Let's just accept that they are dead, Telltale would never do this, we all knew that Telltale would do shit like this to the endings... like they say it's not about the choices, but the story... well.. that's not why Season 1 was big, for us it's about the choices and the story.. They should never have done this. but they are dead.
I do think Jane's death was a huge waste of what could be an amazing character arc for her: her pregnancy.
Let's assume Clem's dream had inconsistencies and she manages to stop Jane before she killed herself (it was a dream, after all). Like, during her pregnancy period we (as Clem) would get a taste of what she went through with Jaime. Taking care of someone who doesn't want to go on. And after the baby was out, we Jane as a character would progress. She would have a change of heart because of the child, and a change on her pragmatic ways. She'd become more human.
After that was done, then cut her off the story. At least we would get a small storyline based on our choices.
The only way Kenny and Jane can be alive is either if you chose the alone with AJ ending, or Telltale retcons the Ken/Jane flashbacks to be just a nightmare Clem had.
That'd actually be a really cool way to end it. Having Jane come to terms with the very thing she said made people a liability would give her a ton of character development, maybe even more than most of the other characters.
That'd be super satisfying, and maybe having her killed off in the end would be a fitting end. It'd be devastating to watch and play through, but I'd take it.
I do think Jane's death was a huge waste of what could be an amazing character arc for her: her pregnancy.
Let's assume Clem's dream had … moreinconsistencies and she manages to stop Jane before she killed herself (it was a dream, after all). Like, during her pregnancy period we (as Clem) would get a taste of what she went through with Jaime. Taking care of someone who doesn't want to go on. And after the baby was out, we Jane as a character would progress. She would have a change of heart because of the child, and a change on her pragmatic ways. She'd become more human.
After that was done, then cut her off the story. At least we would get a small storyline based on our choices.
If people at Telltale were ambitious, they could even make the baby Clem ends up with determinant.
At the end of Jane's subplot, instead of killing her and her baby they could have Clem and her separate, with a twist. Clem would end up with Jaime, and Jane would end up with AJ, both unknow.
It's not that hard to tailor these stories. Considering the determinant characters we would be working with were both mute babies, it wouldn't require much work.
That'd actually be a really cool way to end it. Having Jane come to terms with the very thing she said made people a liability would give he… morer a ton of character development, maybe even more than most of the other characters.
That'd be super satisfying, and maybe having her killed off in the end would be a fitting end. It'd be devastating to watch and play through, but I'd take it.
I do think Jane's death was a huge waste of what could be an amazing character arc for her: her pregnancy.
Let's assume Clem's dream had … moreinconsistencies and she manages to stop Jane before she killed herself (it was a dream, after all). Like, during her pregnancy period we (as Clem) would get a taste of what she went through with Jaime. Taking care of someone who doesn't want to go on. And after the baby was out, we Jane as a character would progress. She would have a change of heart because of the child, and a change on her pragmatic ways. She'd become more human.
After that was done, then cut her off the story. At least we would get a small storyline based on our choices.
Comments
Or just eternal denial.
Still holding on to hope.
Let's just accept that they are dead, Telltale would never do this, we all knew that Telltale would do shit like this to the endings... like they say it's not about the choices, but the story... well.. that's not why Season 1 was big, for us it's about the choices and the story.. They should never have done this. but they are dead.
Wait a minute... Beard... One-eye... One-leg...
Could it be?
Looks like boats are back on the menu, boys!
Nothing wrong with that.
Just imagine, episode 5, off in the distance we see a giant sail boat, with Kenny quickly coming to the rescue!
I do think Jane's death was a huge waste of what could be an amazing character arc for her: her pregnancy.
Let's assume Clem's dream had inconsistencies and she manages to stop Jane before she killed herself (it was a dream, after all). Like, during her pregnancy period we (as Clem) would get a taste of what she went through with Jaime. Taking care of someone who doesn't want to go on. And after the baby was out, we Jane as a character would progress. She would have a change of heart because of the child, and a change on her pragmatic ways. She'd become more human.
After that was done, then cut her off the story. At least we would get a small storyline based on our choices.
If only TellTale could think of these endings instead of what we got.
The only way Kenny and Jane can be alive is either if you chose the alone with AJ ending, or Telltale retcons the Ken/Jane flashbacks to be just a nightmare Clem had.
That'd actually be a really cool way to end it. Having Jane come to terms with the very thing she said made people a liability would give her a ton of character development, maybe even more than most of the other characters.
That'd be super satisfying, and maybe having her killed off in the end would be a fitting end. It'd be devastating to watch and play through, but I'd take it.
Imagine if he lived on and got his hand bitten and amputated. We'd find him a nice hook and he'd become full pirate
That be amazing, clearly when we find out he got away he also got bit on the hand and had to cut it off!
If people at Telltale were ambitious, they could even make the baby Clem ends up with determinant.
At the end of Jane's subplot, instead of killing her and her baby they could have Clem and her separate, with a twist. Clem would end up with Jaime, and Jane would end up with AJ, both unknow.
It's not that hard to tailor these stories. Considering the determinant characters we would be working with were both mute babies, it wouldn't require much work.
But then again,
if people at Telltale were ambitious.
Me to anyone who thinks Insert dead character is alive.
I cant wait for the return of Road Bandit #2
Oh I see, you're still in the denial stage buddy
Just imagine Captain Jack Sparrow's introduction in Pirates of The Caribbean...
But with Kenny.
Interesting! Personally I'd love to have Kenny back. The series isn't the same without him.
Please take a look at my thread
https://telltale.com/community/discussion/112519/what-i-would-have-written-ep1-season-3-ill-try-to-be-brief-but-no-promises
Why...