What Past Characters would you guys like to Return in TWD Season 3: A New Frontier

So with Kenny & Jane probably going to be killed off in Episodes 1 or 2. I was wondering what other past characters would you guys like to see make a return.

Comments

  • None tbh i find it unrealistic

  • edited December 2016

    I'm not sure I want any to be honest, besides the people you ended season 2 with, but I'm not directly opposed given that it's written in properly and not just "I got lucky, real lucky."

  • edited December 2016

    #NoReturningCharacters

  • 7th times the charm, no?

    Originally, I was all for characters like Lilly, Taavia, and Arvo getting another chance but that sentiment has been decreasing as time went on and more information was finally revealed.

  • Other than AJ and the character you saved at the end of Season, no one should return.

  • edited December 2016

    I'd like Lilly to return, but she won't. It actively irritates me how we lack closure for Christa, though- there's no way Clem would've just given up on her entirely. Clem spent longer with her than she did with Lee!!

  • Not many to choose from.

  • Would be cool to see Molly again, doubt we will though.

  • Kenny
    Shel
    Becca
    Nate

    Flashbacks:

    Christa
    Edith (most interesting character that had hardly any screentime for me)
    Lee
    Clementines parents (a pre apocalypse flashback would be nice)

  • Totally agree with Christa.

    I'd like Lilly to return, but she won't. It actively irritates me how we lack closure for Christa, though- there's no way Clem would've just given up on her entirely. Clem spent longer with her than she did with Lee!!

  • Sean Vanaman and Jake Rodkin.

  • enter image description here

    enter image description here

    enter image description here

    enter image description here

    and especially...

    enter image description here

    Aside if possible any of the other survivors from the Michonne mini-series, need I say more?

  • Christa my opinion because you don't know if she survived or not.

  • I think it would be realistic if it's Nate because his fate is non determinant and has a truck.

    zeke10 posted: »

    None tbh i find it unrealistic

  • So basically everyone that might be alive? :p

    MaconMajr posted: »

    and especially... Aside if possible any of the other survivors from the Michonne mini-series, need I say more?

  • edited December 2016

    Because I'm bored, I'm gonna repost my previous musings here:

    December 4
    It's funny, I was originally open to seeing Arvo (and a few other characters) return, but I've since had retroactive slight shift in opinion. Something about the way the New Frontier is being built up and the Sophomore Slump that is Season 2(namely the second half) makes me very iffy about a character like Arvo in particular being in the game. Funny, cause Mr. Ark actually resembles one of the redesigns I thought up for Arvo.

    .

    November 26
    As an example of "Your choices matter," I think Lilly would work better if it was a little of both objectively speaking, depending on her potential role and how much her previous interaction with Lee would bias her placement. Personally, I'd like her to be either an uneasy ally or friendly enemy; same with anyone else like Becca, Mike, and/or Arvo. As I recall posting in the Unpopular Opinions thread a while ago, it kinda annoys me how she suddenly became the bad gal in favor of Kenny as far as anyone can tell. To be fair, it made sense back when she was supposed to be the start of darkness for a comic book villain of the same name, but now the odds are retroactively not stacked in her favor. Don't get me wrong, I definitely don't approve of what she did to Doug/Carley or what she tried to do to Ben, but at the same time, I'm not a fan of the whole "this character fucked up and therefore they deserve die" mentality, with Kenny and/or Jane being the only exception(s). Having Clementine be very uneasy about seeing her again would make the most sense, though I'm not sure if Season 3 will take proper advantage of the timeskip to make Clementine NOT want to tolerate Lilly's presence justified.

    .

    October 27
    Expecting
    Lilly
    Sam
    Paige
    Jane

    Probably
    Christa
    Mike

    Would Love
    Adam
    Tavia
    Arvo

    Wouldn't mind
    Becca
    Danielle

    Certain Conditions
    Kenny
    Sarah
    Jaime

    .

    October 11
    Arvo is a bit of an overrated character if I'm being honest, but not without reason.

    Honestly, one thing I hope Season 3 takes advantage of is flashbacks that develop previous characters in addition to Clementine. One of the many issues I had with Season 2 as it proceeded was that Clementine's character, opinions, and feelings about certain things felt like they were being ignored or downplayed in favor of giving Kenny and Jane prominence at every other junction. This even extended to certain characters, like Sarah, Mike, and Arvo himself, being boiled down to the basic characteristics and biased views for the sake of just having things happen with them without actually focusing on their characters.

