That'd be an awesome Idea. But if they do that, I hope They do a TFTBL/GoT type thing Where you switch Between playing as Clem, AJ, and Maybe Jane/Kenny if you saved one of them, and if not, then just Clem and AJ.
Clementine was fine in hours.
Kenny took a whole episode to get better , wait time between E2- E3
Clementine is a little girl who has less blood than Kenny, but she is fine without medical attention?? We can assume that after they got back to the Motel Kenny got treated, because they had medicine at that time.
Yeah, the shoulder gunshot wound is a Hollywood cliche, it's actually one of the worst places to get shot, but if we're gonna talk cliches even the first season is full of them.
Its so bullshit, if you don't die from the bullet, you would die from infection.
Kenny took a rifle shot to the gut at point blank range in Season 1 and the only effect seems to be that it made it impossible for him to pu… morell anyone up for the rest of the game.
Mike took a shot in the arm in they never mentioned again too, now that I think about it.
Yeah, the shoulder gunshot wound is a Hollywood cliche, it's actually one of the worst places to get shot, but if we're gonna talk cliches even the first season is full of them.
Hm back to the theoretic start and contain of S3;
I would be glad if clem would be 15 or like that - but that would be ca 3,5 years later then S2 and I have less hope that clem have this age when we, I guess, play her in S3.
With the greater number of possible ends the number of potentially protagonists shrink, Kenny,Jane are out, Bonnie and Mike aren´t probably populary enough (and clem won´t accept them in her group I think), AJ is too young, there are little chances for Christa having survived.
From 400 Days we could use Shel and Becca (interesting relationship granted), Wyatt (probably not able to take care on a child), Vince just as a Shane-like part in a group and Russel (seemed to be the best choice because he was quite "normal").
I think it could be possible, that we play Lilly (maybe during one episode, or maybe just in a kind of addon): She tries to survive like all do while she is followed by what she´ve done in the past - I said it in the Lilly-theme, on my mind, Lilly and Kenny are very similar characters, so when Clem get a kind of "family-status" for Lilly, she would take care for her I guess
I like this idea,specially the 16 months alone with christa seemed to haven´t meant much for her...- it would be interesting to see what they´ve done during their journey.
They mentioned when she woke up that it was a through-and-through. You can see the blood from the exit wound on the back of her shoulder, can't you?
She was shot with what looked like a .22 long rifle. In real life, the real danger with a GSW from a .22 is that they tend to bounce around inside the body and tear things up. If it went straight through her and didn't hit anything important it's not beyond the realm of possibility. The infection from having the bullet inside you is what kills you.
Well lets take a look here.
Clementine was fine in hours.
Kenny took a whole episode to get better , wait time between E2- E3
Clemen… moretine is a little girl who has less blood than Kenny, but she is fine without medical attention?? We can assume that after they got back to the Motel Kenny got treated, because they had medicine at that time.
Yeah, the shoulder gunshot wound is a Hollywood cliche, it's actually one of the worst places to get shot, but if we're gonna talk cliches even the first season is full of them.
Its so bullshit, if you don't die from the bullet, you would die from infection.
That'd be an awesome Idea. But if they do that, I hope They do a TFTBL/GoT type thing Where you switch Between playing as Clem, AJ, and Maybe Jane/Kenny if you saved one of them, and if not, then just Clem and AJ.
Probably gonna get me a lot of hate, but I'm sick of Clementine. I want a fresh story, new characters. Playing as a kid has its' limitations, and I think her story ended well.
Probably gonna get me a lot of hate, but I'm sick of Clementine. I want a fresh story, new characters. Playing as a kid has its' limitations, and I think her story ended well.
Maybe.
ut that is the reason for me wanting clem 15, then she can handle the most alone - like carl.
The time would be good for a new story - but leaving all previous characters behind - maybe the plan to make clem to a NPC again isn´t the worst, so we can play another, like Lilly,Shel,Becca,Vince,Russel,Wyatt,Molly, supported by clem and a new group.
I am with you as well. I want a new story with Eddie maybe, or someone else. I feel like Clementine's story is complete, she made it to safety. I would rather have Season 3 more like Wyatt and Eddie's story. A fun story, without all that emotional baggage.
Probably gonna get me a lot of hate, but I'm sick of Clementine. I want a fresh story, new characters. Playing as a kid has its' limitations, and I think her story ended well.
