I thought so too. But nobody I know has mentioned it, so I assumed nobody noticed it, as people made a pretty big deal out of thinking it was Glenn. I guess most people didn't think it was worth discussing.
Most people want to blame Morgan because it's entirely his fault, just like Rick's last ditch effort to distract the herd going bad was entirely his fault for not killing those five Wolves. Hell, even putting aside the whole argument about morality, it's also Morgan's fault because he tied the dude's hands in front of him like a moron, instead of behind his back so he could never grab anything with ease like, say, a stick that he could use to knock someone out (Oh, wait). Or leave him free to fuck around with the binds around his legs, which even then, obviously didn't impede him from standing up. What if he had laid in wait and lunged at Morgan as he came through the door and managed to knock him out? Hell, even Lamson managed to knock Sasha out with his hands behind his back.
Any argument regarding Morgan's tormented psyche and all that crap can easily be extended to Carol as well, who was clearly emotionally devastated by the attack of the Wolves, the actions she was forced to take, and the innocents whose lives they claimed. Now here comes Morgan trying to save and use up medical resources on the guy who orchestrated the entire attack, who also flat out tells Morgan that he should be killed because the second he gets out he's going to kill more people. He's just as single-minded as Carol, just in the opposite and much stupider direction.
And this is coming from someone who doesn't like it any more than you do that the show constantly treats Rick and Carol like nothing they do can be wrong in some way. But when it comes down to it, Carol is fighting to kill the remorseless, un-savable murderer to keep him from ever trying something that will get people killed again, and Morgan is fighting to protect the remorseless, un-savable murderer because he wants to prove to himself that he's not a complete shit after all the things he's done wrong in his life, and the lives of innocents be damned. Annoying or not, one side is right, and the other is stupid.
I'm with you. Both Carol and Rick have been irritating the shit out of me since they arrived in Alexandria. Most people want to blame Morgan… more for the Wolf escaping but he had that guy on complete lock down before Carol made the "smart" decision to push the issue at the worst possible time. Morgan even flat out told her that they could settle their issues after the herd was dealt with. But that's Carol for you. She makes a decision and fuck what anyone else has to say about it.
Why did Daryl even stop the truck? they had been ambushed a day earlier, wouldn't you think it would be the same guys? is it the same guys? Either way that fuel truck could have rolled over all six of those bikes without breaking a valve stem. thats what I would have done, motorcycles offer little protection for riders. my wife's uncle was hit by a camry and was in hospital for weeks. so yeah stopping the truck was a bad idea.
Why did Daryl even stop the truck? they had been ambushed a day earlier, wouldn't you think it would be the same guys? is it the same guys?… more Either way that fuel truck could have rolled over all six of those bikes without breaking a valve stem. thats what I would have done, motorcycles offer little protection for riders. my wife's uncle was hit by a camry and was in hospital for weeks. so yeah stopping the truck was a bad idea.
People were just looking at anything to be glenn, really I think the writers wanted people to think that too. But glenn was revealed so therewas no real point talking about it
I thought so too. But nobody I know has mentioned it, so I assumed nobody noticed it, as people made a pretty big deal out of thinking it was Glenn. I guess most people didn't think it was worth discussing.
But it is a finale nonetheless, it shouldn't leave everything for 3 months. If they'd had that scene from the comics (don't wanna say it incase some people don't know, but I think we see eye to eye on it) right at the end and rolled the credits there, the reviews would have been a lot more favourable. I mean, all it's done is make sure the premiere's gonna be bonkers, it just woulda been nice to have something to remember from the episode
But it is a finale nonetheless, it shouldn't leave everything for 3 months. If they'd had that scene from the comics (don't wanna say it inc… morease some people don't know, but I think we see eye to eye on it) right at the end and rolled the credits there, the reviews would have been a lot more favourable. I mean, all it's done is make sure the premiere's gonna be bonkers, it just woulda been nice to have something to remember from the episode
Fair enough, the Morgan/Carol scene was pretty good.
Don't get me wrong, the episode was suspenseful and had a fitting ending for Deanna.
My problem is that there was no final payoff. There was no shock value or a lasting thought, it just seemed to leave everything to the premiere, and I have comic hindsight, some people won't know it's all about to hit the fan. So I can imagine it was a little underwhelming for them
Fair enough, the Morgan/Carol scene was pretty good.
Don't get me wrong, the episode was suspenseful and had a fitting ending for Deanna.… more
My problem is that there was no final payoff. There was no shock value or a lasting thought, it just seemed to leave everything to the premiere, and I have comic hindsight, some people won't know it's all about to hit the fan. So I can imagine it was a little underwhelming for them
What worries me is Judith. What if he lands on her after getting shot????
