Yeah I agree, I get a feeling that things will really go crazy if they start leap frogging from protag to protag. It made sense to go from L… moreee to Clem since Lee died attempting his best to protect Clem and his wisdom gets passed down to help aid her in future journeys. To go from Clem to a brand new weirdo main character never seen before would be odd. Now we got to try to get invested in some new person and learn everything about them basically starting off from scratch which something like that would be better off saved for a spin-off of the mainstream Telltale game series. Like maybe the DLC to post season 3 once its wrapped up in the no doubt far future with how long they take to begin and complete 1 season.
I'd agree with you 100% about seeing her story from the eyes of another character but not anymore. Not after Lee died. After we lost him in Season 1, I don't think that any adult character would replace him as protagonist. At least not new character, though Telltale won't chose any known character from previous seasons. There is almost no one left. Everyone's dead, determinant or their fate is unknown. In other words, I think it's a choice between Clementine or some new character introduced in Season 3 and I don't want to play as some stranger.
I agree with you , her story is NOT over. I'd just like to see her story go through from a different protagonist, playing as her (again, imo) was quite limited. And it's fine, Everyone has there different views. No opinion is wrong.
I was thinking that one of the 400 Days characters could possibly be a protagonist, yet she would still be able to include in the story. After all, they never really explored any of the 400 days characters except Bonnie (who is meh.)
I'd agree with you 100% about seeing her story from the eyes of another character but not anymore. Not after Lee died. After we lost him in … moreSeason 1, I don't think that any adult character would replace him as protagonist. At least not new character, though Telltale won't chose any known character from previous seasons. There is almost no one left. Everyone's dead, determinant or their fate is unknown. In other words, I think it's a choice between Clementine or some new character introduced in Season 3 and I don't want to play as some stranger.
bad writers made clementine unreal. season 1 and season 2 had diferent ones. hope that the season 3 have better writers. but i want clem was a main char.
I don't think that they will use 400 Days characters because they also are determinant. They can be in Carver's camp or they can be somewhere else. In other words, we can meet them in Season 2 and there is also an option that we won't. At least not all of them and because of that I don't believe that 400 days characters could be used as protagonists again.
Though... hm. Maybe there is a chance, I don't know but if there is then I'd see either Shel or Vince as protagonist. I really like them.
I was thinking that one of the 400 Days characters could possibly be a protagonist, yet she would still be able to include in the story. After all, they never really explored any of the 400 days characters except Bonnie (who is meh.)
I don't think that they will use 400 Days characters because they also are determinant. They can be in Carver's camp or they can be somewher… moree else. In other words, we can meet them in Season 2 and there is also an option that we won't. At least not all of them and because of that I don't believe that 400 days characters could be used as protagonists again.
Though... hm. Maybe there is a chance, I don't know but if there is then I'd see either Shel or Vince as protagonist. I really like them.
Oh, yeah. I didn't understand it seems. In that case, I totally agree with you. They should've done something more then just cameos for this characters. They deserved better than this but what's done is done. We can't change that. Maybe there is a little chance that we might play as one of them as Season 3 protagonist? I mean, in Season 2 there is only one choice that matters about them - if they are in Carver's camp. This could be solved pretty easy by different backstory (which means, different dialogues). I'd still want to play as Clementine but if Telltale ever decide to chose another character, I hope it'll be someone from 400 Days group.
I like all of the 400 days characters except Bithecca.
we can meet them in Season 2 and there is also an option that we won't.
… more That is true. That's why I was saying they should have introduced more of the 400 Days characters instead of just Bonnie.They only made cameos.
I didn't even say you did, wtf? What's the point of saying "I don't want Clem as the protagonist" or "I do" if either way your opinion won't have an impact on what telltale has planned to do for Season 3. The hell is even the point of these kind of threads anyway? It's unimpactful, and just bound to start arguments within the community.