    So, if Arvo does show up again, I hope they'll do the fair thing and try to develop him a little while he does whatever it is his role entails.

    .

    August 28
    Lily because her exit left a bunch of doors open.
    Danielle and Adam because drama...
    Becca and Taavia have potential to be characters with neat continuity nods
    "Sarah" because drama....
    Mike and Arvo for untapped character potential and an enemy's unexpected return storyline. Bonnie can show up with them or not.

    .

    August 13
    Sarah, Becca, and/or Taavia so Clementine and Jane can answer for some of the more selfish/destructive things they've done in the past, good or bad.

    Also, Sam Everett as a side thing.

  • It would be cool to see Christa or Lilly again, but I hope there are just new characters in S3, with Clem being the exception. I didn't care enough about Luke's group when Kenny returned in S2 and I don't want that happening again in S3. Also, if Clem doesn't return to Georgia, then the odds of anyone from the past finding Clem aren't great anyway.

  • How dare Wyatt be close to my favorite color.

    MaconMajr posted: »

    and especially... Aside if possible any of the other survivors from the Michonne mini-series, need I say more?

  • Nate, along with Christa, are the ones that I consider the least unlikely to return.

    I think it would be realistic if it's Nate because his fate is non determinant and has a truck.

  • Yeah but Christa never really liked Clementine, she was pretty rude with her in S2, and in the beginning she and Omid leave her alone to have sex in a bathroom, Lee cared way more about Clem.

    I'd like Lilly to return, but she won't. It actively irritates me how we lack closure for Christa, though- there's no way Clem would've just given up on her entirely. Clem spent longer with her than she did with Lee!!

  • I hate Lilly but it would be so cool to see her especially with staying with Kenny ending

  • Give or take, yeah.

    Nikolaj-11 posted: »

    So basically everyone that might be alive?

  • You and me both. Driving me crazy, I have to know. She's one of the few of the original group of survivors.

    Shadow2122 posted: »

    Christa my opinion because you don't know if she survived or not.

  • Michelle did shoot Omid with Clementine's gun. I'm sure Christa did not fail to notice that.

    Hawkes posted: »

    Yeah but Christa never really liked Clementine, she was pretty rude with her in S2, and in the beginning she and Omid leave her alone to have sex in a bathroom, Lee cared way more about Clem.

    • Kenny or Jane in an actual role rather than an off-camera death
    • Christa
    • Bonnie, if alive at the end of season 2

    Lilly could return, but I'm cool with her not turning up. I left her behind. It seems like the best end for her character in some way.

  • telltale please, just give me christa or lilly. you've been constantly answering questions and talking about them. please. like even if they both come back and then die five minutes later, please.

  • Within the realm of possibility, Christa and Arvo, since they're not dead (not even determinantly, like Bonnie) or plagued with legal issues (Lilly).

  • What legal issues?

    Within the realm of possibility, Christa and Arvo, since they're not dead (not even determinantly, like Bonnie) or plagued with legal issues (Lilly).

  • Wrestlingdead hit it quite damn well, I almost forgot about Nate. I would love to see Nate again, he's someone you can hate easily yet still some charisma there.

  • *lilly maybe Andy if lee spared him *

  • Jane, she finished what Lee wasn't able to.

  • What, getting stabbed in the chest? That's not really an achievement.

    Sardorim posted: »

    Jane, she finished what Lee wasn't able to.

  • Well, when you put it like that, I suppose you could say that. Though Christa arguably taught the beginners/apprentice course beforehand.

    Sardorim posted: »

    Jane, she finished what Lee wasn't able to.

  • enter image description here

    Oh, I love that fanfic!

    MaconMajr posted: »

    and especially... Aside if possible any of the other survivors from the Michonne mini-series, need I say more?

  • Been meaning to get around to it. Maybe the first of next year, give or take.

    Oh, I love that fanfic!

  • uh?

    MaconMajr posted: »

    Been meaning to get around to it. Maybe the first of next year, give or take.

  • I meant getting to read it. It's been on my reading list, but with my work life, I can't find the time. Hence, I'll try early January next year to start, probably.

    uh?

  • Didn't mention arvo.

    Nikolaj-11 posted: »

    So basically everyone that might be alive?

Sign in to comment in this discussion.