Your Episode 4 choices
I'm surprised this has not been made yet anyway share your choices I'll share mine once I remember what they were XD .
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
I'm surprised this has not been made yet anyway share your choices I'll share mine once I remember what they were XD .
Comments
Ok I found out what the choices were
Edit: Firgot to include that I agreed to the Jokers Favour and I also sent Harvey to Arkham.
Promised the Joker a favor (I know this'll cost me eventually, but i'm in Arkham. Might as well have a little fun.)
Made the phone call to Gordon
Rammed the barricade
Visited Harvey as Batman
Went to Wayne Manor and sent Harvey to Blackgate
Denied Joker a favour (because that's never going to be anything good).
Tried to stop the fight Never thought I'd feel sorry for Victor but I couldn't let the guy kill someone for the sake of a cut.
Rammed the Barricade. Bruce does not listen to cash grabbers like that.
Went to Harvey as Batman. Probably regretted it, but like Alfred said I figured that he respects Batman more, and I was happy I saved Gordon.
Went to Wayne Manor instead of Wayne Enterprises. Pros: Alfred is not dead. Wayne Manor's ok. Harvey is off the board. Cons: Batcave and all tech is offline. Penguin is loose. Harvey now likely not able to be saved from himself.
Had Harvey sent to Blackgate instead of Arkham It's a little harsh since he wasn't in his right mind, but there is no way that Arkham is going to be a safer environment, especially with Joker and the like.
-Owed Joker a favor.
-Made the phone call.
-Called Gordon.
-Payed off the guards.
-Visited Harvey as Batman.
-Went to Wayne Enterprises.
-Knocked out Oz.
Am I the only one who didn't owe the Joker? You guys do know who he is, right?
I decided to have Bruce promise him a favor, because 1) Bruce doesn't know who he is, even though the player does, and 2) I thought whatever consequences it might bring could be interesting.
Besides, if that favor involves something evil or crazy you could always have Bruce refuse. The Joker won't be happy I imagine, but that's part of the fun.
Denied Joker a favor
Stopped the fighting
Rammed the barricade
Visited Harvey as Batman
Went to Wayne Enterprises [Regrets it seeing the other option]
Restrained Penguin
I also wish you could've been less violent towards Oswald... like you just instantly went to break his bones, of course I'd probably do it anyway but I'd like to have the option instead of forcing me to do it; be interesting to see in other playthroughs.
I owed Joker a favor (Eh, I'm fair when it comes to getting out)
Followed Joker' s advice (He seemed pretty experienced)
Paid the Enforcer (Didn't want to break the law and make things deeper and worse)
Choose to visit Harvey as Batman (By this point I had enough of Harvey, to be honest I wanted to send him to the fucking hospital, it's time for action)
Chose to stop Harvey and I sent his punkass to Arkham Asylum (I didn't want Alfred to face danger alone and potential get killed, besides family is important)
Fair point, but my Bruce was pretty distrustful of him from the first (though that's probably because of me) especially with how he seemed to have graced himself with the staff. For the Joker I admit he is playing things very differently to normal, which is interesting.
And going by how the Joker tends to deal with denial in the comics I figured I'd let him down now. Don't wanna come back to Wayne Manor and find Alfred dead with a horrible smile stuck on his face.
Bruce really does have poor taste in friends, doesn't he, given that both screw him over (though at least Oswald has a valid reason I guess).
Especially when you're the 10% who didn't go with Selina just for the very reason you were afraid Harvey would snap...
BFFs right? Telltale with their branching; I really hope episode 5 has a REALLY high impact unlike the Rule/Reject Hyperion choice. Hoping for some Rodrik/Asher branching but better.
Perhaps too experienced right? Seemed a bit to interested in Bruce... I hope he knows a bit less then he's leading on.
I definitely think there will be major consequences with the final decision for Episode 5, since we'll either have Penguin OR Two-Face to worry about alongside Lady Arkham, and you'll either have a destroyed Wayne Manor (and a possibly dead Alfred) or the Batcave offline.
Personally, i think it's wise to go after Harvey first. Sure you can take the Penguin down but that still leaves the children and Harvey to split your attention. Take down Harvey and you can focus squarely on the children in episode 5. I didn't want to send Harvey to prison but i didn't feel safe sending him to Arkham..
I didn't accept the Joker's deal- I wasn't quite sure I would like whatever terms he would make up in the future.
