Yeah exactly, so weather or not Carver would've killed Reggie in any way.He wouldn't of had Sarah done her job right.
He would've killed Reggie later on most likely but it was Sarahs incompetence that made him kill Reggie. Reggie could've lived longer had Sarah not fucked up.
Youmake it sound like Sarah has some big fucked up condition. Anxiety is bad but not as bad as you're trying to sell it.
I would've thougt Clementine would be traumatized after all the shit shes seen but apparently a girl who is 15 who only tastes a tiny bit of what a 8-9 year old experienced is alright.
Are you kidding me?
For Sarah picking all the berries? No. For any other reason he could find? Absolutely. Carver had no reason to pin that on Reggie, but he di… mored. He very obviously wanted him dead and was looking for a reason. The fact that Tavia and that other dude I don't remember have a discussion on that matter is meant to show that not even Carver's people believe his bullshit. "I don't think he was going to let him back in..."
Didnd't Clementine get hit in the back of the head by a gun? She seemed to function properly.
Do you just not understand how human beings work? Do you not realize how having a certain condition means you won't react to something the exact same way as somebody else? I think that's the problem here. You're either misinformed or not informed at all on human behavior.
The people who aren't thinking are the ones who want to save everyone. In a world like this, what determines whether or not you survive is h… moreow smart you are. Your morals will just get in the way, and anything that gets in the way is not smart. Risking your life to save someone who will just continue to shut down and put others at risk isn't a smart thing, hence don't fucking do it.
She saved Clem's life, givivng her peroxide to disinfect her wound. I owed her my life, I even taught her how to use a gun. I don't really know why you hate her, just because she got Reggie killed, why would give a damn about him? He was such a wasted character. You even blame her for screaming around the herd? How would you react if someone you love/care about dies in front of you? You think she is a "liability" and a "danger to the group", but she was nice, wasn't she? She never wanted to hurt anybody. I'm not on survivor side bullshit, leting people die to save myself, I don't wanna be like that bitch Jane who cares about nobody but herself.
Wow, that's cold. Who cares about Reggie? People feel sorry for Sarah because she's innocent and broken but Reggie, a poor guy with one arm lost, isn't relevant? Reggie was one of only a few down to earth people in Carvers group and you can say that? Cold as ice dude.
She saved Clem's life, givivng her peroxide to disinfect her wound. I owed her my life, I even taught her how to use a gun. I don't really k… morenow why you hate her, just because she got Reggie killed, why would give a damn about him? He was such a wasted character. You even blame her for screaming around the herd? How would you react if someone you love/care about dies in front of you? You think she is a "liability" and a "danger to the group", but she was nice, wasn't she? She never wanted to hurt anybody. I'm not on survivor side bullshit, leting people die to save myself, I don't wanna be like that bitch Jane who cares about nobody but herself.
The people who aren't thinking are the ones who want to save everyone. In a world like this, what determines whether or not you survive is h… moreow smart you are. Your morals will just get in the way, and anything that gets in the way is not smart. Risking your life to save someone who will just continue to shut down and put others at risk isn't a smart thing, hence don't fucking do it.
The people who aren't thinking are the ones who want to save everyone. In a world like this, what determines whether or not you survive is h… moreow smart you are. Your morals will just get in the way, and anything that gets in the way is not smart. Risking your life to save someone who will just continue to shut down and put others at risk isn't a smart thing, hence don't fucking do it.
I believe Sarah was written as a plot to prove Jane's theory of some people aren't aren't strong enough to make it, just my personal opinion, i could be wrong, i don't have qualms, about admitting my failed tresspasses, unlike others.
"Bye Sarah." Left behind S2 Clem.
That's based on your choices though. People always complain all the time about how they never can … morepick the choices they want. Like, how people complain about not being able to leave AJ behind, that would be against what Clem said in season 1 as well. NPC's are different from playable characters, that's what the difference is between season 1 Clem and season 2 Clem.
Wow, that's cold. Who cares about Reggie? People feel sorry for Sarah because she's innocent and broken but Reggie, a poor guy with one arm … morelost, isn't relevant? Reggie was one of only a few down to earth people in Carvers group and you can say that? Cold as ice dude.
My issue with this mentality (other than the obvious moral problem) is that people who endorse leaving Sarah because she’s a “liability” often think that keeping Kenny & AJ around is perfectly fine…
But if you’d also leave Kenny & AJ to die, then cool, at least you’re consistent.
The people who aren't thinking are the ones who want to save everyone. In a world like this, what determines whether or not you survive is h… moreow smart you are. Your morals will just get in the way, and anything that gets in the way is not smart. Risking your life to save someone who will just continue to shut down and put others at risk isn't a smart thing, hence don't fucking do it.
Because people like selfish people, just because you can do it, doesn't mean you should do it. It will change how people look at you, if you are in that situation that needs help, vs Someone like Sarah, guess who i would choose first to save?
No, but at times it's the smart thing.
Because people like selfish people, just because you can do it, doesn't mean you should do it… more. It will change how people look at you, if you are in that situation that needs help, vs Someone like Sarah, guess who i would choose first to save?
I apoligize for the rudeness, but I don't think i'll ever understand that mentality. People are too precious to just let go of because they might "drag us down". Survival isn't everything, it's also about keeping humanity
Sarah had never been able to fight or survive, so she won't be any help. Someone else, on the other hand, who can do those things, will be more use to you.
I apoligize for the rudeness, but I don't think i'll ever understand that mentality. People are too precious to just let go of because they might "drag us down". Survival isn't everything, it's also about keeping humanity
Sarah had never been able to fight or survive, so she won't be any help. Someone else, on the other hand, who can do those things, will be more use to you.
Sarah had never been able to fight or survive, so she won't be any help. Someone else, on the other hand, who can do those things, will be more use to you.
