Do you mean to say that Kenny didn't go with you to search for Clementine? If so, I know precisely how you feel. I felt so betrayed by Kenny- I did everything to support him and his family.
leaving clem at the mansion .... on reflection it was a dumb ass move!...
Not leaving with Kenny..... the mans speech just crippled me...… more.. dammit Kenny!!!
My biggest regreat bar none is not shooting lee.... it haunts me to this very day!!... walker lee cuffed to that radiator!...
everything else I was happy with..
But I understand completely why you did both of those things. Regardless of what could have worked out for the greater good, I don't believe anything at all would have been worth putting blood on my Clementine's hands (Kenny doesn't count as a murder; it was more like euthanasia at that point).
Shooting Kenny. I rationalized in my mind that I couldn't let Jane die. Even if she did orchestrate the whole thing just to prove her point,… more Kenny had reached his breaking point and a part of me realized Aj and Clem may not be safe around him anymore after that. But I decided to take a look at the endings where you let Kenny kill Jane and the raw emotion in them after she dies is just so heartbreaking...I found myself wanting more interaction with Kenny afterwards--I wanted to talk with him and not Jane, how was I sure she wouldn't leave me again when times get tough? I maintained a close friendship with Kenny as Lee in Season 1, so I think a part of me feels obligated to see Kenny as family, or at least see a small part of Lee in him.
And as bad as it may sound, I regret saving Sarah in the trailers, especially when she just dies in the next episode after all the motivational talking and convincing you did to her.
I feel like I'm the only person who hasn't come to regret leaving Lily behind. She MURDERED an innocent person (in my playthrough it was the darling Doug) in front of a CHILD. There are lines we must not cross and that was patently one of them.
Waiting so long to buy this amazing game. I try not to play with regrets, I was doing what I thought was right the 1st time I played. But if I had to say one it would be being nice to that bitch Jane. I was really hoping for a Kenny/Luke decision, but alas it didn't go that way. I was friendly to Jane pretty much the whole time but when I found out what she did to the baby after I killed Kenny, I was so pissed she was completely done in my eyes. I don't regret killing Kenny, I feel like with my game he had run his course and needed to go be with Katjaa and Duck again. I walked away from Jane and never looked back!
I felt that Doug actually was a very important. I know they killed him off fairly soon but he did have an extremely distinct and unique personality for us (in the minority) who saved him. Moreover, he did die a heroic death which I was pleased with. Personally speaking, I felt close to his character and that's why I did not deliberate before leaving Lily.
IIn terms of what I chose : none but I do regret things that you had no control over
* going to he dairy, wish there was a way lee coul… mored stay and then find out he would have to save the group.
* having Doug being a more important character.
* Shooting Danny in the woods would've been good
* being able to leave both christa and omid from getting on the train
* saving chuck
* Ben didn't fall off the balcony
Did you have the same mindset as me and think that if you took the watch someone would accuse Clementine of stealing thus stirring up some melodramatic bullshit within the cabin?
Curiosity asking: why did you not accept Nick's apology? At that point, were the whole group just rubbing you up the wrong way like they did with most people?
Stealing from the Stranger.
Leaving Clem at the mansion. It's actually a pretty stupid thing to do, if you think about it. Some guy (who … moreended up taking Clem later on) is following us and knows where we are because we saw him by the gate. With a very sick Omid and just Clem (especially if you don't give her the gun) at the mansion he easily could've taken her right then and there. At least I was smart enough to give her the gun. :P With Clem in Crawford you can at least keep an eye on her and know what's happening to her all the time.
Not accepting Nick's apology.
Not hugging Kenny when we first saw him. I chose "I thought you were dead" because that's what it was in the preview for the episode and I wanted to see how Clem actually ended up saying it. I hugged him in episode 3, though.
They made doug based on a guy who works or worked at telltale didn't they? Seemed they just did a homage to the guy hence why Carley is more important then doug which I found stupid because if people pick doug rather then Carley, you can't tell the group about your past and thus losing trust with certain characters .
I felt that Doug actually was a very important. I know they killed him off fairly soon but he did have an extremely distinct and unique pers… moreonality for us (in the minority) who saved him. Moreover, he did die a heroic death which I was pleased with. Personally speaking, I felt close to his character and that's why I did not deliberate before leaving Lily.
Yeah, I will admit that I find it a shame that choosing Doug deprived us of the chance to confess what we did. Mind you, it doesn't eat away at me because- let's be honest- I probably would have kept it to myself anyway.
