Why AJ was taken away from Clem?
Why would New frontier do that if they admitted they won't treat AJ with their medicine any longer... Doctor said that Aj was going to die, so what was the point to waste time and resources on dying baby? Unless David wanted to kill him himself because he knew clementine wouldn't be able to put him out of his misery, but why would he do that if he kinda hated Clem?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Because they could at least make AJ as comfortable as possible, even if he's going to die. They could let a teenager leave with a sick toddler and doom him to a potentially gruesome death, or they can keep him with them, where even if AJ dies, he could at least die in relative safety and peace. Besides, I think the implication is that all they did was decide to stop treating him with antibiotics-- it's not like they were going to just let the kid starve to death or something. They would have kept feeding him and doing what they could, just without the medicine.
Dr Lingard makes a comment to that effect depending on your choices
That, and I honestly doubt any of them really have the heart to exile a dying toddler, regardless of the circumstances. I mean, even David says "I wouldn't have let him" in response to Clem asking if he suffered.
And I suppose it doubles as a punishment of its own, if you're going off the way David says it-- "Can't take him with you. That ship has sailed."
For clem to have a reason to stick with havi so we can see her lol telltale needs a storyline for clems existence in this game and it's aj
No I don't think so. Lingard said the medicine would make him comfortable but not help overall, and he still didn't want to give it to him. I think they were "keeping" the medicine. If that makes sense. Otherwise its just cruel.
Isn't that a plothole actually? Clem doesn't know AJ is alive during episode 3. Yet episode 1 and 2 heavily implied Clementines reasons for wanting to go to Richmond is that's where she left AJ or where AJ was taken to or something. But ep3 makes it clear she thought AJ had died....and thought Richmond wasn't controlled by the NF. Her wanting to go there doesn't even make any sense.
Regardless, kick out a teenage girl for giving a sick baby medicine. lmao....
To turn him into Fallout's super mutant.
Suddenly, I'm getting Fallout 4 flashbacks.
EDIT: Also, that is just bad writting.
This makes sense if you gave AJ the medicine, but doesn't actually explain anything if you put the drug back. It's like they taking him for no reason, just to separate them.
Because AJ gets to say his first words. Ugh. Glad it was "Clem" not "mama" or something. I would've cringed the hell out.
Or not giving it at all, remember it was determinant. Kick her out for putting the drug back and take her dying baby while having no interest in treating him... This doesn't make any sense at all.
David, a man with two children. A daughter who is possibly the same age as Clem whom the fate is unknown. Meanwhile a grown adult is high right there.
Dat logic doe
Clems intire storyline this season is a GODDAMN mess in ep 1 and 2 all she wanted was a vehicle and we thought it was to get aj an leave turns out she thought he was dead so she needed to move on I can't believe right now in ep 1 and 2 she was there just to get out of the whole city really telltale that is how you treat the charecter that made you relevant? You're just a bunch of uncreative writers
Clem's role is to lure us back to the franchise, by far she served no purpose except being the familiar face from previous games, for players to be all happy to see her on the screen.
I love Clementine but if she was replaced with anyone else, it wouldn't make the slightest difference.