I didn't even say you did, wtf? What's the point of saying "I don't want Clem as the protagonist" or "I do" if either way your opinion won't… more have an impact on what telltale has planned to do for Season 3. The hell is even the point of these kind of threads anyway? It's unimpactful, and just bound to start arguments within the community.
I want Clem as the playable character in S3. I left her and Jane together with AJ in Howes and here is so much that can happen. Will that family I turned away return and try to take Howes? Will another herd of walkers pass through? Will a group of bandit's happen by? There's nearly unlimited possibilities of what could happen to keep Clem's story going.. And about those who took Clem to Wellington.. What could happen inside there? Will it fall from a group outside? Will it fall from within? Is Lily the leader inside? Could it be like Woodbury? there's almost unlimited directions of where TTG could take Clem's story and no need for any time skip's.
If you left with Kenny, what sort of adventures will they discover? What will get Kenny killed, what will happen to Clem and AJ, who may they meet?
I think there's alot of Clem's story to tell, there's what? 5 different possible beginnings, 5 different directions to take Clem til they all merge into one finale.
I think the Michonne 3-part mini series will be just extra content, something we'll all just enjoy while waiting for Season 3. I doubt and hope that this will have nothing to do with Clementine. It's just extra and I can't wait for it!
An opinion is an opinion. It's no different than people saying "Lee should not have been killed". It's never going to happen, yet it's an opinion. If you don't like this thread, well then you don't have to post if you find no meaning in it.
You just said I am acting like ttg is going to listen. The gun example is just how you are making it look like I am "demanding" ttg to do what I say.
By this theory, No opinionated threads or posts should be allowed on the forum at all, due to an argument arising.
I didn't even say you did, wtf? What's the point of saying "I don't want Clem as the protagonist" or "I do" if either way your opinion won't… more have an impact on what telltale has planned to do for Season 3. The hell is even the point of these kind of threads anyway? It's unimpactful, and just bound to start arguments within the community.
That's not the point. It's fun to have debates and share opinions, but it's not fun to argue and repeat the same thing half of the community already has.
An opinion is an opinion. It's no different than people saying "Lee should not have been killed". It's never going to happen, yet it's an opinion.
Yeah, but there's not thousands of threads about it and it's not springing up any vicious arguments like these type of threads have. Besides, what's done is done. Telltale hasn't confirmed anything about their protagonist for Season 3.
You just said I am acting like ttg is going to listen. The gun example is just how you are making it look like I am "demanding" ttg to do what I say.
That's... not how that type of stuff works. At all. Acting like their listening and MAKING them listen to/do what you want, id completely different.
By this theory, No opinionated threads or posts should be allowed on the forum at all, due to an argument arising.
No, by my theory, you should stop beating the dead horse that's just going to make a shitstorm. Just like the Kenny vs Jane crap.
An opinion is an opinion. It's no different than people saying "Lee should not have been killed". It's never going to happen, yet it's an op… moreinion. If you don't like this thread, well then you don't have to post if you find no meaning in it.
You just said I am acting like ttg is going to listen. The gun example is just how you are making it look like I am "demanding" ttg to do what I say.
By this theory, No opinionated threads or posts should be allowed on the forum at all, due to an argument arising.
Before "Long Road Ahead" got released, there were theories on the internet how there would be more characters from Ben's summer camp appearing, and how they might be future protagonists (they would've worked like Tales FB)... or how those two shadowy figures in the distance from "No Time Left" how one of them would be OC and a protagonist...
I don't agree with Clementine being season 3 protagonist
OP makes it sound like they announced the news. Titling it "The Walking Dead: Clementine is the Protagonist Season Three" sounds like something the mods would use, not someone who has an opinion on the forums. Also, how am I being smug in the slightest? I never said I wanted Clementine to be the protagonist, it just makes sense to keep with her story since it started with her.
Believe me you are not alone. Their are quite a few of us on this forum that don't want clementine as the protagonist of S3 and I am one of … morethem. I couldn't stand Clementine in season 2, she was overpowered, boring, and I felt no emotional connection to her in season 2 like I did in season 1.
Ok? If you don't agree with me well then let me fail.
