Why is Doug not shown until the walkers ramp up their attack on the pharmacy? The entire time Lee and Kenny are arguing with Larry about Duck, Doug is nowhere to be seen, let alone voice an opinion.
I thought it was one of the better episodes WITH character development. It was the only lull in the game, not in a boring way. You could actually strike conversations with the characters. It felt more organic than the interactions at Howe's.
I don't think of these as plot holes as much as being unrealistic.
* Why would Lee not pack a bag with clothes and food for Clementine … morebefore they left her house?
* Why do only the adults have winter jackets in the 3 month time skip at the motel?
Um? But before being left on the side of the road or taken in the RV, Lilly says "I'm a murderer? You've had Lee with you this whole time. He didn't tell you? He killed before this, he was a convicted murderer", words to that effect anyway. Larry must have told her. Lee even assumes to Carley by saying "her and Larry spoke obviously". I'd also say Larry told Lilly as soon as possible so she was made aware that he could be dangerous
Well, that's what I'm gettin at: her reaction if you tell her suggests she didn't actually know because Larry did say there was "something" … moreabout Lee but she know what to know, which gives me the impression that he didn't actually tell her the whole story for whatever reason.
Which, considering he asks Lee if he likes Lilly before he reveals that he knows about his past, sends some interesting mixed messages.
I brought that up above specifically as the plot hole: her reaction if you tell her yourself suggests that Larry never told her all the details, just that he doesn't trust Lee for some reason. So if all she had to go on was essentially an unspecified hunch, how did she find out he was a murderer?
Um? But before being left on the side of the road or taken in the RV, Lilly says "I'm a murderer? You've had Lee with you this whole time. H… moree didn't tell you? He killed before this, he was a convicted murderer", words to that effect anyway. Larry must have told her. Lee even assumes to Carley by saying "her and Larry spoke obviously". I'd also say Larry told Lilly as soon as possible so she was made aware that he could be dangerous
Ah i see. The thing is though, if you sided against her in the meat locker, and then reveal your past to her and say i killed before this, sent down for murder" or words similar to that and she says "you think that's news?" which also tells me that she was told the details by Larry. I guess in that scenario it makes it clearer than in the one you mentioned where she sounded like she didn't know all the details. Maybe in the other scenario where she is nice to Lee, she said it to spare his feelings instead of saying "yeah I know your a murderer". Guess we'll never know for sure
I brought that up above specifically as the plot hole: her reaction if you tell her yourself suggests that Larry never told her all the deta… moreils, just that he doesn't trust Lee for some reason. So if all she had to go on was essentially an unspecified hunch, how did she find out he was a murderer?
Dougs lack of interaction with anyone or being involved in virtually no scenes except that one with Lee and his brother is why originally 76% i think of players chose Carley over him. I prefer Carley's scenario anyway for story purposes as it felt as though there was more interesting scenes and bzckground to her character. I did like Doug's scenario as well but just not as much
Why is Doug not shown until the walkers ramp up their attack on the pharmacy? The entire time Lee and Kenny are arguing with Larry about Duck, Doug is nowhere to be seen, let alone voice an opinion.
Hmm...maybe. I do recall that line from my recent playthrough and I think another way of looking at it would be that Larry simply let on that there was "something" about Lee, never actually told her all the details for whatever reason(again, "You like my daughter?"), and what Lee does at the St. John's farm tells her everything she needs to know.
"Oh, you say you're murderer, Lee? Well, I already know that. First. Hand."
Ah i see. The thing is though, if you sided against her in the meat locker, and then reveal your past to her and say i killed before this, s… moreent down for murder" or words similar to that and she says "you think that's news?" which also tells me that she was told the details by Larry. I guess in that scenario it makes it clearer than in the one you mentioned where she sounded like she didn't know all the details. Maybe in the other scenario where she is nice to Lee, she said it to spare his feelings instead of saying "yeah I know your a murderer". Guess we'll never know for sure
When I was playing Season 2 Episode 2 I had to leave during the first chapter so I shut it down and came back later. It should've remembered that I went with Pete since that was on the first Episode all together. Nope, when I restarted it put me with Nick so I had to replay Episode 1 so that I could reset Clem being with Peter.
So after restarting a couple of times later I realized that I don't think it was remembering some other choices as well, so I think if the choices are like 0 and 1 the 0 choice is the default to it sets it back to that.
I'm going to be interested in seeing how they do a set-up where you can fill in the pre-choices before playing Season 3.
You know what is something of an inconsistent plot hole as far as I know: how did Lilly find out Lee was a killer? She had no proof, and I d… moreon't recall Larry or anyone else telling her that...
