Why do some of you did not like protagonist is a child?

13»

Comments

  • It was sarcastically ... yes?

    Wolfenus54 posted: »

    In conclusion, FUCK YOU, Clementine best. That insult was unecessary. And I never insulted you in the first place. Wow... That was a jerky move, insulting someone that never insulted you.

  • That was uncalled for. No need to insult people just because their opinions differs from yours.

    Also, didn't I mention this to you a few days ago? If you cannot handle criticism or opinions that opposes yours in a level-headed matter, then this place isn't for you.

  • But they're trying to hurt me, I have not seen?

    RichWalk23 posted: »

    That was uncalled for. No need to insult people just because their opinions differs from yours. Also, didn't I mention this to you a few

  • [removed]

    CuteClem posted: »

    But they're trying to hurt me, I have not seen?

  • Indeed. As I said, probably just cutting corners in the animation or writing department.

    Deltino posted: »

    It wouldn't be much animation work depending on how they do it. If you just hit the doorknob with the hatchet, all they have to do is make some chopped wood sprites and animate the knob falling out, and it would be good enough.

  • Just... quit forcing Clementine down our throats. People like what they like and hate what they hate. A majority of fans like Clem and a minority don't. I'm part of that minority and I'm proud of it and have never regretted disliking Clementine.

    CuteClem posted: »

    But that's your opinion, not mine, and * most * people I met. They think that it is very appreciated character and strong. I admire her and

  • We get it, you don't like playing as female characters.

    Kennyftw posted: »

    Because I'm a guy, and will never be in a life or death situation trapped in a little girl's body.

  • I can get behind 3 -- that is just a matter of taste. As for the other two, I just don't buy them.

    Clementine has as much or as little personality at the player invests her with. But, more importantly, one of the core arguments carried through Season 1 AND Season 2 is that there are no kids any longer. Or, rather, if you treat children as "kids", you kill them. 2-3 years in, most of the kids would have died off now if they weren't sheltered in a rare safe zone. Whether you're 11 or 41, there are only survivors out there by the end of Season 2.

    Our conception of childhood is a modern invention produced in an environment of plenty. Historically, children as young as 3 were expected to be contributing members of the community, I have worked with homeless children in Chicago. Those kids are much more mature and capable than their more coddled suburban counterparts. I don't find Clem implausible at all.

    Because * Clementine has little to no character or personality * I don't want to play as a child given adult responsibilities it doe

  • Quite simple for me. As Lee I felt like I was participating in an amazing story. As Clem I felt like I was watching an amazing story.

    I'm a guy in my 30's, Lee was a perfect avatar for me. I spent all of Season 2 thinking "what would a little girl do?", I spent Season 1 thinking "what should I do?" Massive difference.

    As no 11 year old girls should be playing this game, I can't imagine literally anyone feeling like Clem was an avatar for them. Instead everyone was simply playing the role the best they could.

  • I enjoyed playing as Clem, I enjoyed playing as Lee. Had a strong connection to both. Meeting kenny again was a great moment. But some things such as sewing her arm was a it stupid for her age. Otherwise i enjoyed S2 and cant wait for S3 hopefully she'll return!

  • It was just ridiculous, the things the adults expected Clem to do lol.

    I really didn't like Clem as a protagonist. Hope they ditch her

Sign in to comment in this discussion.