Most unrealistic moment
I intend for this to be more comical instead of us whining and ranting. With that being said, name something from season 1/2 of TWD that was not realistic. I will have to say the infinite space in Lee's back pocket(s)
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Jane: Hey Clem, there are walkers around, so as the adult here I'm going to have to ask you to drive while I hold onto the baby, and won't tell you to get in the back so I can drive the truck instead. Now step on it please, if you can reach the pedals.
Clem: But, but I'm eleven-
Jane: I SAID STEP ON IT!!!
Clem: AAAAHH!!!
Jane: I DID NOT THINK THIS THROOOOOUGH!!!
Clem: YOU THIIIIIIIIIIIIIINK!?!?!?!!
Pretty much just waiting for Season 3 to reveal Clem where she pulls up in a truck about twelve-years old and just holds out her hand to the protagonist and says "come with me if you want to live!"
This:
Click here
No way, with all that noise and him killing several walkers, did the others not hear him. there was no reason why they weren't swarming him and no reason why he didn't die there. It's in there to simply be a badass moment (which it is, don't get me wrong), but it's unrealistic as shit.
I'm not sure when this happened, but Pffft, I'm sure clementine doesn't know how to drive a kart.
Well, The accurate part in this is that she drives better and faster than that Scumbag Larry...........
The Bonnie surviving the ice fiasco
Clem holding off a group of walkers on her own
Kenny's survival
Same, to this day my little sister and I still laugh over the pockets.
Read in Cinema Sins Voice
(This one is a rant) Pete an experienced ZA survivor suddenly gets bitten soon after Clem joins the group for the sake of the plot...
Sarita and Kenny either don't give a shit about Matthew or don't remember his existence, They never learn he's dead from Walter, Nick never tells them, Clem never says anything, and it's never brought up again..........
The magical trade of weapons between the Russians at the shootout
And the last thing i'll say is that the majestic Saltlick hasn't appeared since Season 1 Episode 2....Telltale I can't believe your ignorance on this one, Saltlicks always make a surprise appearance and you purposely ignored this crucial fact about my Kind and THEN you replaced the Saltlick with a lame Crowbar.....This is a hate crime....That's what it is...
The shootout.
There are a lot but off the top of my head - Clem dragging Lee into the jewelry shop, Clem kicking down the door, and the whole shootout with the Russians.
Kenny's return.
Pretty much everything that happened in Season 2! But can you even class TWD as being realistic? The whole apocalypse is unrealistic.
im not trying to be rude but we already have a thread revolving around this and i made it its called the walking realism which is a sarcastic title
well you can pretty much class twd as real like for example in the tv-series rick's beard growth he had up until he uh shaved it
and also the walking dead game season 1 has a few intresting real survival tips like the smashing the spark plug trick
so i would say the walking dead has its real feel aspects to it
Casdow90 probably didn't realise that the thread 'The Walking Realism' is a sarcastic title and is about the unrealistic events of 'The Walking Dead'. Simple mistake.
Lee is able to fit Molly's hook into his pocket.
Like Short round? lol
Doesn't matter. Even if he did get bit again, he would have just kept going. He wasn't going to live anyway. All he really had to do was not get devoured.
Try playing old lucasarts games... shudders
Bonnie just really shouldn't have fallen in the ice at all. I don't know what they were thinking there. It makes the possibility of a DLC following the 400 days characters much harder.
And the battery, and an axe, and a fucking blowtorch.
I'm saying that there's no reason why he wasn't devoured. Had the walkers all noticed him, as they should have, they would have surrounded him and their numbers become too huge for him to handle. He was in the middle of a herd, screaming and he wasn't even trying to act like a walker, but yet the walkers all of a sudden become deaf and don't hear him. That goes against everything we've ever learned about walkers from TWD, there's no reason why they all didn't start attacking Lee, which would have led to him being devoured.
I seriously need to find the pants that Lee wears. Clem too.
Clem kicking the door in, Clem basically being the group's leader, Clem being able to be so calm, stealthy and professional that she can sneak through the cabin and carver's camp with no one noticing
They probably would have noticed, but I don't think it would be impossible to survive without being devoured. Maybe bitten a few times but not devoured. Regardless, it was still pretty badass
probably
i think he gets his jeans at Wal-mart
Agreed, making a character determinant so late on the story is kinda pointless anyways.
Her sneaking around undetected wasn't that far fetched IMO. But I agree with everything else you said.
Yeah, especially because you basically have to not do anything for her to die. I wonder how many people didn't bother to crack the ice.
Clementine not telling Luke that the ice was cracking
The walkers on Hershel's farm being able to sneak up on Shawn...and not being able to save Shawn too
the walkers that popped outta nowhere when Lee and Clem are searching the train station
When heading up to the ski lodge there is a long shot of the whole group heading up.
Nick is all ready waiting up the top, then it goes Rebecca, Alvin, Sarah, Carlos, Clem and Luke.
The change in shot to Nick and Carlos is meant to be instantaneous, which means Carlos teleported. As the shot changes on Rebecca and the others, Clem is with them. She was only a few feet in front of Luke and you can still see him right at the bottom of the hill. Remember it's an instantaneous shot...
I don't know about you, but if I was 11 and sneaking around a place like that i'd be scared enough to slip up once or twice. I understand why you'd think that, though.
Season 1 - Lee fiting a truck battery, a blowtorch, a shotgun, etc. in his pocket.
Season 2 - Clems superhuman strenght (for example kicking down a door,fighting off walkers like its nothing,breaking ice,cutting off an arm in two hacks...)
This is basically a carbon copy of the other thread. :P
The 1000s of zombies crowded together at the same time making a lot of noise themselves, with Lee not making a lot of fuss with killing the zombies and in general and kept moving calmly, explains a lot of your post imo. I really don't see why all 1000 of the walkers should have noticed him in that scenario. Even if they did hear something, they are slow to react and he would disappear into the crowd in a few seconds. Also I didn't hear any all out 'screaming' from him, he just grunted loudly while killing some zombies. The only part which looks unrealistic to me is he had 4-5 zombies coming at him in waves before he killed one of them, and I don't get where'd the other 4 zombies go.
Walkers close to him should not only hear him (no matter how much noise he is making) but also see him moving like a regular human and should immediately tell that he is not a walker. But as he's walking by, they just ignore him, walkers don't do that, they are alerted by even the slightest noise or movement, but for sake of the plot, I guess that's thrown away. He's walking, moving, and killing a bunch of walkers, one of them is bound to notice him, but none do. And once one walker notices him, it causes others to take notice as well, that's how walkers in TWD act. Look at Carlos in the third episode of Season 2, he breaks rank for a couple of seconds, and his cover is blown, but for Lee, who's moving freely and actually killing several walkers around him, they just ignore him, it just doesn't make sense.
The baby surviving in the cold with only a few blankets.
I love TWD But still.......
they try to make an unrealistic event realistic...like what would happen if it REALLY did happen....there's definitely a lot of silly plot hole moments in telltales walking dead games, though.
the tv show (which is awesome) is much, much more realistic.
The zombie apocalypse.