If you tell her, she simply realizes that it must be why Larry was so against you, at least on friendly playthroughs. However, should you consider kicking her out(and possibly even if you let her stay, idk) she tells everyone as proof that she's willing to forgive, which implies that she knew for some time.
Unless we're meant to assume that Larry kept a diary or something.
Why is Lee ditching a lot of useful weapons?
* He gets rid of the police officer's shotgun after killing it, who cares if it was out of… more ammo? It's always possible to encounter more than one walker when you're moving on, he could have searched the corpse of the officer to see if he had any spare ammo and even if you didn't have ammo, you could just smack them with the gun.
* Lee immediately gets rid of Clem's hammer after killing Sandra for no reason.
* Lee ditches the screwdriver after killing the walker stuck by the car at the motel, who cares if he purchases a better weapon? He could just given it to Glenn to watch his back if anything was going to hell. Hell, it could have been useful for Doug to kill the walkers at the window of the drugstore which wouldn't have led us to the tough situation.
* Lee doesn't pick up the weapon he chose in the meat locker after the fight with Danny St. John.
* Lee doesn't reclaim his axe aft… [view original content]
This is more a Walking Dead Plothole. Where is the rain storm in Georgia? In the novel, there's a big storm in the first year of the outbreak, but is never shown in Season 1 in the game nor during the time that Rick and Co are at the prison.
Comments
I noticed that too last week. Somebody mentioned that he originally had a few other scenes, including a sequence with him and Lee trapping B cut.
What interactions?
They trapped who?
B Everett, Lee's brother.
Carver's spiel
Bonnie's apology tour
Troy barking orders
Reggie in general
Kenny tucking in Clementine's "pockets"
I meant to put a smiley face to show that I was joking. Of those things, Bonnie and especially Kenny were the only worthwhile things in the longrun.
Why doesn't Lee leave a note at Clem's house, in case Clem's family member arrives trying to find her?
Um? But before being left on the side of the road or taken in the RV, Lilly says "I'm a murderer? You've had Lee with you this whole time. He didn't tell you? He killed before this, he was a convicted murderer", words to that effect anyway. Larry must have told her. Lee even assumes to Carley by saying "her and Larry spoke obviously". I'd also say Larry told Lilly as soon as possible so she was made aware that he could be dangerous
I brought that up above specifically as the plot hole: her reaction if you tell her yourself suggests that Larry never told her all the details, just that he doesn't trust Lee for some reason. So if all she had to go on was essentially an unspecified hunch, how did she find out he was a murderer?
Ah i see. The thing is though, if you sided against her in the meat locker, and then reveal your past to her and say i killed before this, sent down for murder" or words similar to that and she says "you think that's news?" which also tells me that she was told the details by Larry. I guess in that scenario it makes it clearer than in the one you mentioned where she sounded like she didn't know all the details. Maybe in the other scenario where she is nice to Lee, she said it to spare his feelings instead of saying "yeah I know your a murderer". Guess we'll never know for sure
Dougs lack of interaction with anyone or being involved in virtually no scenes except that one with Lee and his brother is why originally 76% i think of players chose Carley over him. I prefer Carley's scenario anyway for story purposes as it felt as though there was more interesting scenes and bzckground to her character. I did like Doug's scenario as well but just not as much
Hmm...maybe. I do recall that line from my recent playthrough and I think another way of looking at it would be that Larry simply let on that there was "something" about Lee, never actually told her all the details for whatever reason(again, "You like my daughter?"), and what Lee does at the St. John's farm tells her everything she needs to know.
"Oh, you say you're murderer, Lee? Well, I already know that. First. Hand."
I think that some of the choices get forgotten.
When I was playing Season 2 Episode 2 I had to leave during the first chapter so I shut it down and came back later. It should've remembered that I went with Pete since that was on the first Episode all together. Nope, when I restarted it put me with Nick so I had to replay Episode 1 so that I could reset Clem being with Peter.
So after restarting a couple of times later I realized that I don't think it was remembering some other choices as well, so I think if the choices are like 0 and 1 the 0 choice is the default to it sets it back to that.
I'm going to be interested in seeing how they do a set-up where you can fill in the pre-choices before playing Season 3.
Okay, apparently Larry did tell Lilly everything about Lee and she just didn't wanna believe it until what happened in the meat locker.
Lee's logic sucks.
That's a novel plothole, not of literally all other TWD media.
Christa is currently in a plot hole right now. She's been there since the start of season 2 and it has just gotten deeper and deeper.