I am with you as well. I want a new story with Eddie maybe, or someone else. I feel like Clementine's story is complete, she made it to saf… moreety. I would rather have Season 3 more like Wyatt and Eddie's story. A fun story, without all that emotional baggage.
What do you mean "What personality did she have in s2?" and "no personality" ? You as the player form her personality.
You can play a kin… mored, thoughtful and hopeful Clem, who hasn't changed that much and still sees the good in every one.
Or a emotionally hardened, but still hopeful sassy Clem, who can be very sarcastic. But who is still helpful and compassionate, and will help those that can be helped.
Or even a complete Jerk Clem, who does everything she can do ensure her own survival, including Blackmailing, Killing and letting die people that are a burden. And in general, being a very mean person.
Also, what to you mean with " no emotions really. Just a spectator"? Crying, screaming, being angry and/or scared are no emotions? And she is, or can be played, as much mire than a spectator. In fact, one of the most often criticized aspect of Season 2 is how much and how often the adults let Clem do dangerous things even though she is … [view original content]
Well lets take a look here.
Clementine was fine in hours.
Kenny took a whole episode to get better , wait time between E2- E3
Clemen… moretine is a little girl who has less blood than Kenny, but she is fine without medical attention?? We can assume that after they got back to the Motel Kenny got treated, because they had medicine at that time.
Yeah, the shoulder gunshot wound is a Hollywood cliche, it's actually one of the worst places to get shot, but if we're gonna talk cliches even the first season is full of them.
Its so bullshit, if you don't die from the bullet, you would die from infection.
"Clem is going to be the protgaonist in S3 [...] which isn't very good, at least to the majority."
And you are even doing it AGAIN. How can you say that the majority would agree with you? Okay then, prove it. Link me to threads where most say that they don't want Clem as Protagonist in S3, or some poll on this Forum. As long as you don't, or can't, do that, you can't speak for the majority. Hell, even then you couldn't, because the majority of players don't write and are active here on this Forum.
And one other thing, I don't think you can speak for the majority.
When did I say this? I said I thought she didnt have a personali… morety, tf?
On this board, the majority would agree Clem being the s3 protagonist is a fail. Maybe not on twitter,facebook,instagram or whatever.
Well, she didn't make it to safety in most Endings. In fact, the only Ending where you could say she might be safe, is the "Leave Kenny for Wellington" Ending. My "canon" ending is either stay with Jane and let the family in, where it is not clear whether the Family is dangerous or not, seeing the weapon of the Guy, or Clem and AJ alone, which is by far the unsafest of them all. And letting those Endings unresolved would be terrible for us who didn't went for the safest Ending. And making Clem a secondary character wouldn't work, because each player has a different Clem, personality-wise. And killing her off would be stupid too, because then everything we did in Season 1 and 2 would have been worthless.
And if you want a fun story without emotional "baggage", you've got TftB. This is the Walking Dead. A series known for being brutal and cruel. Even if Telltale would want that, which I am 100% sure they wouldn't, Kirkman would never allow that. It would make as much sense as making a Sonic/Mario/Kirby Horror game.
I am with you as well. I want a new story with Eddie maybe, or someone else. I feel like Clementine's story is complete, she made it to saf… moreety. I would rather have Season 3 more like Wyatt and Eddie's story. A fun story, without all that emotional baggage.
And if you want a fun story without emotional "baggage", you've got TftB. This is the Walking Dead.
There has to be a healthy balance, that's why Season 1 imo, worked better. If there is nothing but bad, the entire season, people get desensitized quick. I think if made season 3 like the Eddie/ Wyatt storyline, something like that, i'd be happy.
I haven't played borderlands yet or GOT, i'm waiting for them to be complete, before i get them. I can't wait to play them.
No, there doesn't. Have you ever read the Comics? You should, they are very good. And very popular and good-selling. And yet the Comics are even more bleak and dark than even Telltales Walking Dead. And neither Kirkman nor Telltale will change it. Because the Fans like it the way it is, or else it would either sell less or Kirkman would get many angry letters. We all know how passionate Comic Fans are, I do, I am one myself.
Fact is, luckily the Telltale Walking Dead Games are based on the Comics, and as long as the Comics don't take a turn towards (Dark) Comedy, the games won't. And seeing how The Walking Dead Series is about realistically (as much as possible) portraying Human Life in a Zombie Apocalypse, it won't.
And if you want a fun story without emotional "baggage", you've got TftB. This is the Walking Dead.
There has to be a healthy balanc… moree, that's why Season 1 imo, worked better. If there is nothing but bad, the entire season, people get desensitized quick. I think if made season 3 like the Eddie/ Wyatt storyline, something like that, i'd be happy.
