If you swapped Clem's group with Rick's group in the Negan scene, Who would get Lucilled?
I'm looking at this situation if somehow Clem's group killed Negan's men the same fashion that they killed Arvo's Russian group, but to later find out that they messed with the wrong group of people and get rounded up similar to how Rick and his group got ambushed in the season 6 finale.
Assuming in this situation that we have the following characters: Clem,Kenny,Luke,Nick,Bonnie, Rebecca(pregnant),Jane, Arvo( who is with Negan group), and Mike.
Safe List:
1.Clem: Even though, would try to stop Negan from beating the victim(determinant based on trying to save Kenny from Carver's beating and trying to save Alvin from Carver at gun point), Negan would never kill someone he respects or kids*.
- Rebecca: She is out of the list because she is pregnant.
3.Arvo: Negan burns his face off later.
- Kenny: His attitude would cause more to be killed in the group, but will not be killed because he is the leader of the group and that is a major but of Negan's game.
Lucilled List:
1.Luke: His death would impact the group more than any member of the group. And he seems so innocent like Glen. His last words" I'm sorry Bonnie."
Bonnie: Negan seeing Bonnie's willingness to bend to him after seeing what he believed to be Bonnie's lover, kills her ,too. Negan will say something like " heartless"
Mike: Mike would be killed too if Clem interrupts the Lucilling of Luke or Bonnie as punishment. The reason that Negan picks Mike is because he thinks that Mike is Clem's older brother.
After the Lucilling, Negan is still not convinced that Kenny will follow orders, and he chops off Clem's Left pinky finger. After cutting of Clem's finger, Kenny becomes enraged but is thrown on the group with a gun pointed towards his head. Negan hands Kenny the hatchet and threatens Kenny that if Kenny doesn't cut off Clem's ear that he will kill everyone.
Negan counts down to 10. At 9, Kenny begs Negan. At 7, is mustering up the courage to do it. At 3, Kenny ceased to function and yells out " Kill me! Kill Me!" At 0,Negan:Alright then.[ makes a bang sound and pretends that his hand is a gun]
Comments
No...he would kill Kenny for the same reason he killed Abraham...he would look him in the eyes and show no fear....so Kenny gets cracked...says heh...fucker. Negan will hit him again then laugh at what he called him...then keep beating Kenny until there is nothing left.
Clem gets pissed attacks Negan...Negan shuts that shit down by killing Carlos.....causing Sarah to freak out....Negan shuts that shit down by killing Luke...Bonnie gets pissed and tries to attack...Negan shuts that shit down by killing Arvo...Mike gets upset and attacks Negan...Negan shuts that shit down by killing Sarah...that pissed Rebecca off so she attacks....Negan shuts that shit down and kills Sarita....He then cracks Rebecca over the head to shut her up..
Negan realises that Clementine is the only one left.......
Negan: I am too tired to give Lucille her best....say kid, do you know how to finger wrestle?
Funny thing is, I also thought about that. Glad I'm not the only one
I would totally see Kenny going out like Abraham, taking it like a champ!
haahahhaahaha. "Shuts that shit down"
When you say that, It reminds me the sorrow that Clem must feel being the only survivor of her groups. I wonder if that lingers in mind and feels responsible for that?
I think Negan would be amused and a bit disgusted at the amount of responsibility the adults place on Clementine.
Wasn't Luke the leader of the cabin group? I think Kenny would be the first to go. I can see Nick breaking loose and getting Mike killed. Did Negan know Maggie was pregnant? She didn't seem to be showing yet. Negan could threaten the baby to seal Luke's obedience.
It'd probably be Kenny. He'd get picked, say one of his almighty Kenny lines and then get the bat.
Clementine or Sarah would probably make the most impact for shock value. Two young and innocent characters. Kenny wouldn't be sitting there when the guy does his eenie meenie shit so he would probably die trying to kill him. Anyway the character is an overpowered cartoon, a joke, a classic sign of what happens when a show is suffering from creative exhaustion - so hopefully he never appears in the games.
If it were the Governor's crew (Governor, Merle, Andrea, Martinez, etc) I reckon they would just bum rush him at the same time and hope to kill him. They would all die yeah, but better to go down like that instead of being his bitch. That's the beauty of a crew that isn't one big happy family. You don't have to worry about keeping anyone else alive.
If that happened in S2EP5 I don't think Telltale would make us wait two years for Season 3 to find out who Negan killed... would they? XD
They might lol games take time and money to make perfect just like a show but a show has locations, actors and such all ready. In a game you have to create it from scratch.
Yeah, but I mean, I don't think Telltale would pull such cliffhanger on us. I think they'd cut to black once Negan leaves. "Ta ta..."
Well they can release the next part as a DLC if they did something like that.
Kenny's last words: "Heh. Fucker."
"Eeny meeny miny m..." - Negan
"I don't know what the fuck you're saying, but I know it's bullshit." - Kenny's last words.
Damn I love you Ken.
um you do know negan is from the comics right? he is not some random original character the show made up.
Negan and his gang then proceed to beg Clem for mercy and to let them go.
Definitely. Thanks @BetterToSleep