I just don't understand "an argument will occur" thing. If everyone is grounded and knows how to express their opinion, no argument will occur. I know different threads have had this thing (Jane vs Kenny).
An opinion is an opinion. It's no different than people saying "Lee should not have been killed". It's never going to happen, yet it's an op… moreinion.
Yeah, but there's not thousands of threads about it and it's not springing up any vicious arguments like these type of threads have. Besides, what's done is done. Telltale hasn't confirmed anything about their protagonist for Season 3.
You just said I am acting like ttg is going to listen. The gun example is just how you are making it look like I am "demanding" ttg to do what I say.
That's... not how that type of stuff works. At all. Acting like their listening and MAKING them listen to/do what you want, id completely different.
By this theory, No opinionated threads or posts should be allowed on the forum at all, due to an argument arising.
No, by my theory, you should stop beating the dead horse that's just going to make a shitstorm. Just like the Kenny vs Jane crap.
That's not the point. It's fun to have debates and share opinions, but it's not fun to argue and repeat the same thing half of the community already has.
I don't agree with Clementine being season 3 protagonist
OP makes it sound like they announced the news. Titling it "The Walking Dea… mored: Clementine is the Protagonist Season Three" sounds like something the mods would use, not someone who has an opinion on the forums. Also, how am I being smug in the slightest? I never said I wanted Clementine to be the protagonist, it just makes sense to keep with her story since it started with her.
If you left with Kenny, what sort of adventures will they discover? What will get Kenny killed, what will happen to Clem and AJ, who may they meet?
I think there's alot of Clem's story to tell, there's what? 5 different possible beginnings, 5 different directions to take Clem til they all merge into one finale.
I think all of the beginnings, no matter what, must merge into one beginning, maybe the same situation, just with either Jane/Kenny.
I want Clem as the playable character in S3. I left her and Jane together with AJ in Howes and here is so much that can happen. Will that family I turned away return and try to take Howes? Will another herd of walkers pass through? Will a group of bandit's happen by? There's nearly unlimited possibilities of what could happen to keep Clem's story going.. And about those who took Clem to Wellington.. What could happen inside there? Will it fall from a group outside? Will it fall from within? Is Lily the leader inside? Could it be like Woodbury? there's almost unlimited directions of where TTG could take Clem's story and no need for any time skip's.
If they do go with Clem being protagonist, interesting things could POSSIBLY happen. I'd just hate for the story line to come up repetitive.
One of the other things people wouldnt want clem to be s3 protagonist is b/c of the perspective in clem's shoes. SHe most likely won't have a lot of group leadership, and due to her age the interactions are very "basic".
But you do make a point. ttg still has many possibilities to take with clem.
I want Clem as the playable character in S3. I left her and Jane together with AJ in Howes and here is so much that can happen. Will that … morefamily I turned away return and try to take Howes? Will another herd of walkers pass through? Will a group of bandit's happen by? There's nearly unlimited possibilities of what could happen to keep Clem's story going.. And about those who took Clem to Wellington.. What could happen inside there? Will it fall from a group outside? Will it fall from within? Is Lily the leader inside? Could it be like Woodbury? there's almost unlimited directions of where TTG could take Clem's story and no need for any time skip's.
If you left with Kenny, what sort of adventures will they discover? What will get Kenny killed, what will happen to Clem and AJ, who may they meet?
I think there's alot of Clem's story to tell, there's what? 5 different possible beginnings, 5 different directions to take Clem til th… [view original content]
I don't care who the protagonist is as long as I still enjoy the game like I did both seasons. If i don't like something, anything about a game, I won't buy it. You morons should follow suit. What puts you in a position to say how a game "should be" made. Are you a developer, fan, or non-fan? Know your role.
You morons should follow suit. What puts you in a position to say how a game "should be" made. Are you a developer, fan, or non-fan? Know your role.
