Who did you choose to save (or try to save) over the other?

24

Comments

  • A-IBRAHIM0702A-IBRAHIM0702 Banned
    edited July 2016

    Kenny lost his family, TWICE, but still wants to lead the group. WHY??? Why doesn't he just take a backseat in the story and let others make the important decisions or atleast listen to what others say.

    Imagine if the whole group made it to Wellington safe and sound in Kenny's lead, would they had been allowed to enter? Wellington also rejected Arvo's group. Hence they had the same supply deffel bags.

    Clementine and AJ do not count for the whole group. That's the problem there mate. Kenny only cares for who he considers family but everyone else could get eaten for all he cares.Yes Kenny and Christa were right that Wellington exists but the plan was to stay there not admire its big walls and leave.

    I'm not just thinking of a little girl and a baby. I'm thinking about everyone. I still don't understand why Kenny was so obsessed with Wellington.

    Chusets posted: »

    "Dictatorship" would imply tha someone is dictating things the WHOLE time, wich he wasn't. There were various moments where people had to fo

  • We hadn't known at that time but she was pregnant.

    AronDracula posted: »

    Christa. Ladies first What do you mean? Omid got a wounded leg and Christa didn't have any injuries. She was faster than Omid

  • edited July 2016

    At the time we chose to go there we couldn't know that they weren't taking more people in. Also, if there's a community that big, it'll always be worth to check out, that's why the choice was clear. Besides, even if the group couldn't stay, letting Clem and AJ there is overall rewarding. Kenny loses his temper often with the group but he cares for them on his own way of caring, I mean, all they do is question him and judge him, but if they need anything he is the one they look up for. He made a lot of mistakes but he still is a good man who is trying to survive, not alone, not only with Clem and AJ, with the whole group, if Bonnie and Mike didn't want to stay, they could've at least had the bloody balls to say that and leave, instead of betraying the group. Then Jane starts that shit in order to prove a point, no doubt he would rely on Clem and AJ, when everybody else had prove they're assholes.

    Kenny lost his family, TWICE, but still wants to lead the group. WHY??? Why doesn't he just take a backseat in the story and let others make

  • edited July 2016

    1)Shawn,
    2)Carley,
    3)Travis,
    4)Omid,
    5)Justin,
    6)Pete,
    7)Sarah,
    8)Kenny.
    In first time gameplay

  • edited July 2016
    1. Shawn (Kenny was already going for Duck.)
    2. Doug (After being stuck with Doug in my first playthrough thanks to a glitch, I actually think I like him more than Carley.)
    3. Travis
    4. Christa (I didn't realize we could switch between them lmao.)
    5. Justin (Who would even pick Danny???)
    6. Pete
    7. Jane (I pulled her up in my first playthrough because I thought if I didn't, she would die. Totally love Sarah though.)
    8. Jane
  • Shawn or Duck?

    I don't even remember why I chose Shawn over Duck, but I just did???

    Carley or Doug?

    I chose Carley on my first playthrough, but I honestly adore Doug.

    Travis or David?

    I completely panicked and my time ran out, so I chose Travis.

    Omid or Christa?

    I saved Omid, since he was injured. I thought he would die if I didn't save him, to be honest.

    Danny or Justin?

    Well, we all know that Danny is the living embodiment of garbage. I just had to choose Justin, man.

    Nick or Pete?

    I chose Nick on my first playthrough and I don't regret it. Uncle Pete is pretty amazing, though.

    Jane or Sarah? (if you didn't leave her at the trailer park)

    Nah, I forced Jane to go down there and save Sarah. I thought that I could save her...

    Kenny or Jane?

    Kenny can literally eat my left shoe for all I care, Jane all the way.

  • Kenny is different . he is a leader . he lost a lot . one sun . two wife. others pushed him

    Lee held up okay after his girlfriend was shot in the face. Luke held up okay after his best friend died. Heck, even Leland kept it together after his wife died and doesn't go full Kenny even if Bonnie admits killing his wife.

  • A-IBRAHIM0702A-IBRAHIM0702 Banned
    edited July 2016

    No, no and no.

    No one pushed him. He pushed everyone to follow him on a death march. Did you even play season 2?

    Kenny is different . he is a leader . he lost a lot . one sun . two wife. others pushed him

  • Why are you attacking him/her for their opinion?? If he/she wants to think that then let them.

    No, no and no. No one pushed him. He pushed everyone to follow him on a death march. Did you even play season 2?

  • Heck, even Leland kept it together after his wife died and doesn't go full Kenny even if Bonnie admits killing his wife.