I stopped the fight - Things were getting rather ugly, and I wasn't about to let some orderly get destroyed just to lessen my stay.
Paid the enforcer- I was absolutely exasperated, and paying them off just seemed like the easiest way to go about things. Yeah, it wasn't quite fair for Bruce, but going all bazooka seemed like it would just worsen the situation.
I visited Harvey as Bruce- I wanted to attempt once again to straighten things out on a more personal level. From the image and dialogue, it seemed that Batman would threaten Harvey instead of talking things through, and I didn't want to waste an opportunity as Harvey's idol.
I went after Harvey and sent him to Arkham- I still believe in Harvey Dent, and I didn't want to see my friend destroy himself any further. Allowing him to continue his rampage would just be incredibly damaging to Harvey himself, Bruce, and the entirety of Gotham. As for the Asylum, there's hope for him there, no matter how small. Prison may be a safer bet in some ways, but there's no opportunities to receive the help he needs.
Yeah it was more wiser but tbh I thought it was just going to be like who to go to find Aunty Greenleaf or finding the mirror shard(Didn't realize the episode was almost over, time flies) and you'd just end up going to the other place after. So I figured to have Alfred hide out while I get my tech fixed then bounce back and take down Dent. Obviously, things didn't go as planned and was shocked when I saw the end title screen.
Did not owe Joker a favour. - He was super cryptic and completely avoided what it was. So, odds are, not good later on.
Stopped the fight. - Okay, here, I mostly did it to see what happens if I didn't make the call, and how I'd get out that way. I also played it as if Bruce was still being influenced by the drug to have violent tendencies. He sees violence, he goes for violence.
Payed the toll to the guard. - I figured it'd just make things much worse for Bruce against these guys, so I thought paying them would get them on my side, or at least leave me alone for a while. Plus, isn't Bruce a billionaire?
Talk with Harvey as Bruce. - In my playthrough, I saved Harvey, making him idolise Batman. Alfred mentioned him being unpredictable, erratic, which made me think the choice you made wouldn't be exactly how you thought it'd go down. I also thought that Harvey could hunt Batman, and keep him from helping Gotham, maybe he wants to be the only protection for Gotham, not having Batman do it his own way. And, I kind of wanted to test the waters with Harvey and see just how fargone he is off the edge. Turns out, he's insane. Guess Batman will deal with him later.
Stop Oswald's control on Wayne Enterprises. - I really, really wanted to go save Alfred, but having compromised Wayne Tech wouldn't be good. If I saved Harvey, I thought something would go wrong, the tech would go haywire and cause unintended damage to people. Batman's best tactics involve his weapons, so I needed to get them back online, that way, I could take on any threat. You better not be dead by the time I get back home, Alfred. Or I'll kill Dent.
P.s.: Could someone tell me what the web choices for this episode were? Seems the website forgot all of my Batman choices, so you'd help quite a bit.
Why do so many of you suspect that Alfred is dead? Bruce clearly tells him to hide out in the Bat Cave. I'm sure his house is burned down but his Bat Cave will still be intact. Alfred will be fine guys
best episode yet by far, imho. especially loved calling for "backup" during the fight with Harvey.
I promised Joker a favor. Words are wind, like we would say in the Game of Thrones forum
I didn't go with his plan, my Bruce wouldn't risk letting someone get killed. Besides, during the whole time, I was thinking "I don't really have to warn anyone or call my lawyers, I have the best goddamn butler in the world to take care of this!". Really, who would I call? It is not like Alfred didn't know Bruce was there. Oh, also I gave the key to one of the guys that work at the Asylum. I'm pretty sure the Joker wasn't supposed to have it to begin with :P
I rammed the barricade because honestly I was just as fed up with that bull as Bruce was.
I went as Batman to see Harvey because I am sick and tired of trying to reason with him. The man is crazy.
I went home. Both Alfred and Lucius are there in my game, and Harvey is completely out of his mind. Hell if I would risk leaving Alfred and Lucius alone with him. Even if Lucius wasn't there, no one touches my Alfred.
I have no regrets.
I promised Joker a favor
I broke up the fight instead of going for the phone
Drove through the enforcer
I visited Harvey as Bruce
Went to Wanye Manor
Sent Harvey to prison
1.Eh sure this could be fun later on.
2.Ok, someone might have gotten stabbed to death but heck I wasn't gonna stay there.
3.Better than the alternative.
4.Sounds pretty naive but I still have hope for him!