I haven't played borderlands yet or GOT, i'm waiting for them to be complete, before i get them. I can't wait to play them.
Does it bother you that much that it could very well be the majority on THIS forum (Because we are talking about THIS forum) probably do not want Clem as an S3 protagonist?
Are you joking? Gonna quote YOU here:
"Clem is going to be the protgaonist in S3 [...] which isn't very good, at least to the majority."
… more
And you are even doing it AGAIN. How can you say that the majority would agree with you? Okay then, prove it. Link me to threads where most say that they don't want Clem as Protagonist in S3, or some poll on this Forum. As long as you don't, or can't, do that, you can't speak for the majority. Hell, even then you couldn't, because the majority of players don't write and are active here on this Forum.
But that's the whole point of The Walking Dead. It's not fun. It's grim and brutal and depressing. You take that away-that is, lives under great psychological pressure-you have nothing left.
I am with you as well. I want a new story with Eddie maybe, or someone else. I feel like Clementine's story is complete, she made it to saf… moreety. I would rather have Season 3 more like Wyatt and Eddie's story. A fun story, without all that emotional baggage.
The real problem is that they skipped a year and a half, which on the comics timeline jumps you from People Still Have Hope to Rick Is A Serial Killer And All Is Lost.
I honestly wouldn't be surprised to see the third season of the game have a "safe" camp for a good part of the season, to give you hope back before ripping your soul out.
And if you want a fun story without emotional "baggage", you've got TftB. This is the Walking Dead.
There has to be a healthy balanc… moree, that's why Season 1 imo, worked better. If there is nothing but bad, the entire season, people get desensitized quick. I think if made season 3 like the Eddie/ Wyatt storyline, something like that, i'd be happy.
I haven't played borderlands yet or GOT, i'm waiting for them to be complete, before i get them. I can't wait to play them.
I see Clementine (Whether PC or NPC) protecting and raising AJ like Lee did her. Only since he's a baby with no memory of his parents, she'd be able to tell him about them and protect him until he's old enough for gun training etc. Before it's over she'll be a big sister/parent figure to him... or AJ will die making Clem cold to the world.
We will not be AJ. If we are AJ i won't play this game. Clementine is the main character. Also in season 3 AJ will be 3, clementine will be 14. Thus we can't be AJ.
I'd love Christa to be in it somewhere (Or in the least a play through of what happened to her after she and Clem seperated... and a flashback of where her baby went... the 'now I'm pregnant, now I'm not' is driving me insane! ...... MAYBE Molly return but I dunno, she'd have to like leave Savannah.... Arvo, Bonnie and Mike (if Bonnie and Mike are alive in your game) Be antagonists .... Ummm Lilly returning ... maybe leader of Wellington shocker? Older AJ (Like 2 or 3 years old)..... Clementine (As PC or NPC don't care as long as she's somewhere there) .... Kenny/Jane (depending on your season 2 choices) .... Love the 400 days characters to return, they didn't make as much impact on Season 2 as I'd liked .... so I'd love them to be in Season 3 ... Maybe even see more of the new family (if you chose Jane path and let the strangers in)......Maybe older Clem starts deleving into 'adult feelings' with someone around her age .... or has issues with adults cause of being a 'kid with a baby' cause no one realizes the circumstances and assumes he's her's (Like the dad in the jane ending asks Clementine "Cute baby. Is he yours?")
I'm more interested in how they time skipped a whole year (16 months) and bypassed Christa's pregnancy with no conversation options, mentions, or plot for her baby's fate! Why even mention/show her as pregnant to begin with and just toss it???
I wouldn't say she 'made it to safety' .... If she stayed in Wellington, she's safe .... if she went with Kenny, their fate is unknown .... if she went with Jane, they're safe for a while ... if she accepted the strangers into her group with Jane, she may or may not be safe seeing as the dude has a gun..... and going solo? How is she safe walking through a horde with a baby...? All it'd take is AJ fussing once and they're dead ....
I am with you as well. I want a new story with Eddie maybe, or someone else. I feel like Clementine's story is complete, she made it to saf… moreety. I would rather have Season 3 more like Wyatt and Eddie's story. A fun story, without all that emotional baggage.
I see Clementine (Whether PC or NPC) protecting and raising AJ like Lee did her. Only since he's a baby with no memory of his parents, she'd… more be able to tell him about them and protect him until he's old enough for gun training etc. Before it's over she'll be a big sister/parent figure to him... or AJ will die making Clem cold to the world.