85 Comments
1.1 R-E-S-P-E-C-T! We're all here to have fun, so be cool to each other. Always behave respectfully towards other community members, moderators and Telltale team members. Insults, hate speech, platform wars… leave it out. Constructive criticism of another user's opinions or actions is OK, but refrain from insulting users/volunteer moderators/Telltale staff members themselves - whether directly or in passing. If you feel especially slighted by another forum member, use the "Flag" button to report their comments to moderators instead of shooting back!
I don't care who the protagonist is as long as I still enjoy the game like I did both seasons. If i don't like something, anything about a g… moreame, I won't buy it. You morons should follow suit. What puts you in a position to say how a game "should be" made. Are you a developer, fan, or non-fan? Know your role.
Comments
Or, you could start with a character we have some background info on (400 days characters).
I'd agree with you 100% about seeing her story from the eyes of another character but not anymore. Not after Lee died. After we lost him in Season 1, I don't think that any adult character would replace him as protagonist. At least not new character, though Telltale won't chose any known character from previous seasons. There is almost no one left. Everyone's dead, determinant or their fate is unknown. In other words, I think it's a choice between Clementine or some new character introduced in Season 3 and I don't want to play as some stranger.
I was thinking that one of the 400 Days characters could possibly be a protagonist, yet she would still be able to include in the story. After all, they never really explored any of the 400 days characters except Bonnie (who is meh.)
That's what I was thinking too. Out of a 1-10, s1 was a 9.6 to me and s2 was a 6.1. Writers can make or break a game.
I don't think that they will use 400 Days characters because they also are determinant. They can be in Carver's camp or they can be somewhere else. In other words, we can meet them in Season 2 and there is also an option that we won't. At least not all of them and because of that I don't believe that 400 days characters could be used as protagonists again.
Though... hm. Maybe there is a chance, I don't know but if there is then I'd see either Shel or Vince as protagonist. I really like them.
I like all of the 400 days characters except Bithecca.
That is true. That's why I was saying they should have introduced more of the 400 Days characters instead of just Bonnie.They only made cameos.
She needs redemption story arc, she'd make a great anti-hero if you ask me
Oh, yeah. I didn't understand it seems. In that case, I totally agree with you. They should've done something more then just cameos for this characters. They deserved better than this but what's done is done. We can't change that. Maybe there is a little chance that we might play as one of them as Season 3 protagonist? I mean, in Season 2 there is only one choice that matters about them - if they are in Carver's camp. This could be solved pretty easy by different backstory (which means, different dialogues). I'd still want to play as Clementine but if Telltale ever decide to chose another character, I hope it'll be someone from 400 Days group.
If they brought her back for a little while in s2, I would've had a different opinion. But now, im not sure. They missed a lot of opportunities in s2.
She should have came back instead of Kenny. His story seemed finished to me s1. His story in s2 was kinda the same, just revamped a bit.
I have no idea why they brought Kenny back either. He was really wearing out his welcome.
Who cares? Telltale are going to do their thing whether you want them to or not.
Am I the only one that just wants a good story? I don't care if Clementine is in Season 3 or not, just gimme a story with good writing and intrigue.
It's a goddamn opinion. I'm not holding a gun up to ttg and telling them to "do what i say". I'm giving my opinion and looking at other's opinions.
I didn't even say you did, wtf? What's the point of saying "I don't want Clem as the protagonist" or "I do" if either way your opinion won't have an impact on what telltale has planned to do for Season 3. The hell is even the point of these kind of threads anyway? It's unimpactful, and just bound to start arguments within the community.
Why even post threads then if you think TT doesn't listen? Even if they don't its fun to have debates and see other peoples opinions.
I want Clem as the playable character in S3. I left her and Jane together with AJ in Howes and here is so much that can happen. Will that family I turned away return and try to take Howes? Will another herd of walkers pass through? Will a group of bandit's happen by? There's nearly unlimited possibilities of what could happen to keep Clem's story going.. And about those who took Clem to Wellington.. What could happen inside there? Will it fall from a group outside? Will it fall from within? Is Lily the leader inside? Could it be like Woodbury? there's almost unlimited directions of where TTG could take Clem's story and no need for any time skip's.