    I really don't give a shit if you don't like what i'm about to say but i'll say it anyway. Kenny lost his family all in an instant, out of the blue. Now everyone else has lost people too yes, but the thing you have to understand is that everyone is different and react differently to losing a loved one. Kenny technically lost more than everyone else but that doesn't matter, it's how each people deals with grief. He didn't deal with it well and that was unfortunate, that's all there is to it.

    Lee held up okay after his girlfriend was shot in the face. Luke held up okay after his best friend died. Heck, even Leland kept it together after his wife died and doesn't go full Kenny even if Bonnie admits killing his wife.

  • I made all of the same choices, though my reason to save Kenny was mostly dependent on finding Wellington.

    Kenny726 posted: »

    * Duck He was shown to not be the most...competent character. I thought he would die if I didn't help him. I wanted to get him, move the t

  • Kenny only cares for who he considers family

    disagree. Kenny would have left with just AJ and Clem if he felt that way. He wouldn't have stuck around if he didn't care in any way about them. He got a truck working to get everyone transport to wherever they decided to go. Believe it or not, despite being an asshole at times, i think he wanted them around, safety in numbers and all that. My opinion anyway, take it with a pinch of salt

    Kenny lost his family, TWICE, but still wants to lead the group. WHY??? Why doesn't he just take a backseat in the story and let others make

  • A-IBRAHIM0702A-IBRAHIM0702 Banned
    edited July 2016

    Alright, you got me there. But you cannot deny about his Come with me to Wellington or Fuck off attitude.

    dan290786 posted: »

    Kenny only cares for who he considers family disagree. Kenny would have left with just AJ and Clem if he felt that way. He wouldn't

  • No. No. I'm sorry I'm not attacking them for their opinion.

    I'm actually replying "no" to their points listed above i.e the first three.

    I'm terribly sorry if it felt like that.

    dan290786 posted: »

    Why are you attacking him/her for their opinion?? If he/she wants to think that then let them.

  • A-IBRAHIM0702A-IBRAHIM0702 Banned
    edited July 2016

    That's the problem man. Kenny deals with grief by blaming Ben illogically, constant wishing for him to die, beating Arvo again and again and again until the victim snaps and faces the torturer bravely (Ben) or cowardly (Arvo). Your "dealing with grief" shouldn't ruin other's life.

    dan290786 posted: »

    Heck, even Leland kept it together after his wife died and doesn't go full Kenny even if Bonnie admits killing his wife. I really do

  • Yeah he comes across as an asshole and i get that and why people can't stand him for that. But his intentions were what he believed were in the best interest for everyone, even though he wasn't to know he was doing the right thing if that makes sense

    Alright, you got me there. But you cannot deny about his Come with me to Wellington or Fuck off attitude.

  • edited July 2016

    I agree, and both times he shouldn't have done what he did. Believe it or not, I didn't agree with everything Kenny did but at the same time as i have previously said, i look at both sides of the coin. He had reasons to treat Ben the way he did. He found out this guy was partially the reason his family died and the fact he was putting everyone in danger due to cowardly or dumb decisions. With Arvo it's much the same. Beating him up was uneeded especially just because Arvo cursed at him. It just shows that he lost control of his temper easier than in previous times and for the record I don't agree with him beating him up. However, look at the reasons as to why he did. He saw Arvo as threat previously due to what him and his pals did in holding the group at gunpoint. Kenny was never going to trust him after that. I think i'd be shitty with someone who had threatened me in that way and if someone said "fuck you" to me, i'd be offended. Arvo was asking for a reaction and he got it. But yes the violence was extreme and this was just to show the change Kenny was going through. My point is, he still had a reason for it, even though it was bad.

    As for him dealing with the grief, sadly not everyone can deal with it so easily.

    That's the problem man. Kenny deals with grief by blaming Ben illogically, constant wishing for him to die, beating Arvo again and again and

  • edited July 2016

    Thanks. male & 22 years By the way

    dan290786 posted: »

    Why are you attacking him/her for their opinion?? If he/she wants to think that then let them.

  • they did pushed him. even Lee did once back in season 1

    No. No. I'm sorry I'm not attacking them for their opinion. I'm actually replying "no" to their points listed above i.e the first three. I'm terribly sorry if it felt like that.

  • Shawn or Duck?

    Shawn was stuck under a tractor, figured he needed more help than the kid, who was actually not my responsibility at the moment.

    Carley or Doug?

    I thought Carley would be more useful for the group, even though I liked both of them.

    Travis or David?