They made doug based on a guy who works or worked at telltale didn't they? Seemed they just did a homage to the guy hence why Carley is more… more important then doug which I found stupid because if people pick doug rather then Carley, you can't tell the group about your past and thus losing trust with certain characters .
It only annoys me because I like to be honest and I liked doug but if you pick him then obviously lily will tell and then everyone will be on your back for not being truthful. Just annoying.
Yeah, I will admit that I find it a shame that choosing Doug deprived us of the chance to confess what we did. Mind you, it doesn't eat away at me because- let's be honest- I probably would have kept it to myself anyway.
Biggest regret was not being able to kill Kenny in season 1. What a waste of flesh...hell I would love to have seen him become a walker jus… moret for the pleasant thought that he would screw whatever herd he joined just like he screwed the group up. There is not one single redeeming quality of that shithill that even makes me question this regret.31
I regretted leaving Nick's watch from Pete at the cabin during my first playthrough, and regretted not being nicer to Sarah at first on that same file. And Rebecca, to be completely honest. Luckily, on this replay I fixed those mistakes.
I also was super upset when I realized what significance the 400 days characters played in Season Two. I'm glad that my two favorites, Vince and Russell, didn't go with Tavia this time.
I didn't accept it because I told myself I wouldn't trust anyone except for people Clem already knew and/or people I liked that somehow returned. I didn't want Clem to let her guard down and look weak... I mean, he did almost kill Clem, too, and that's not cool.
Curiosity asking: why did you not accept Nick's apology? At that point, were the whole group just rubbing you up the wrong way like they did with most people?
Not stopping Kenny from killing Jane. I didn't like her a whole lot, but when I saw AJ in that car I could not stop crying on her behalf. I was still with Kenny in the end, though. Couldn't let go.
Shooting Kenny is my biggest Season 2 regret. It was a heat-of-the-moment thing, but what followed made me feel sick. Especially Clementine tearfully telling Jane she forgives her. Jane, the woman who manipulated her and forced her into a situation where she'd have to let SOMEONE die, AND left a baby somewhere in the freezing snow JUST to prove a point!
Kenny's mind wasn't what it used to be, yes, but I know he cared for Clem and AJ more than Jane did. He lashed out at her once, yes, because he was in grief over Sarita's death, but if you make the right dialogue options you can get him out of his depression without yelling at him, and he'll apologize for that and pull himself together. He was viciously beaten by Carver, taking the blame for the theft of the radio. I don't think Jane would have done something like that. Jane has good traits, I know, but what she did at the end of episode 5 just makes me unable to forgive her in my mind.
When I do a replay of season 2, I'll definitely NOT be choosing her.
Shooting Kenny is my biggest Season 2 regret. It was a heat-of-the-moment thing, but what followed made me feel sick. Especially Clementine … moretearfully telling Jane she forgives her. Jane, the woman who manipulated her and forced her into a situation where she'd have to let SOMEONE die, AND left a baby somewhere in the freezing snow JUST to prove a point!
Kenny's mind wasn't what it used to be, yes, but I know he cared for Clem and AJ more than Jane did. He lashed out at her once, yes, because he was in grief over Sarita's death, but if you make the right dialogue options you can get him out of his depression without yelling at him, and he'll apologize for that and pull himself together. He was viciously beaten by Carver, taking the blame for the theft of the radio. I don't think Jane would have done something like that. Jane has good traits, I know, but what she did at the end of episode 5 just makes me unable to forgive her in my mind.
When I do a replay of season 2, I'll definitely NOT be choosing her.
Comments
Do you mean to say that Kenny didn't go with you to search for Clementine? If so, I know precisely how you feel. I felt so betrayed by Kenny- I did everything to support him and his family.
Haha! Yeah, the dude was crazy. Everything in the entire world provoked him.
But I understand completely why you did both of those things. Regardless of what could have worked out for the greater good, I don't believe anything at all would have been worth putting blood on my Clementine's hands (Kenny doesn't count as a murder; it was more like euthanasia at that point).
I feel like I'm the only person who hasn't come to regret leaving Lily behind. She MURDERED an innocent person (in my playthrough it was the darling Doug) in front of a CHILD. There are lines we must not cross and that was patently one of them.
I did the same thing what with Lily... hey, she was a very sympathetic character before she went and murdered someone!
Yeah, well, I think we all regretted bringing our lovely characters to that hell-hole of a camp once we got to meet Carver.
