Lee
This question is sort of tongue-in-cheek and maybe half-serious, but hear me out...
Could Lee still be alive? Could he have been immune to the infection? Could Clementine have missed the shot?
Just... just tell me how each of those questions are ludicrous. Give me evidence where Clementine says she "shot lee".
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
inb4 someone says "not this thread again", why are you so eager to dismiss it? Isn't it possible?
Maybe we didn't see it but lee is shot at the head
Robert said there is no such thing that call cure or immune in the walking dead he not gonna put it and no one is going to till he want and as long is TWD telltale series is in the same with the comic the telltale will not dare to put it
he actually said that? do you have a source for that? would be much appreciated
I read it that a life time ago and actually not the tybe of guy who save the sources of his informations even if i take it a one day ago i will froget were i did read it
Sorry i don't remember where and even when i read it but i am sure of it
Its possible if you didnt tell Clem to shoot you, BUT, it would be really stupid and dumb, Lees death was really well made, and constituted huge growth for Clementines character, and if he was magically alive, it would ruin the moment of Lees death, and it would also go against the theme of The Walking Dead, which is "there is no happy endings"
I'm just shooting in the dark here. I'm more interested in the possibility of him coming back, rather than whether The Walking Dead community would like that or not, which I think is a separate issue. It's wholly possible that if you chose the gun option, Clementine could have shot the wall instead. I don't see why that couldn't have happened.
Kit Harington (Game of Thrones) said Jon Snow was dead... I've seen these kinds of comments before. I mean, that guy may be head of communications, but it's not exactly a convincing tweet or a full-stop to the whole thing.
As long as the possibility in the plot for him to still be alive remains, it's hard for me to believe anything anyone says.
It would have the vague chance of being possible if the choice to cut off Lee's arm or not wasn't left to the player. If his arm was taken off every time, it could be stretched to be a possibility.
We know cutting off the bitten limb can stop a person from turning but not only does Lee have the chance of keeping his arm, if he does cut it off then so much time has passed that whatever was in that zombie's bite would already be well into his system.
But put that aside and assume the cutting off his arm is the 'canon' story. Could Clem have missed? Sure. Could Molly have shown up with a lockpick and a convenient bag of antibiotics? Well it's possible I suppose.
In the end what puts an end to any chance of Lee still being alive was Telltale giving us the choice over his arm. Once they made that a player choice, Lee's fate was sealed.
Job Stauffer works at Telltale and he fucking confirmed Lee was fucking dead. Just because Lee was the protagonist of S1, doesn't mean he gets to survive better than other survivors. Even if Clem didn't shoot, doesn't mean he is alive, he is fucking dead. This is how me and @MetallicaRules feel like when people think Lee is alive.
So, in your opinion, the determinant arm-cutting is the all-consuming veto over this being an impossibility? What if Lee had the gene, or the immunity to the bite? That would at least make the arm-cutting irrelevant.
Sorry, but saying "he's dead" a hundred times doesn't make it so. The plot still says him being alive is a possibility. If Job really wanted to put an end to this fiasco, then show his dead body, give us something that would confirm that he's gone.
Lee is not coming back.
Get over it.
Where? Lee was less mentioned in Season 3.
He already did, Lee was not Season 2 and he is not in Season 3. You really think Job would make Lee return?
When I saw this thread I was like:
Because we haven't seen him die. We heard a gunshot, and we saw him falling asleep, or go unconscious. That's it.
How is that definitive evidence that Lee is dead? He could very easily just pop up in season 3, season 4, season 5, etc.
Not an argument.
I'm afraid it is. The choice to remove his arm or not means his fate was sealed. We know both events have the possibility of occurring because of Clem's reaction to Luke's joke in season 2 about losing a limb. But player choice bumps up against the need for Telltale to keep the story on a set path. So while having Clem laugh at a joke or not is possible, having Lee survive the bite is not.
Also no-one in the Walking Dead universe is immune. That's not to say that there isn't a possibility of it but if there were to be such a person, I think Kirkman would want to use that story element for himself and not have it happen in spin-off media.
As long as immunity is a possibility, Lee being alive is a possibility. I don't think you can be 100% certain either way on this.
DID YOU FUCKING FORGET HE GOT BITTEN AND WAS PALE AT THE END OF SEASON 1?????!!!!!!! I'm telling you again for fuck's sakes, just because you didn't see him get shot, doesn't mean he is not dead. In Season 2, Clem has an option which confirms she shot him. Do you want me to slap you or you're just a troll? I'm telling a mod to close this.
Anyone who thinks Lee is alive is not a smart person.
I'm sick of these threads, can they be a weekly discussion instead of daily?
Immunity to the bite may still follow up with symptoms.
This is what I was looking for. Is there a video of her confirming this? I don't remember it.
Do what you want. I'm trying to have a civil discussion and you're acting like a child.
That's better
When was the last time one of these threads came up? I haven't seen one in a while, and I must digress that people saying that they're disappointed over season 3 in threads daily doesn't make their opinions any less valid.
Well of course no-one can be 100% certain of anything except a fanatic, but you have to look at it realistically.
Would Robert Kirkman really let such an important plot point such as an immune survivor happen in a spin-off media, or do you think he'd want to write that story himself in the main series?
Plus I think you are forgetting that the zombie infection wouldn't be the only thing Lee would have to deal with. Keep his arm or not, there is going to be a lot more nasty bacteria festering in that zombie's bite than just the zombie virus. Just look at all the disease causing bacteria in a living dog's mouth, you think a zombie's mouth is going to be less dangerous?
When your opponent starts stating opinions as facts, then he has lost.
lee is dead fam.
Skip to 33:58
Ah, so I'm the one causing trouble because I'm telling the truth.
"Lee is Alive" is one of the worst theories in TWD franchise. Lee Everett is dead, just like:
"Insert any dead characters"
Since when did I ever treat my opinions as facts? Lee is dead which is 100% true.
If it were 100% true, then you would have given me substantiated evidence to prove your claims. You haven't done that. Instead, you've used hyperbole and gifs, neither of which are thoroughly convincing.
Indeed it is, handsome Lee.
In the words of Lee Everett: YOU'RE A DENIAL.
Thanks for the video, and this may surprise you, but I don't consider that proof Lee's dead. Clementine stated "I had to kill him before he turned", which is an... interesting way of putting it. Not once did she state that she shot him. Very interesting indeed.
And yeah, carry on perceiving your views as "the truth".
Not an argument.
Sighs I think you're younger than me.
I told a mod to close this. It will be closed in any second.
If I'm not mistaken, Kirkman has inputs on the Telltale story, right? I have no doubt that Telltale would ask his permission to put in such an impacting plot device before actually going with it, and who's to say that Kirkman would refuse?
No kidding. It is a terrible situation, but it's not impossible to get out of.