Comments
That'd be an awesome Idea. But if they do that, I hope They do a TFTBL/GoT type thing Where you switch Between playing as Clem, AJ, and Maybe Jane/Kenny if you saved one of them, and if not, then just Clem and AJ.
Well lets take a look here.
Clementine was fine in hours.
Kenny took a whole episode to get better , wait time between E2- E3
Clementine is a little girl who has less blood than Kenny, but she is fine without medical attention?? We can assume that after they got back to the Motel Kenny got treated, because they had medicine at that time.
Its so bullshit, if you don't die from the bullet, you would die from infection.
maybe the writers Ellie her, and make her the Golden Child.
SO ORIGINAL I LOVE IT.
Hm back to the theoretic start and contain of S3;
I would be glad if clem would be 15 or like that - but that would be ca 3,5 years later then S2 and I have less hope that clem have this age when we, I guess, play her in S3.
With the greater number of possible ends the number of potentially protagonists shrink, Kenny,Jane are out, Bonnie and Mike aren´t probably populary enough (and clem won´t accept them in her group I think), AJ is too young, there are little chances for Christa having survived.
From 400 Days we could use Shel and Becca (interesting relationship granted), Wyatt (probably not able to take care on a child), Vince just as a Shane-like part in a group and Russel (seemed to be the best choice because he was quite "normal").
I think it could be possible, that we play Lilly (maybe during one episode, or maybe just in a kind of addon): She tries to survive like all do while she is followed by what she´ve done in the past - I said it in the Lilly-theme, on my mind, Lilly and Kenny are very similar characters, so when Clem get a kind of "family-status" for Lilly, she would take care for her I guess
i just hope in s3 that we get a flashback on clems journey with christa and omid so we can find out after she found them at the end of season one
I like this idea,specially the 16 months alone with christa seemed to haven´t meant much for her...- it would be interesting to see what they´ve done during their journey.
They mentioned when she woke up that it was a through-and-through. You can see the blood from the exit wound on the back of her shoulder, can't you?
She was shot with what looked like a .22 long rifle. In real life, the real danger with a GSW from a .22 is that they tend to bounce around inside the body and tear things up. If it went straight through her and didn't hit anything important it's not beyond the realm of possibility. The infection from having the bullet inside you is what kills you.
I'd be on board with multiple POVs. In fact it would solve a lot of their narrative problems with having an eleven year old as the protagonist.
Probably gonna get me a lot of hate, but I'm sick of Clementine. I want a fresh story, new characters. Playing as a kid has its' limitations, and I think her story ended well.
I'm emotionally still attached to Clementine but I agree, it's time for a new character
Maybe.
ut that is the reason for me wanting clem 15, then she can handle the most alone - like carl.
The time would be good for a new story - but leaving all previous characters behind - maybe the plan to make clem to a NPC again isn´t the worst, so we can play another, like Lilly,Shel,Becca,Vince,Russel,Wyatt,Molly, supported by clem and a new group.
I am with you as well. I want a new story with Eddie maybe, or someone else. I feel like Clementine's story is complete, she made it to safety. I would rather have Season 3 more like Wyatt and Eddie's story. A fun story, without all that emotional baggage.
Agreed.
When did I say this? I said I thought she didnt have a personality, tf?
On this board, the majority would agree Clem being the s3 protagonist is a fail. Maybe not on twitter,facebook,instagram or whatever.
Amazingly, I actually agree with you. That was unrealistic af how she got shot in the shoulder and survived without medical attention.
Are you joking? Gonna quote YOU here:
"Clem is going to be the protgaonist in S3 [...] which isn't very good, at least to the majority."
And you are even doing it AGAIN. How can you say that the majority would agree with you? Okay then, prove it. Link me to threads where most say that they don't want Clem as Protagonist in S3, or some poll on this Forum. As long as you don't, or can't, do that, you can't speak for the majority. Hell, even then you couldn't, because the majority of players don't write and are active here on this Forum.
Well, she didn't make it to safety in most Endings. In fact, the only Ending where you could say she might be safe, is the "Leave Kenny for Wellington" Ending. My "canon" ending is either stay with Jane and let the family in, where it is not clear whether the Family is dangerous or not, seeing the weapon of the Guy, or Clem and AJ alone, which is by far the unsafest of them all. And letting those Endings unresolved would be terrible for us who didn't went for the safest Ending. And making Clem a secondary character wouldn't work, because each player has a different Clem, personality-wise. And killing her off would be stupid too, because then everything we did in Season 1 and 2 would have been worthless.
