[Flagged] What would you do - Joans Fate [BIIIIG Ep.5 SPOILER]

edited May 2017 in The Walking Dead

[removed]

Comments

  • I would definitely kick her out of richmond

  • Hmm, kill her I guess. I may replay the series once done to see other possible deaths

  • Enough killing, for fuck's sake. Why this forum always wants to kill everyone?

    Death is an easy way out, if you people want to make her suffer, just kick her out, away from safe stronghold's walls and let her try to survive on her own. Living in such a nightmare is much worse than a quick shot in the head.

  • I already executed her, but if I didn't I'd probably execute her.

    fallandir posted: »

    Enough killing, for fuck's sake. Why this forum always wants to kill everyone? Death is an easy way out, if you people want to make her s

  • Why this forum always wants to kill everyone?

    Probably because it's a post-apocalyptic setting where survival is the #1 priority. Killing will often be a reasonable conclusion.

    fallandir posted: »

    Enough killing, for fuck's sake. Why this forum always wants to kill everyone? Death is an easy way out, if you people want to make her s

  • Well, she's dead in my game, but I would personally kick her out of Richmond.

  • I'd kick her out, killing her seems like too much but keeping her around would be too dangerous.

  • What if I tell you sir that you can be reasonable without murdering everyone on sight.

    Joan deserved to be punished, but banishment would be much worse than death. Condemned to herself, she would understand how hard is to survive outside the walls, how fatiguing and dangerous it is to gather supplies and deal with everything without preparation. She would understand what she's done to other communities and acknowledge the size of her crime.

    lolitsadam posted: »

    Why this forum always wants to kill everyone? Probably because it's a post-apocalyptic setting where survival is the #1 priority. Killing will often be a reasonable conclusion.

  • Because in the walking dead if you spare people it comes back to bite you in the ass.

    fallandir posted: »

    Enough killing, for fuck's sake. Why this forum always wants to kill everyone? Death is an easy way out, if you people want to make her s

  • Please do not make threads to discuss game leaks before the episode's official release. Thanks.

  • I don't quite recall people coming back to me, and I think I was merciful to every character possible and spared them when I had the chance.

    Telltale doesn't care about determinant characters (Conrad's an exception) and it's quite understandable, if they did it would take way to much time and work to keep the game playable, as every player would have a different version of it.

    Chibikid posted: »

    Because in the walking dead if you spare people it comes back to bite you in the ass.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.