›

Surprising... I really liked Episode 4... What were YOUR choices?

OfficialMonkeyOfficialMonkey
in The Walking Dead

My choices: enter image description here

^ My choices.

MY REVIEW OF EPISODE 4:
This episode was A LOT better than the last three. The Clementine moments, the Kenny flashback (I teared up a little), the ending (including the ending choice) - goddamn it was good. The start was meh but it picked up at the end. I want this writer to write more episodes. Many determinant characters, many choices (which actually matter). The end choice was hard to pick, I decided to save Ava but then she died because of Joan so I was stuck with Tripp (who already hated me because I shot Conrad in ep2). Episode 4 was good, I loved it (and I hated the previous three episodes). Hard choices, intense, and it had a few HUBS (though they were not as big as S1)

VERDICT: 7.5/10, maybe even an 8/10.

Comments

  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules
    • I promised to help Kate
    • I assisted Lingard's suicide
    • I rejected Kate
    • I tried to save Ava
    • I took the deal

    Overall: 9.2/10

  • AronDraculaAronDracula
    • Promised to look after Kate
    • Killed Lingard
    • Said I didn't feel the same way as Kate
    • Tried to save Ada
    • Shot Joan

    This episode was surprisingly good. Better than the last three.

    8/10

  • BaloeBaloe

    Same choices as OP, but I shot the bitch and it was satisfying as fuck.

    Kenny flashbacks? I ended up alone so I didn't get that one, is it in place of the Ava flashback? Or?

    Call me a fanboy all you like, idc, I liked the episode, I'm excited: 10/10 :p
    Can't wait for e5!!

  • OfficialMonkeyOfficialMonkey

    I agree, it was a surprisingly good episode. Didn't expect to see a good episode this season, glad that Telltale proved me wrong.

    AronDracula posted: »

    * Promised to look after Kate * Killed Lingard * Said I didn't feel the same way as Kate * Tried to save Ada * Shot Joan This episode was surprisingly good. Better than the last three. 8/10

  • BroKennyBroKenny

    -Promised to look after Kate
    -Killed Dr. Lingard
    -Rejected Kate
    -Tried to save Tripp
    -Shot Joan

    Extremely well done episode. Very nice to get some closure and to hug Kenny one last time. I needed that. The present story is fucking awesome too. What started from gas and pudding has escalated into all of this. I cannot WAIT for episode 5. The thing with Tripp made me flip. Luckily I recorded my reaction. I didn't hesitate to shoot that bitch Joan. And Kate....Jesus Christ. Amazing episode! Best of the season! I have very high hopes for episode 5!

    8/10

  • AronDraculaAronDracula

    Don't worry. This episode was awesome. I doubt there won't be anymore people complaining about it.

    Baloe posted: »

    Same choices as OP, but I shot the bitch and it was satisfying as fuck. Kenny flashbacks? I ended up alone so I didn't get that one, is i

  • Jaku2011Jaku2011

    Promised to help Kate
    Didn't kill Lingard
    Romanced Kate
    Tried to save Tripp
    Tried to take the deal

  • bloopbloop
    • Promised to help Kate
    • Didn't kill Lingard
    • Told Kate I felt the same way
    • Tried to save Trip
    • Tried to take the deal
  • fallandirfallandir

    In the minority, as always.

    c

  • BaloeBaloe

    Let's hope they won't :)

    AronDracula posted: »

    Don't worry. This episode was awesome. I doubt there won't be anymore people complaining about it.

  • MartOPMartOP
    • Promised to look after Kate
    • Didn't kill Lingard
    • Said I didn't feel the same way as Kate
    • Tried to save Ava
    • Tried to take the deal
  • OfficialMonkeyOfficialMonkey

    Kenny flashbacks? I ended up alone so I didn't get that one, is it in place of the Ava flashback? Or?

    Kenny first (with an improved model and a pretty well written flashback), then the Ava flashback after - so you still get the Ava flashback.

    Baloe posted: »

    Same choices as OP, but I shot the bitch and it was satisfying as fuck. Kenny flashbacks? I ended up alone so I didn't get that one, is i

  • Creeper1846Creeper1846
    edited April 2017

    I'm always the opposite opinion of people on these forums I thought it was a decent episode not great but decent 7/10 but my choices are...

    -promised to take care of David's family
    -Did not kill Lingard
    -said I felt the same way for Kate
    -Tried to save Tripp
    -Shot Joann (I hated her so fucking much after she just killed Tripp anyway. Even though Tripp was mad at me about Conrad he was still a good character.)

  • BaloeBaloe

    Ah, thought it wouldn't have made sense to not have the Ava one. So if you end up alone, you get a flashback less, aw.
    Thx for clearing that up!

    OfficialMonkey posted: »

    Kenny flashbacks? I ended up alone so I didn't get that one, is it in place of the Ava flashback? Or? Kenny first (with an improved model and a pretty well written flashback), then the Ava flashback after - so you still get the Ava flashback.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.