No one taught her how to fight or survive, i am a great teacher.
Sarah had never been able to fight or survive, so she won't be any help. Someone else, on the other hand, who can do those things, will be more use to you.
Sarah had never been able to fight or survive, so she won't be any help. Someone else, on the other hand, who can do those things, will be more use to you.
No one taught her how to fight or survive, i am a great teacher.
Oh please, You act like Sarah is the only child who has went through something so traumatic. Clementine wasn't like that when she it happene… mored to her. She was able to find a safe spot and yes this was before she knew anything about walkers. When Lee was attacking those walkers in the train station, Clementine was going to shoot but froze but when there was another walker in with her, she quickly gave Lee the keys, Sarah would've probably just stood there and got eaten.
I never said it was her fault she was sheltered, when did I say that?
Inever said her life wasn't important, you said that, not me. All I was saying was that she was a liability to the group. She got memebers of the group in dangerous situations that could've killed them. Sarah should be able to trust Clementine but she still doesn't. And Clementine was trying to guide her but she still doesn't want to be helped. If people won't help themselves, how are you expected to help them?
I can see why people liked her, though I wasn't a fan. Maybe in the real world she was a good, kind person but when the apocalypse happens you got to get your sh** together. I'm surprised she survived as long as she did.
I didn't say she wasn't smart, but she gloats it around others, and tries to make them feel stupid because of her own insecurities. At least that is how i remember her character, its been ten years since i watched it though.
I didn't say she wasn't smart, but she gloats it around others, and tries to make them feel stupid because of her own insecurities. At least that is how i remember her character, its been ten years since i watched it though.
Comments
Yeah exactly, so weather or not Carver would've killed Reggie in any way.He wouldn't of had Sarah done her job right.
He would've killed Reggie later on most likely but it was Sarahs incompetence that made him kill Reggie. Reggie could've lived longer had Sarah not fucked up.
Youmake it sound like Sarah has some big fucked up condition. Anxiety is bad but not as bad as you're trying to sell it.
I would've thougt Clementine would be traumatized after all the shit shes seen but apparently a girl who is 15 who only tastes a tiny bit of what a 8-9 year old experienced is alright.
Are you kidding me?
[removed]
Did Sarah do something stupid after she was saved?
[removed]
She saved Clem's life, givivng her peroxide to disinfect her wound. I owed her my life, I even taught her how to use a gun. I don't really know why you hate her, just because she got Reggie killed, why would give a damn about him? He was such a wasted character. You even blame her for screaming around the herd? How would you react if someone you love/care about dies in front of you? You think she is a "liability" and a "danger to the group", but she was nice, wasn't she? She never wanted to hurt anybody. I'm not on survivor side bullshit, leting people die to save myself, I don't wanna be like that bitch Jane who cares about nobody but herself.
Wow, that's cold. Who cares about Reggie? People feel sorry for Sarah because she's innocent and broken but Reggie, a poor guy with one arm lost, isn't relevant? Reggie was one of only a few down to earth people in Carvers group and you can say that? Cold as ice dude.
That's a pretty disgusting mentality to have. People aren't just things you can throw away like garbage.
being selfish isn't a very good thing
I believe Sarah was written as a plot to prove Jane's theory of some people aren't aren't strong enough to make it, just my personal opinion, i could be wrong, i don't have qualms, about admitting my failed tresspasses, unlike others.
I don't say I hate him, I just never cared for him. He isn't that tough to stand up Carver and he thinks he is a good guy.
Carlos caused her problems
No, because the writers gave her two lines of dialogue. Give her time, on the other hand
No, but at times it's the smart thing.
Call it disgusting if you want. It's how to survive in a world like this
[removed]
My issue with this mentality (other than the obvious moral problem) is that people who endorse leaving Sarah because she’s a “liability” often think that keeping Kenny & AJ around is perfectly fine…
But if you’d also leave Kenny & AJ to die, then cool, at least you’re consistent.
Because people like selfish people, just because you can do it, doesn't mean you should do it. It will change how people look at you, if you are in that situation that needs help, vs Someone like Sarah, guess who i would choose first to save?
You would choose Sarah, except it'll be your ass that gets hurt at the end
On what basis?
I apoligize for the rudeness, but I don't think i'll ever understand that mentality. People are too precious to just let go of because they might "drag us down". Survival isn't everything, it's also about keeping humanity
Sarah had never been able to fight or survive, so she won't be any help. Someone else, on the other hand, who can do those things, will be more use to you.
Survival is everything in a world like this. When you get safe, that's when you can start regaining humanity.
But what if the other person is an asshole? wouldn't you save a nice useless person over a asshole useful person?
Depends on how much of an asshole he is
No one taught her how to fight or survive, i am a great teacher.
At this point, no one can bring her back. She was sheltered beyond coming back
You are correct, she is dead. The writers wrote her as a plot device to justify Jane's viewpoints/reasoning.
Honestly, im at the point where I'd have Kenny gone as long as Jane was also out of the story, just so sarah could live on
haha this made me giggle
I can see why people liked her, though I wasn't a fan. Maybe in the real world she was a good, kind person but when the apocalypse happens you got to get your sh** together. I'm surprised she survived as long as she did.
[removed]
Not all of them. Sarah was suffering from PTSD and Carlos knew the only way to save her was to shelter her from everything.
[removed]
[removed]
Don't think that's necessary, bud.
Prove me wrong man and i'll agree with you....
Attacking a entire gender, you know you are on your own with that one.
I didn't say she wasn't smart, but she gloats it around others, and tries to make them feel stupid because of her own insecurities. At least that is how i remember her character, its been ten years since i watched it though.
Why don't people like Sarah?
I... don't think that's her character at all. Unless she's defending herself against the usual bullies or Bart, then yeah.