    David, I honestly didn't even realise that there was a choice between them O.O.

    Omid or Christa?

    Omid was injured, so I pulled him up.

    Danny or Justin?

    Justin, Danny can go f*ck himself.

    Nick or Pete?

    I went with Pete, I thought I could help him with the bite or somehing.

    Jane or Sarah? (if you didn't leave her at the trailer park)

    Well, I convinced Jane to help Sarah, but the writers had other things in mind I suppose...

    Kenny or Jane?

    Jane, didn't even think twice about it.

  • He isn't a very loving uncle, just saying. His nephew was going to hell and he was just "giving him a hard time"

    Might I ask you why do you think that Pete is an asshole? Just curious.

  • edited August 2016

    if someone is the leader of something, people should trust this person from time to time

    What we need is some nice, savage, bloody, free anarchy, with no leaders, no rules, no laws more that one's ideals, free solitude.

    Anarchy, Anarchy, why do people think you're so bad?

    GOVERMENTS MUST FALL.

    Chusets posted: »

    "Dictatorship" would imply tha someone is dictating things the WHOLE time, wich he wasn't. There were various moments where people had to fo

  • edited August 2016

    David, I honestly didn't even realize that there was a choice between them O.O.

    Yeah, there is. You just have to wait really really really looong for it to happen.

    Justin, Danny can go f*ck himself.

    Dare I ask the obvious question of "Why"?

    Well, I convinced Jane to help Sarah, but the writers had other things in mind I suppose...

    Too bad they didn't think it through or even, I don't know,capitalize....

    (I apologize, I usually don't like saying things like that....)

    Shawn or Duck? Shawn was stuck under a tractor, figured he needed more help than the kid, who was actually not my responsibility at

    1. Duck - He's a child.
    2. Carley - Good shot.
    3. David - He was stuck in a damn bear trap.
    4. Christa - I wanted to choose Omid but I misclicked.
    5. Don't really remember. I know I chose the rapist to stay.
    6. Pete - I figured he was in need of help more than Nick.
    7. Sarah - Jane had a likelier chance of surviving than Sarah.
    8. Kenny - I hated Jane for what she did.
  • Hahahahahahahahahhhahaha c'mon, don't do this to me! You're killing me! Hahahahahahaha

    Wait, you're joking right? 'Cause I can't tell but, it looks like you are. I laughed anyway.

                                                                                                                                                                                 No Hate, Your Mate
    

    if someone is the leader of something, people should trust this person from time to time What we need is some nice, savage, bloody,

  • No joke. I'm 100% serious in this.

    Society must die. Money must die. Power must die. Goverment must die.

    Chusets posted: »

    Hahahahahahahahahhhahaha c'mon, don't do this to me! You're killing me! Hahahahahahaha Wait, you're joking right? 'Cause I can't tell but

  • enter image description here

    No joke. I'm 100% serious in this. Society must die. Money must die. Power must die. Goverment must die.

  • Oh, I'm sorry then, I really thought you were joking.

    I understand your reasoning. And even though you have a point, I kindly desagree.

                                                                                                                                                                     No Hate, Your Mate.
    

    No joke. I'm 100% serious in this. Society must die. Money must die. Power must die. Goverment must die.

  • I love how people make fun of my ideals.

    really.

  • And even though you have a point, I kindly desagree

    I'd love to hear your opinion. Or, read, you know.

    Chusets posted: »

    Oh, I'm sorry then, I really thought you were joking. I understand your reasoning. And even though you have a point, I kindly desagree.

  • edited August 2016

    I agree with you about the government being awful and all, but I'd rather to optimistacally wait for something better, maybe even contribute somehow, everybody has their two cents to give, also, Anarchy is way too much in my opinion, all we need is faith and attitude.

                                                                                                                                                 No Hate, Your Mate.
    

    And even though you have a point, I kindly desagree I'd love to hear your opinion. Or, read, you know.

  • Yeah, there is. You just have to wait really really really looong for it to happen.

    I just straight up decided to chop David's leg, so yeah :D

    Dare I ask the obvious question of "Why"?

    I'm not a big fan of rapers, that's all.

    (I apologize, I usually don't like saying things like that....)

    It's okay, don't sweat it.

    DabigRG posted: »

    David, I honestly didn't even realize that there was a choice between them O.O. Yeah, there is. You just have to wait really really

  • I admire your optimism, I'm the kind of person that thinks humanity is in its way to death and all that stuff... But I respect your opinion.