And if you want a fun story without emotional "baggage", you've got TftB. This is the Walking Dead. A series known for being brutal and cruel. Even if Telltale would want that, which I am 100% sure they wouldn't, Kirkman would never allow that. It would make as much sense as making a Sonic/Mario/Kirby Horror game.
Less emo shit, i don't bitch about my feelings, i keep all mine in like a man is supposed to., the feels just aren't working anymore IMO.
Maybe the antagonist for season 3 will be Jared from Subway.
There has to be a healthy balance, that's why Season 1 imo, worked better. If there is nothing but bad, the entire season, people get desensitized quick. I think if made season 3 like the Eddie/ Wyatt storyline, something like that, i'd be happy.
I haven't played borderlands yet or GOT, i'm waiting for them to be complete, before i get them. I can't wait to play them.
Poor Jared, he is so screwed in Prison.
No, there doesn't. Have you ever read the Comics? You should, they are very good. And very popular and good-selling. And yet the Comics are even more bleak and dark than even Telltales Walking Dead. And neither Kirkman nor Telltale will change it. Because the Fans like it the way it is, or else it would either sell less or Kirkman would get many angry letters. We all know how passionate Comic Fans are, I do, I am one myself.
Fact is, luckily the Telltale Walking Dead Games are based on the Comics, and as long as the Comics don't take a turn towards (Dark) Comedy, the games won't. And seeing how The Walking Dead Series is about realistically (as much as possible) portraying Human Life in a Zombie Apocalypse, it won't.
Who knows. Since he's famous he will probably get put in protected custody.
Does it bother you that much that it could very well be the majority on THIS forum (Because we are talking about THIS forum) probably do not want Clem as an S3 protagonist?
But that's the whole point of The Walking Dead. It's not fun. It's grim and brutal and depressing. You take that away-that is, lives under great psychological pressure-you have nothing left.
The real problem is that they skipped a year and a half, which on the comics timeline jumps you from People Still Have Hope to Rick Is A Serial Killer And All Is Lost.
I honestly wouldn't be surprised to see the third season of the game have a "safe" camp for a good part of the season, to give you hope back before ripping your soul out.
I see Clementine (Whether PC or NPC) protecting and raising AJ like Lee did her. Only since he's a baby with no memory of his parents, she'd be able to tell him about them and protect him until he's old enough for gun training etc. Before it's over she'll be a big sister/parent figure to him... or AJ will die making Clem cold to the world.
Now who's being unrealistic...?
Agreed.
I'd love Christa to be in it somewhere (Or in the least a play through of what happened to her after she and Clem seperated... and a flashback of where her baby went... the 'now I'm pregnant, now I'm not' is driving me insane! ...... MAYBE Molly return but I dunno, she'd have to like leave Savannah.... Arvo, Bonnie and Mike (if Bonnie and Mike are alive in your game) Be antagonists .... Ummm Lilly returning ... maybe leader of Wellington shocker? Older AJ (Like 2 or 3 years old)..... Clementine (As PC or NPC don't care as long as she's somewhere there) .... Kenny/Jane (depending on your season 2 choices) .... Love the 400 days characters to return, they didn't make as much impact on Season 2 as I'd liked .... so I'd love them to be in Season 3 ... Maybe even see more of the new family (if you chose Jane path and let the strangers in)......Maybe older Clem starts deleving into 'adult feelings' with someone around her age .... or has issues with adults cause of being a 'kid with a baby' cause no one realizes the circumstances and assumes he's her's (Like the dad in the jane ending asks Clementine "Cute baby. Is he yours?")
I'm more interested in how they time skipped a whole year (16 months) and bypassed Christa's pregnancy with no conversation options, mentions, or plot for her baby's fate! Why even mention/show her as pregnant to begin with and just toss it???
If they do a new character it'll HAVE to somehow tie in with season 1 and 2 in order for all those choices made to even be transfered over....
I wouldn't say she 'made it to safety' .... If she stayed in Wellington, she's safe .... if she went with Kenny, their fate is unknown .... if she went with Jane, they're safe for a while ... if she accepted the strangers into her group with Jane, she may or may not be safe seeing as the dude has a gun..... and going solo? How is she safe walking through a horde with a baby...? All it'd take is AJ fussing once and they're dead ....
Please don't bump old threads.
Thanks!