Don't want to be that guy...

This is a slight continuity thing. The shotgun model FN SLP Mk 1 in both S1 and S2. According to research, the zombie apocalypse takes place 2003 and down the line, but the SLP wasn't introduced until 2008. Anyway I can avoid overthinking this anachronism?

«1

Comments

  • Anyway I can avoid overthinking this anachronism?

    Pretend that they invented this shotgun in 2003 instead of 2008

  • I've never been one to get so serious about stuff like this, its just seems irrelevant. The game isnt a period piece so the stuff doesnt really matter

  • Allow me to blow your mind further, in Episode 1, Lee uses it as a pump action, when in real life it's semi-automatic.

  • It is confirmed. Read the wiki on the VG page.

  • I noticed.

    BigBlindMax posted: »

    Allow me to blow your mind further, in Episode 1, Lee uses it as a pump action, when in real life it's semi-automatic.

  • CrazyGeorgeCrazyGeorge Banned
    edited September 2015

    . Anyway I can avoid overthinking this anachronism?

    I don't see any weapon experts in the credits. Lets be honest here, TTG doesn't know shit about weapons. They think the AK -47 is just EVERYWHERE in america. In America everyone would be using AR -15s.

  • True, but various sporting goods stores do carry AK derivatives and AR derivatives as well.

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    . Anyway I can avoid overthinking this anachronism? I don't see any weapon experts in the credits. Lets be honest here, TTG doesn't

  • Which ones?

    I am surprised that they didn't even mention how to reload ammo, or anything else you would think people would be doing with their brass. To me, that should've been a no brainer at Carver's camp, and added in the story to make it a more believable experience.

    MaconMajr posted: »

    True, but various sporting goods stores do carry AK derivatives and AR derivatives as well.

  • BigBlindMaxBigBlindMax Banned
    edited September 2015

    As a gun enthusiast, I noticed that too. I love the windmill scene in S2E2 when Sarita starts firing her Winchester Model 70 in semi-auto.

    IRL AR-15's would be everywhere early on. Then, when 5.56mm ammo started to get scarce, they'd probably turn to guns like the Mosin Nagant and M1 Garand that have a huge civilian ammo surplus.

    I'd take an AK-47 derivative over an AR-15 any day though. Just feels better.

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    . Anyway I can avoid overthinking this anachronism? I don't see any weapon experts in the credits. Lets be honest here, TTG doesn't

  • I been to a Cabela's and seen some with my own eyes.

    And that last part I suppose, yeah.

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    Which ones? I am surprised that they didn't even mention how to reload ammo, or anything else you would think people would be doing with

  • Whatever strikes your fancy.

    But aren't Mosin Nagant's ammo no longer made?

    BigBlindMax posted: »

    As a gun enthusiast, I noticed that too. I love the windmill scene in S2E2 when Sarita starts firing her Winchester Model 70 in semi-auto.

  • Oh, 7.62 Russian is definitely still made in high quantity. Mosin Nagants have become very popular sporting rifles, since they're extremely cheap and fairly easy to maintain. Plus, it's impossible to overstate the ridiculously huge amounts of WWII surplus rifles and ammo that have been imported.

    MaconMajr posted: »

    Whatever strikes your fancy. But aren't Mosin Nagant's ammo no longer made?

  • edited September 2015

    According to research, the zombie apocalypse takes place 2003 and down the line

    What research? Telltale and Robert Kirkman have both said that the games take place in the same universe as the comics, and Kirkman said the following about the timeline:

    [The Walking Dead] is set in modern times...but the book started in 2003 and only a year has passed in the book. But that doesn't mean it's 2004 in the book...maybe it's 2009...who knows...who really cares? I don't want to be specific."

    So you can pretend it takes place in 2009 if you wish. But it shouldn't matter. The game (and comics) don't have to be super accurate. This is a zombie story after all.

  • He's getting at the fact that anyone can edit a wiki, that info is just fan theorizing that someone put on the page.

    AronDracula posted: »

    Then why is it there?

  • Honestly, I'd prefer a blunt weapon in a survival situation, since I don't see that good. But I'm a pretty damn good shot with a handgun, considering.

  • If the administators didn't agree with User's edit, the it wouldn't be there.

    Green613 posted: »

    He's getting at the fact that anyone can edit a wiki, that info is just fan theorizing that someone put on the page.

  • As if the administrators know everything.

    AronDracula posted: »

    If the administators didn't agree with User's edit, the it wouldn't be there.

  • Consider this all it's own universe if you will. Similar? Yes, but whatever fits to keep the story going.

  • I love the windmill scene in S2E2 when Sarita starts firing her Winchester Model 70 in semi-auto

    Don't forget Nick burst firing at the end of episode 1 when you go with him

    BigBlindMax posted: »

    As a gun enthusiast, I noticed that too. I love the windmill scene in S2E2 when Sarita starts firing her Winchester Model 70 in semi-auto.

  • I thought 7.62×54mmR rounds were no longer in production, unlike the standard 7.62x39 AK rounds. But if that's true I'll take your word for it.

    BigBlindMax posted: »

    Oh, 7.62 Russian is definitely still made in high quantity. Mosin Nagants have become very popular sporting rifles, since they're extremely

  • This is new to me, i didn't know a hunting store sold AK -47s

    MaconMajr posted: »

    I been to a Cabela's and seen some with my own eyes. And that last part I suppose, yeah.

  • hen, when 5.56mm ammo started to get scarce

    I just don't see that happening. at least not in america. Most gun enthusiasts reload their own brass.