Waiting so long to buy this amazing game. I try not to play with regrets, I was doing what I thought was right the 1st time I played. But if I had to say one it would be being nice to that bitch Jane. I was really hoping for a Kenny/Luke decision, but alas it didn't go that way. I was friendly to Jane pretty much the whole time but when I found out what she did to the baby after I killed Kenny, I was so pissed she was completely done in my eyes. I don't regret killing Kenny, I feel like with my game he had run his course and needed to go be with Katjaa and Duck again. I walked away from Jane and never looked back!
I felt that Doug actually was a very important. I know they killed him off fairly soon but he did have an extremely distinct and unique personality for us (in the minority) who saved him. Moreover, he did die a heroic death which I was pleased with. Personally speaking, I felt close to his character and that's why I did not deliberate before leaving Lily.
Haha! I remember thinking 'A watch? The hell would I need that for when my arm is hemorrhaging?'
We all were.
Curiosity asking: why did you not accept Nick's apology? At that point, were the whole group just rubbing you up the wrong way like they did with most people?
They made doug based on a guy who works or worked at telltale didn't they? Seemed they just did a homage to the guy hence why Carley is more important then doug which I found stupid because if people pick doug rather then Carley, you can't tell the group about your past and thus losing trust with certain characters .
Yeah, I will admit that I find it a shame that choosing Doug deprived us of the chance to confess what we did. Mind you, it doesn't eat away at me because- let's be honest- I probably would have kept it to myself anyway.
It only annoys me because I like to be honest and I liked doug but if you pick him then obviously lily will tell and then everyone will be on your back for not being truthful. Just annoying.
I have one regret not shooting that harry potter duch avro
Cutting off Lee's arm.
looks like I have a new word to include in my vocabulary
Getting Alvin killed. I felt awful. I probably have more i just forgot.
But now i can just make more files, or just rewind.
I regretted leaving Nick's watch from Pete at the cabin during my first playthrough, and regretted not being nicer to Sarah at first on that same file. And Rebecca, to be completely honest. Luckily, on this replay I fixed those mistakes.
I also was super upset when I realized what significance the 400 days characters played in Season Two. I'm glad that my two favorites, Vince and Russell, didn't go with Tavia this time.
Purchasing Season Two.
Dammit read older comments and somebody already beat me to saying that, meh, I tried..
I didn't accept it because I told myself I wouldn't trust anyone except for people Clem already knew and/or people I liked that somehow returned. I didn't want Clem to let her guard down and look weak... I mean, he did almost kill Clem, too, and that's not cool.
Not stopping Kenny from killing Jane. I didn't like her a whole lot, but when I saw AJ in that car I could not stop crying on her behalf. I was still with Kenny in the end, though. Couldn't let go.
She tried to manipulate you to kill Kenny
There's worse things to spend $25 on
A lot of worse things
You could have ordered an expensive lobster meal, but then realized you don't like lobster
You could have ordered a bunch of pizzas, only to realize you got the wrong topping that you hate
You could have bought that six-pack of those totally legit energy drinks from that shady looking guy in the alley
Except that makes no sense. She was trying to get you to realise that you should leave Kenny. She did not think you would have to kill him.
Jane is the one who caused him to go crazy in the first place.
Slapping Sarah b/c then she lives.
Letting Ben die (Kenny forced me to)
Leaving Sarah (Jane forced me to)
You can say fuck both of them right?
Riiiight.
I mean Kenny and Jane
Shooting Kenny is my biggest Season 2 regret. It was a heat-of-the-moment thing, but what followed made me feel sick. Especially Clementine tearfully telling Jane she forgives her. Jane, the woman who manipulated her and forced her into a situation where she'd have to let SOMEONE die, AND left a baby somewhere in the freezing snow JUST to prove a point!
Kenny's mind wasn't what it used to be, yes, but I know he cared for Clem and AJ more than Jane did. He lashed out at her once, yes, because he was in grief over Sarita's death, but if you make the right dialogue options you can get him out of his depression without yelling at him, and he'll apologize for that and pull himself together. He was viciously beaten by Carver, taking the blame for the theft of the radio. I don't think Jane would have done something like that. Jane has good traits, I know, but what she did at the end of episode 5 just makes me unable to forgive her in my mind.
When I do a replay of season 2, I'll definitely NOT be choosing her.
I know
Cool
doesn't matter, I didn't steal and they come after you anyway.
I got Alvin killed. Had trouble understanding what was going on and what the choices were. The game was going
too fast.