like it.
I just don't get he point of the whole long thread title it could have easily been titled Luke or Nick but whatever. I choose Luke. Despite Nick having a better back story and harsher time in the ZA I liked Luke's chemistry with Clementine in earlier episodes and thought his character was sadly ruined after episode 3
Well the whole "Pizza or Ice Cream" thing started around the time Season 2 was still being made, and that trend started by a Telltale staff. People back then referred to the Kenny/Jane choice as "Pizza or Ice Cream" after Episode 5, so I made my title an eye catcher to get people away from the Kenny and Jane War bullshit. This thread is pretty old anyway.
Definitely Nick.
what? Nick is the clumsiest character TWD has seen!
To me Luke had lack of development over the whole season. Nick was probably the most developed character and that was just from the first two episodes.
That was Season 2's issue. No characters developed at all, which means my care towards these characters had no develop at all.
But I would have chose Nick.
Nick performed hand to hand combat with walkers whilst intoxicated...
That's a pretty neat skill right there.
tbh would have been better than what we got, on my first playthrough it felt like I (clem) was basically trying to keep the peace between everyone, and frankly that made it repetitive, and arguing for arguing sake does not make for good character development. However, making an emotional choice is much better, than a heat of the moment decision, which is ultimately what arguments that get out of hand boil down to.
Which ever way it was set up, it would have been better to take this route than the kenny vs jane route. That being said, I did hear in an interview somewhere that TTG wanted to remind us that Clementine is still a child and cannot control the adults around us, and that she could only intervene the only way she knew how i.e. shooting them. This decision is what screwed the ending for season 2 imo.
More like Trevor and Michael's reaction to each others spoiler cough in GTA5.