A new Theory regarding keeping/losing your finger
What if the choice to keep/lose your finger is determinant of if you kept the St John brothers alive? The barn reminds me a lot of the slaughter house screenshot that we saw.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Knowing my luck, I'm losing the finger no matter what.
No offence but this is stupid. Why would a choice someone else did four years ago lots of miles away would affect this? No. Just no. Sam x Javi is more probable than this (CUZ SAM GOT LUCKY REAL LUCKY YOU'LL SEE INSIGNIFICANT HUMANS)
Anyone taking my finger i'm taking their life. Period. Point. Blank.
Well,anything is possible. But since they have the creator back on board this year, I think not. More likely to be somthing like if you "stole"from the stranger. Hope that hoody was worth it! Granted I have no clue how that could connect story wise. More fitting a theme of "if you steal Clem looses a finger". If you cut off Sarita's arm maybe the same and so on. Working referance in about the St Johns is likely. But I can't see it leading to Clem's finger loss. Just my thoughts. Like your thread, gave it a bump:)
It's probably going to be a choice you make in S3 or near the end of S2. Thinking further back is just wishful thinking.
Maybe the result of choosing to survive by yourself.
I didn't steal from the stranger's vehicle, but I've always wondered if that's where Clementine got the "Brooklyn" hoodie.
This actually makes the most sense -that it would be a result of your final decision, since none of the others had any affect of your Season 2 game experience.