5.I wasn't gonna let Alfred deal with that by himself.
I immediately regretted making that choice after hearing Bruce's dialog.
So I shut the game and started over. xp
I kinda did too, but Arkham would probably just do the same. i dont really want him meeting Joker.
Yeah, I was thinking that at first but they presented the choice like either serve Justice or give him help. Besides, I think that Doctor at Arkham legitimately wants to help people. I just hope she doesn't become Harley or something.
Just because I promise him doesn't mean I'm going to go through with it, it was more of just telling him what I wanted him to hear so I can get his help. He's the fucking Joker, you think I'm actually going to help him...although, it could be fun to see what it is.
I needed to get the hell out of there, of course I'm going to make a call.
Bruce is already being viewed negatively, so paying him off seemed like the better of the two options.
He needed a friend to try and get him to see reason. There's still some good in my Harvey, it just needs to come back out.
In order to stop the Children of Arkham, I need Batman to be unhindered, saving the Manor is just not as important as the tech.
Owed the Joker a favor - Because how could this possibly go wrong
Stopped the fighting - I might have had an opportunity to get out, but how I'm playing Bruce, he would still want to help people. His goal as Batman of trying to save people would take priority over trying to get out of Arkham.
Rammed the barricade - I'd rather not fund the enemy, especially when there's another option.
Visited Harvey as Bruce - I thought I could still get through to him. I'm one of the people that still believe Harvey can come back from this. That the old Harvey's still in there, we just need to break through the delusions.
Stopped Harvey - I'm not risking anyone hurting Alfred, no way. I'd rather risk my tech than risk Alfred getting hurt.
Sent Harvey to Arkham - Both of these choices have a chance of backfiring, but I still believe Arkham's the best chance to help him. While there's a chance he could get worse, the people there might still be able to help him, like Batman says. Besides, I'm already betting on it; Joker's going to get out of Arkham. Watch there be an after-credits scene in episode 5 of Joker leaving Arkham, ready to wreak havoc on Gotham.
Owed the Joker a favor - I guess it was only fair. I shouldn't of played fair with a psychopath though.
Went for the phone - Figured this was my only way out and I didn't want to waste it.
Rammed the barricade - I didn't trust the guards. Figured they'd let them go ahead and bang up the car more.
Visited Harvey as Batman - Harvey had half a face and going nuts. I didn't think I could help him.
Went to Wayne Tower - I could sacrifice my tech, but I couldn't let Alfred die.
Sent Harvey to Blackgate - Harvey can't be saved now. I don't think he can, especially since he's Two-Face in my save. So like any murderer he has to go to prison and face the consequences of what he has done.
I think I remained silent toward Joker when he asked for a favor. I'm not going to owe ANY insane person a favor. I can endure Arkham.
I tried to stop the fight. I'm partially responsible, so I tried to stop it.
I paid the enforcer. I just needed to get away before the drugs caused me to do more harm; I was already recorded threatening to kill someone.
I met Harvey as Bruce Wayne. I want to save Harvey, but it's too late I guess.
I went to Wayne Enterprises. I already saw the trouble it caused me at Vales with Penguin hacking my stuff, and taking control of the Batmobile? No. I need that. It's the priority, not my home.
I knocked Penguin out. I restrained myself all the time not attacking him, but that was Bruce. I'm BATMAN.
Loved the episode, really loved it. I just wish it was longer, felt way too short.
Denied Joker's Favor
Used the phone
Paid Harvey's People Off
Choose to visit Harvey As Bruce
Choose to go to Wayne Enterprises
For some reason, I did not enjoy this episode as much as the others, least favorite so far... huh.
Got to give Telltale props for making some REALLY hard choices in this episode (I mean look at that 50/50 split).
Can anyone get the extra choices to work?
But taking down the Penguin doesn't eliminate the children so now your attention will still be split between Harvey and Vicki in episode 5. I took down Harvey so he'd be out of the way and i'd be able to focus solely on the children/Penguin & Vicki. Saving Alfred and Lucius, two people Bruce cares about is more important then tech any day (In my opinion). Plus, I don't think it was a choice of which was more important the manor or the tech. I think it was Alfred or the tech.
I think the choice was more geared towards Alfred or the tech, not the manor or the tech.
Huh. I figured Alfred would be fine no matter what (he's not going to stand his ground against thugs when Batman's not coming and he can get out of there) so I just made the decision based on me not just sitting back and letting some guy steal my home.