Would you had wanted to stay at the St. John Dairy if you knew they were cannibals?
Even though they were cannibals would you had wanted to stay at the St. John Dairy just for safety? I mean the St. Johns didn't start showing their true colors until Kenny started to be a nosey busy-body.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
You seem to have forgotten that they chopped off Marks legs and fed them to the group. This is really reaching if you're trying to find another way to hate on Kenny.
And to answer your question. No. God no.
So. You're asking us if we'd stay there and get eaten. Nope.
I we could've killed them and took it.
I'm glad Kenny got nosy or else we might not have figured out what they were up to. Regardless, the St. Johns were going to kill and feed Mark to us. So, no, under no circumstances would I have stayed with those nutcases. I like the skin on my bones.
They were planning on killing most of us off anyways
Andy turning on the fence wasn't an accident; he was hoping it'd kill Mark and Lee so two of the group's muscle would be gone. He was forced to play along when that didn't work, and Mark became an opportunity since he was shot.
Yeah. Getting eaten by cannibals would have been a good way to end the game.
Yes. I love being in the presence of psychopaths who eat people on a regular basis. Seriously, what kind of a question is that?
I'm a Saltlick so they couldn't eat me
Absolutely not.
As soon as Mark was attacked by bandits, I agreed with Lilly about leaving the place as soon as possible. I had figured that the barn folks were not keeping up with giving them food to keep them off their backs, and that was long before I figured that they were cannibals.
I never trusted it from the get-go and as soon as they handed me the biscuits, I wanted to leave.
Uhhh...no.
Safety? Lmao, the St Johns were likely going to murder the whole group eventually if they had their way. This had nothing to do with Kenny being nosey.
True, i agree with you. If you think back to the walk to the farm, you can see them grilling lee for information about their numbers, how many guns they have, etc.
The fence turning on was the biggest sign that they were going to eat them. What's the use of the farm when the zombies are going to raid in.
This thread is definitely just an opportunity to get a snide remark in for Kenny, I can feel it. I hate to bring it up but I'm 99% sure you sided with Jane in Season Two. Kenny being nosey potentially saved the rest of the groups lives, you pretty much can't deny that. They were cannibals either way, since they didn't know Kenny was sneaking around, how could that change whether they were cannibals or not?
"Someones sneaking around. Lets become cannibals." Logic???
I also don't believe they could face the trauma of staying at the dairy (after the cannibalism), it'd be too much for everyone even if it is a safe spot. Plus...the bandits were still there.
Maybe, if we banish 'em.
Well we're still in the company of cannibals who likely lured us into a trap anyway. We outnumbered them I would have taken the dairy and left once I finished raiding it. The bandits we're still going to come calling
Andy tried to get lee and mark killed before kenny got to the farm by turning the fences on when they were scouting the perimeter, this is evident by Andy saying he heard them yell and thought he was giving them the all clear to turn the fences on yet mark yells when he is shot with an arrow AFTER the fences are put back on. And no I wouldn't want to be on the farm because if rations went small, who do you think they would try to eat?
Larry took your challenge and...you know what happened
Damn right I do, I was the one that killed him....
I got the idea by your name
If you ever meet Saltlick305, he's the one Clem licked, he's really busy and stuff so you probably won't see him...
Nope. Never saw him. And you're like, a SALTLICK family
First, I agree with what chilled said, if Kenny hadn´t made Lee open that door he wouldn´t have been suspiciously enough to find Mark, and the gruop would be separated at the night.
And further - when should we´ve stay there ?
Defenitley not in the cold store, and later the whole place was stormed by the walkers.
We should have eliminated the St.Johns and then keep the dairy...but we haven´t know what they are early enough, so there wasn´t the choice to stay there.
If I knew? I would have Lilly snipe them from afar, so I could raid them.
farms are the worst; there's no protection from gunfights and it's too open