    Chusets posted: »

    I agree with you about the government being awful and all, but I'd rather to optimistacally wait for something better, maybe even contribute

  • edited August 2016

    Thank you love! I admire your realism, being optimist doesn't make me blind you know? Hahahah, anyway, we'll be talking again soon.

                                                                                                                                                                                                  No Hate, Your Mate.
    

    I admire your optimism, I'm the kind of person that thinks humanity is in its way to death and all that stuff... But I respect your opinion.

  • And that would be why consolers have jobs in reality. Something I've wondered about is wether or not Jane's "assesement" of Kenny while he's fixing the truck is correct. It's fairly clear that she is. But still pretty gray. I feel like Jane's arguements may suffer because we lack knowing who Kenny was "before". Sure plenty may be implied,but we learned more from his wife in S1. With Jane you can tell she's always been an. implusive not so bright person. "You are glass, that's stupid". that's a clem line. While I do like Jane better, I could'nt go with her.

    That's the problem man. Kenny deals with grief by blaming Ben illogically, constant wishing for him to die, beating Arvo again and again and

  • I'm not a big fan of rapers, that's all.

    Glad to know I'm not the only one who sometimes phrases it that way.

    As for the choice, I perfectedly understand: the scenario puts you on a prisoner bus chained to two other criminals, who you just befriended, and ends with you choosing one to mutilate. One is a entitled conman who unapolagetically robbed dozens of people and proudly admits to lying on the stand, the other seems to be a truly noble and friendly guy who is more worried about his heartbroken girlfriend's well-being than defending the fact that he was convicted for statutory rape(. So, its a question of do you put up with the pompous thief or deal with the idea of helping an alleged rapist?

    Personally, I cared more about their character than their crimes in this instance (especially since Vince is also a prisoner for murdering some guy he felt was a threat to his brother) and Justin was just too easy a hate-sink that I didn't really hesitate. Danny, on the otherhand, could prove a valuable ally since 1.I recalled the backstory talk between Clementine and Lee, 2.he risked his life trying to get the dangerously highstrung guard to back off, and 3. The game is vague about whether he actually did it or not, at least on my playthrough, since he only comments on it once and the only other comments on in comes from Justin (a selfrighteous conman) and Russell(a former gangbanger who doesn't trust easily).

    Also, similar to my later attitude towards Troy possibly joining the Ski Cabin Group, if he did turn out to be guilty or/and strikes again, Vince could deal with him later.

    Yeah, there is. You just have to wait really really really looong for it to happen. I just straight up decided to chop David's leg,

  • Russell (a former gangbanger who doesn't trust easily).

    former gangbanger who doesn't trust easily

    former gangbanger

    What. In the hell.

    And I find myself asking to you again, when was this hinted at?

    DabigRG posted: »

    I'm not a big fan of rapers, that's all. Glad to know I'm not the only one who sometimes phrases it that way. As for the choice,

  • The Rusell thing? Gangbanger is a fancy street way for saying someone in a gang of thugs. With "thug" being the average rap music video definition.

    Rusell tells Nate that he was in a gang of seven with a gun happy leader named Steve who relentlessly killed other survivors and took their stuff. Which Nate proceeds to do himself, hence causing Rusell to be even more hesitant about trusting people than before.

    Not sure how you got confused about that. Also, did we speak recently? I don't recall.

    Russell (a former gangbanger who doesn't trust easily). former gangbanger who doesn't trust easily former gangbanger What. In the hell. And I find myself asking to you again, when was this hinted at?

  • Not sure how you got confused about that.

    I suspected that gangbanger was a term that is not safe for work, to put it lightly. A ten second search on Google confirmed my suspicion, so, uh, let's just say that this was a conflict of meaning and leave it at that.

    Or you can search gangbanger for yourself. I don't know.

    Also, did we speak recently? I don't recall.

    I asked you about Jane's supposed bisexuality.

    DabigRG posted: »

    The Rusell thing? Gangbanger is a fancy street way for saying someone in a gang of thugs. With "thug" being the average rap music video defi

  • Yeah, I can understand your choice, too. I guess I acted impulsively since I found out he could be a rapist and I didn't trust him when he started making excuses (I think? , I don't really remember). But I don't regret my choice, because it simply didn't really matter at the end :D. I mean Vince's part of the Season 2 story was just 2-3 lines, and that was it. Same goes for Russell, Wyatt, Shel and Becca.

    Kinda got off-topic, sorry about that.

    DabigRG posted: »

    I'm not a big fan of rapers, that's all. Glad to know I'm not the only one who sometimes phrases it that way. As for the choice,

Sign in to comment in this discussion.