The Walking Dead Battle Royale (idea taken from GoT thread)

credit to Clemenem for the idea!

alright, so here's how this works. I pitch a battle between two characters and you post who you think would win. please note that this isn't a thread about which is better, it's about who would win in a fight.

S1 Clem vs. Ben

Lee vs. S2 Kenny

Katjaa vs. Tavia

Bonnie vs. Carley

Mike vs. Luke

Pete vs. Omid

Sarah vs. Duck

Christa's baby vs. AJ

good luck, and may the best character win!

Comments

    1. Clem
    2. Lee
    3. Katjaa
    4. Carley
    5. Luke
    6. Omid
    7. Duck
    8. AJ
  • Ben

    S2 Kenny (since Lee can either be a good or bad fighter depending on how you play him)

    Tavia

    Carley

    Mike

    Pete

    Neither

    AJ

  • Neither

    rofl

    Ben S2 Kenny (since Lee can either be a good or bad fighter depending on how you play him) Tavia Carley Mike Pete Neither AJ

    1. Ben
    2. Lee
    3. Tavia
    4. Bonnie
    5. Mike
    6. Pete
    7. Duck
    8. AJ
  • edited March 2015
    1. Ben
    2. Lee
    3. Tavia
    4. Carley
    5. Luke
    6. Omid
    7. Duck
    8. AJ
    1. Clem
    2. Lee
    3. Tavia
    4. Mike
    5. Pete
    6. lol
    7. Aj
  • edited March 2015

    Clem

    Lee

    Tavia

    Carley

    Mike

    Pete

    Sarah

    Neither

  • Clem

    Depends on how you play your Lee......

    Tavia

    Carley

    Mike

    Pete

    Neither(xD)

    AJ

  • Ben

    Lee

    Tavia

    Bonnie

    Luke

    Pete

    Duck

    AJ

  • S1 Clem vs. Ben

    Lee vs. S2 Kenny

    Katjaa vs. Tavia

    Bonnie vs. Carley

    Mike vs. Luke

    Pete vs. Omid

    Sarah vs. Duck

    Christa's baby vs. AJ

    thanks

  • S1 Clem vs. Ben

    Lee vs. S2 Kenny

    Katjaa vs. Tavia

    Bonnie vs. Carley

    Mike vs. Luke

    Pete vs. Omid

    Sarah vs. Duck

    Christa's baby vs. AJ

  • S1 Clem vs. Ben - he wouldn't be trying to win but screw up and knock her out by mistake

    (my)Lee vs. S2 Kenny

    Katjaa vs. Tavia

    Bonnie vs. Carley

    Mike vs. Luke

    Pete vs. Omid

    Sarah vs. Duck

    Christa's baby vs. AJ

  • Ya forgot to add something!

    S2 Clem VS Becca.

  • edited March 2015
    1. Ben
    2. Lee
    3. Tavia
    4. Carley
    5. Mike
    6. Pete
    7. Sarah
    8. AJ
  • edited March 2015

    Nice.... -_-

    Ben

    Lee (Same thing as when they fought on the train)

    Tavia

    Carley would beat that ass

    Mike

    Omid

    Duck

    They both lose

  • S2 Clem VS Becca.

    ZapThroat posted: »

    Ya forgot to add something! S2 Clem VS Becca.

  • S2 Clem all the way.

    becca's a straight up bitch

    ZapThroat posted: »

    Ya forgot to add something! S2 Clem VS Becca.

  • S2 Clem vs Becca

    ZapThroat posted: »

    Ya forgot to add something! S2 Clem VS Becca.

  • If this thing isn’t judged by opinions,then Clem would sure as hell win.
    But if it is,then your opinion is respected.

    supersagig posted: »

    S2 Clem vs Becca

  • If this thing isn’t judged by opinions,then Clem would sure as hell win

    e.e. That´s YOUR opinion. That isn´t a fact.

    ZapThroat posted: »

    If this thing isn’t judged by opinions,then Clem would sure as hell win. But if it is,then your opinion is respected.

  • S1 Clem vs. Ben

    Lee vs. S2 Kenny (My Lee lost to Kenny on the train...)

    Katjaa vs. Tavia

    Bonnie vs. Carley

    Mike vs. Luke

    Pete vs. Omid

    Sarah vs. Duck (I think Duck would win by default because Sarah would probably be too nice to want to hurt Duck. If she was willing to fight then I'd say Sarah.)

    Christa's baby vs. AJ

  • edited March 2015

    I read the title on this thread, and I thought of Battle Royale the movie and the TWDG stuck on that island with the exploding collars forced to fight other....;_; scary thought.

    S1 Clem vs. Ben

    Lee vs. S2 Kenny

    Katjaa vs. Tavia

    Bonnie vs. Carley

    Mike vs. Luke

    Pete vs. Omid

    Sarah vs. Duck

    Christa's baby vs. AJ....are you friggin kidding me? What did they have, a crying contest? Come on I'm not picking between two babies, get out of here.

  • Well,judging by how experienced Clementine is in fighting,it could easily be a fact.But still,this is all opinion based,you don’t have to believe me.

    supersagig posted: »

    If this thing isn’t judged by opinions,then Clem would sure as hell win e.e. That´s YOUR opinion. That isn´t a fact.

  • edited March 2015

    We don't know enough about Becca to know how much expirience she has in a fight, we don't what she has gone through if she managed to survive the fall of Howe's or beign in the wild for months with the members of the 400 Days group that didn't went to Howe's.

    We know that Becca is older an likely helds a pretty heffty weight advantage to Clementine, altough since Clementine has survived confrontations with adults (granted mostly by outsmarting them) it might not be a decessive factor in all but a boxing style match.

    ZapThroat posted: »

    Well,judging by how experienced Clementine is in fighting,it could easily be a fact.But still,this is all opinion based,you don’t have to believe me.

  • Then,we yet have to see them fight to judge it (fingers crossed).

    We don't know enough about Becca to know how much expirience she has in a fight, we don't what she has gone through if she managed to surviv

  • If Becca is alive, and if they somehow cross into each other, and if they don't get along, and if...

    A lot of variables won't probably happen.

    ZapThroat posted: »

    Then,we yet have to see them fight to judge it (fingers crossed).

  • I think Clementine hated her from the moment she saw her,right?

    If Becca is alive, and if they somehow cross into each other, and if they don't get along, and if... A lot of variables won't probably happen.

  • edited March 2015

    Things can change depending on circumstances they might not even recognize each other (remember that they only met if Shel and Becca went to Howe's), also her reaction seem more of annoyance than hate.

    ZapThroat posted: »

    I think Clementine hated her from the moment she saw her,right?

  • Okay,I have really had enough,you win.

    Things can change depending on circumstances they might not even recognize each other (remember that they only met if Shel and Becca went to Howe's), also her reaction seem more of annoyance than hate.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.