    BigBlindMax posted: »

    As a gun enthusiast, I noticed that too. I love the windmill scene in S2E2 when Sarita starts firing her Winchester Model 70 in semi-auto.

  • Really? I know a lot of gun people and only a few are reloaders. It requires some expertise to avoid blowing your appendages off IIRC.

    I worked the front counter at a gun store for a couple months. 5.56/.223 ALWAYS flew off the shelf quicker than we could get it. Same with .22LR.

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    hen, when 5.56mm ammo started to get scarce I just don't see that happening. at least not in america. Most gun enthusiasts reload their own brass.

  • Reloading brass. Do you mean the actual shells that are left over?

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    hen, when 5.56mm ammo started to get scarce I just don't see that happening. at least not in america. Most gun enthusiasts reload their own brass.

  • edited September 2015

    I think Kirkman knows things better than wiki and he never confirmed that ZA started in 2003. He only said that TWD takes place in "modern times" but no dates are revealed so it may be 2003 as well as 2005, 2013 etc.

  • edited September 2015

    Well, I'm guessing that comment is from 2009. Today he would say that you can pretend it's 2015 instead.

    In my eyes it starts in 2003, and I really wouldn't use false gun models as proof for anything. Not everyone knows guns as well as you guys, if you showed a gun to me and ask me what model it is, all I could tell you is that it's a handgun.

    But 2003 isn't confirmed, all that's confirmed is that it starts on July 20 in 'modern times' (the date is from the tapes in Crawford), and that is intended by Kirkman. The year is supposed to be vague, meaning it could happen at any time, on any day. I think that's what he wants to say. Or maybe he just doesn't give a shit.

    Probably unrelated, but the show takes place in August of 2010, confirmed by a banner in the latest 'Fear The Walking Dead' Episode.

    mosfet posted: »

    According to research, the zombie apocalypse takes place 2003 and down the line What research? Telltale and Robert Kirkman have both

  • I say hey I don't mind that much cuz it's a game im enjoying the story in the game and playing as clem.

  • Yeah, the collect empty shell casings and load them with new powder, primers and bullets.

    Lilacsbloom posted: »

    Reloading brass. Do you mean the actual shells that are left over?

  • DeltinoDeltino Moderator
    edited September 2015

    For what it's worth:

    enter image description here

    That's the map of the train routes in Long Road Ahead. While it doesn't suggest without a shadow of a doubt that the game takes place in 2003, it does suggest that it takes place within the general timespan. It might also be worth noting that this is the only texture in the game that has a positive year-date. Everything else is cut off or too low quality to make out, at least from what I can tell.

    Small edit: I actually did some snooping and I found one other texture for the rest stop in No Going Back.

    enter image description here

    It's a small part of a larger texture file, but it's a poster for an evacuation notice. You can make out what says "Saturday - July 24/26"

    It's difficult to tell if it's 24 or 26, but after doing some google searches, it turns out that there was a July 26 on a Saturday in 2003, and a July 24 on a Saturday in 2004.

  • That's some New Vegas shit right there.

    BigBlindMax posted: »

    Yeah, the collect empty shell casings and load them with new powder, primers and bullets.

  • At least that is how it is in my Family.

    BigBlindMax posted: »

    Really? I know a lot of gun people and only a few are reloaders. It requires some expertise to avoid blowing your appendages off IIRC.

  • Your posts are awesome!

    Deltino posted: »

    For what it's worth: That's the map of the train routes in Long Road Ahead. While it doesn't suggest without a shadow of a doubt that

  • Hand Loader perk is best perk.

    papai46 posted: »

    That's some New Vegas shit right there.

  • o.o cool. I bet that would definitely be a useful thing in a ZA.

    Curious question since I noticed you seem to know quite a bit on guns, let's say that was community in TWDG [like Wellington for example] that needed to keep itself secure, but also went out hunting and on scavenge runs for supplies, what kind of guns do you think they would use?

    BigBlindMax posted: »

    Yeah, the collect empty shell casings and load them with new powder, primers and bullets.

  • That's definitely a 6, it doesn't even look like a 4.

    Deltino posted: »

    For what it's worth: That's the map of the train routes in Long Road Ahead. While it doesn't suggest without a shadow of a doubt that

  • o.o bro, nice find.

    Deltino posted: »

    For what it's worth: That's the map of the train routes in Long Road Ahead. While it doesn't suggest without a shadow of a doubt that

  • Realistically, probably bolt or lever action rifles and pistols. like the motel and cabin groups. There would probably be some semi-automatic rifles too, like the AR-15 or M1A, plus whatever guns military deserters could scrounge. Fully automatic weapons are feasible but impractical. They're primary function is suppressive fire (keeping the enemy pinned down) and since walkers can't feel fear, it's not that helpful. Plus they encourage poor trigger discipline and wasteful firing.

    If I had my choice, I'd pick a small, suppressed .22LR rifle for hunting / stealthy walker killing and a 9mm or .40S&W pistol for personal defense.

    However, the rule of cool would probably dictate that a town like Wellington would use tactical assault rifles and combat shotguns to show how advanced their community is.

    Lilacsbloom posted: »

    o.o cool. I bet that would definitely be a useful thing in a ZA. Curious question since I noticed you seem to know quite a bit on guns, l

  • TWDS1and2 take place in the same world as the comics and at the start of the comics the year is somewhere around 2003-2004.

  • enter image description here

    soysauce posted: »

    TWDS1and2 take place in the same world as the comics and at the start of the comics the year is somewhere around 2003-2004.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.