Wow, that'd be how Judith (AKA Judy) died in the comics ac… moretually. Lori's shot, She lands on the baby. Holy crap they'd be following the comics a lot better than I thought.
Comments
I thought so too. But nobody I know has mentioned it, so I assumed nobody noticed it, as people made a pretty big deal out of thinking it was Glenn. I guess most people didn't think it was worth discussing.
Im preatty sure it will
And even before that a few scenes are pretty memorable.........
Most people want to blame Morgan because it's entirely his fault, just like Rick's last ditch effort to distract the herd going bad was entirely his fault for not killing those five Wolves. Hell, even putting aside the whole argument about morality, it's also Morgan's fault because he tied the dude's hands in front of him like a moron, instead of behind his back so he could never grab anything with ease like, say, a stick that he could use to knock someone out (Oh, wait). Or leave him free to fuck around with the binds around his legs, which even then, obviously didn't impede him from standing up. What if he had laid in wait and lunged at Morgan as he came through the door and managed to knock him out? Hell, even Lamson managed to knock Sasha out with his hands behind his back.
Any argument regarding Morgan's tormented psyche and all that crap can easily be extended to Carol as well, who was clearly emotionally devastated by the attack of the Wolves, the actions she was forced to take, and the innocents whose lives they claimed. Now here comes Morgan trying to save and use up medical resources on the guy who orchestrated the entire attack, who also flat out tells Morgan that he should be killed because the second he gets out he's going to kill more people. He's just as single-minded as Carol, just in the opposite and much stupider direction.
And this is coming from someone who doesn't like it any more than you do that the show constantly treats Rick and Carol like nothing they do can be wrong in some way. But when it comes down to it, Carol is fighting to kill the remorseless, un-savable murderer to keep him from ever trying something that will get people killed again, and Morgan is fighting to protect the remorseless, un-savable murderer because he wants to prove to himself that he's not a complete shit after all the things he's done wrong in his life, and the lives of innocents be damned. Annoying or not, one side is right, and the other is stupid.
Why did Daryl even stop the truck? they had been ambushed a day earlier, wouldn't you think it would be the same guys? is it the same guys? Either way that fuel truck could have rolled over all six of those bikes without breaking a valve stem. thats what I would have done, motorcycles offer little protection for riders. my wife's uncle was hit by a camry and was in hospital for weeks. so yeah stopping the truck was a bad idea.
Human skin offers little protection from bullets.
thanks science side of the telltale forum
People were just looking at anything to be glenn, really I think the writers wanted people to think that too. But glenn was revealed so therewas no real point talking about it
It would have been great if the show didnt do this weird split season thing. All that tension built will be lost in two months
Yuuup. Mid-season finale's suck ass.
A-fucking-men to that.
Dude are you bill nye or some shit? That's some amazing science right there.
It was 10 seconds away from what would have been one of the most memorable mid-s finales. Oh well, roll on the premiere!
thats why you don't stop the truck
and lets not forget that Abraham has an RPG
There's no way they could've gone straight through them without one of them successfully killing them.
It not the only show that does that. Right now chrismas break is popular since its believed all people watch in this time is chrismas movies.
Also the Rpg is in the back.......which is covered by a wall. Also its not loaded so he would have to load it
I don't think they want to keep the mindset that mid season finales are the best part. It would maje sense for a premier though.
But it is a finale nonetheless, it shouldn't leave everything for 3 months. If they'd had that scene from the comics (don't wanna say it incase some people don't know, but I think we see eye to eye on it) right at the end and rolled the credits there, the reviews would have been a lot more favourable. I mean, all it's done is make sure the premiere's gonna be bonkers, it just woulda been nice to have something to remember from the episode
O cmon we had good scenes.
Morgan vs Carol
The stair scene
Deana talking to the group
Fair enough, the Morgan/Carol scene was pretty good.
Don't get me wrong, the episode was suspenseful and had a fitting ending for Deanna.
My problem is that there was no final payoff. There was no shock value or a lasting thought, it just seemed to leave everything to the premiere, and I have comic hindsight, some people won't know it's all about to hit the fan. So I can imagine it was a little underwhelming for them
Well look at it this way next ep is definetly going to get people talking.....
besides in the comic judith definitely gets shot along with Lori, not killed by lori landing on her.
Anyone know when TWD is going to return?
Please do not bump old threads like this, just use the edit button.
Before I lock the thread, February 14th I believe is the day.
Thanks!! I can't wait