If you left with Kenny, what sort of adventures will they discover? What will get Kenny killed, what will happen to Clem and AJ, who may they meet?
I think there's alot of Clem's story to tell, there's what? 5 different possible beginnings, 5 different directions to take Clem til they all merge into one finale.
I think the Michonne 3-part mini series will be just extra content, something we'll all just enjoy while waiting for Season 3. I doubt and hope that this will have nothing to do with Clementine. It's just extra and I can't wait for it!
You just answered your own question. It's fun to see other's opinions.
An opinion is an opinion. It's no different than people saying "Lee should not have been killed". It's never going to happen, yet it's an opinion. If you don't like this thread, well then you don't have to post if you find no meaning in it.
You just said I am acting like ttg is going to listen. The gun example is just how you are making it look like I am "demanding" ttg to do what I say.
By this theory, No opinionated threads or posts should be allowed on the forum at all, due to an argument arising.
I think that many people are associating whether or not Clem is in the game with whether or not the game will have a good story
Wait, did they confirm Clem as season 3 protagonist?
That's not the point. It's fun to have debates and share opinions, but it's not fun to argue and repeat the same thing half of the community already has.
Yeah, but there's not thousands of threads about it and it's not springing up any vicious arguments like these type of threads have. Besides, what's done is done. Telltale hasn't confirmed anything about their protagonist for Season 3.
That's... not how that type of stuff works. At all. Acting like their listening and MAKING them listen to/do what you want, id completely different.
No, by my theory, you should stop beating the dead horse that's just going to make a shitstorm. Just like the Kenny vs Jane crap.
Before "Long Road Ahead" got released, there were theories on the internet how there would be more characters from Ben's summer camp appearing, and how they might be future protagonists (they would've worked like Tales FB)... or how those two shadowy figures in the distance from "No Time Left" how one of them would be OC and a protagonist...
I would've preferred one of these TBH...
Oh, the title had me thinking that telltale confirmed her.
And don't get too smug, Clementine is almost certainly going to be the protagonist, if not that then dual protagonist.
OP makes it sound like they announced the news. Titling it "The Walking Dead: Clementine is the Protagonist Season Three" sounds like something the mods would use, not someone who has an opinion on the forums. Also, how am I being smug in the slightest? I never said I wanted Clementine to be the protagonist, it just makes sense to keep with her story since it started with her.
I actually wouldn't mind playing Kenny's story before he met up with Clementine again.
She always has been boring.
BECAUSE SHE'S CLEMENTINE OMG CLEM4LYFE LOL CLEMMY CLEM CLEM CLEM CLEM CLEM CLEm
Ok? If you don't agree with me well then let me fail.
I just don't understand "an argument will occur" thing. If everyone is grounded and knows how to express their opinion, no argument will occur. I know different threads have had this thing (Jane vs Kenny).
ARGUE? Lol there were no arguments in this thread?
That's the biggest possibility, sadly.
Bad wording on my part. I already know that the odds are against my wishes.
That'd make an interesting dlc.
I think all of the beginnings, no matter what, must merge into one beginning, maybe the same situation, just with either Jane/Kenny.
If they do go with Clem being protagonist, interesting things could POSSIBLY happen. I'd just hate for the story line to come up repetitive.
One of the other things people wouldnt want clem to be s3 protagonist is b/c of the perspective in clem's shoes. SHe most likely won't have a lot of group leadership, and due to her age the interactions are very "basic".
But you do make a point. ttg still has many possibilities to take with clem.
The amount of people that hate Kenny would make that impossible tbh
hmmm true
Agreed. Clem is a terrible protagonist.
You just have my mind. I too want a well written story.
I don't care who the protagonist is as long as I still enjoy the game like I did both seasons. If i don't like something, anything about a game, I won't buy it. You morons should follow suit. What puts you in a position to say how a game "should be" made. Are you a developer, fan, or non-fan? Know your role.