I agree with Kennyshouladied to an extent that it's been a good few months now since it was over and posts that generically insult the game are pretty pointless at this stage (not that I really care about stopping the posters doing so though). I also agree with Dan though that season 3 was very disappointing and below the required standard fo what a game should be.
Just to add, the posts expressing anger and disappointment were fine when the season was happening and it was in the heat of the moment I didn't agree with the notion that we should stop criticising the game just to create a nice atmosphere on the board. Even more confusing and bizarre to me were the posters that didn't even like s3 much but would defend it for the sake of creating a positive atmposphere, even though that clearly wasn't the general feeling at the time.
Shoula has a point, dan. I've seen plenty of sour grapes, saltiness, bias steamrolling, and bitching all over the board, but barely 15% of the criticism was actually suggestions on how to improve certain aspects.
Ha shit posts? Really? You mean the posts of me positively defending Kenny whilst day after day you fill your posts with negativity about hi… morem because you've nothing better to do? Those posts? Lol at least i am not negative like you and when i am it's only in reply to your crap or if something i am being critical of is justified.
Guess what? There is a lil button that says "Hide Thread" that you are welcome to click if you hate seeing my "shit posts" lol but yet you don't either because you still obviously have some fascination to them in some way. I will continue to say exactly what i damn well want to say thanks. Tell me this though? How is what i have said not in any way a constructive post? I have stated a lot what i would change about shit season 3 (as i have again above) and you say i never have when evidence proves otherwise. I noticed you failed to acknowledge my points of what would have made season 3 and future TT games better.
Ohh so you think i have grabbed onto other ideas from other people eh? Even though i have been suggesting those things even when Season 2 was still releasing episodes but you won't remember that far back i imagine.
you have never actually stated how exactly you would have improved S3.
What do you expect me to say? I have stated all the things Season 3 needed to have which was basically everything Season 1 had:
Longer episodes - speaks for itself, gives us more of an opportunity to do things, get used to the surrounding, knowing the characters and generally being given more gameplay.
Character interaction and development - you want me to honestly make a story on what to improve? Use your imagination. It would improve this game giving the players chance to ask them questions, learn their life stories, optional choices that carry over and not just the main choices we are forced to go through.
Puzzles, side quests - again this is down to being given longer episodes. There could be more to do at Prescott or other areas, little extra things to spice it up.
I really don't know what else you expect me to say. Everything i and others have previously said about what to improve in this game all speaks for itself.
And finally whatever this strange thing calling me lil Dan you've started, well it's just weird kid. You certainly wouldn't be saying that if you knew how tall i actually was
At least with season 2 i made the effort, weeks of writing before making a thread for an entirely different game that I would have done differently which is more than what can be said for you and numerous others. I suppose that thread i made was a "shit post" too? Even though i got high praise for my original ideas. Here it is in case you forgot that my posts aren't "shit":
Anyway, the fact is, Season 3 isn't worth the effort on what i would improve about it. I think it would take me a whole year to list things i would improve but I gave you the basics on what TT should bring back to the table and that should be enough. Funny i haven't seen the things you would improve about it yet you criticise me for it. Did you make a thread? If so I wouldn't have seen it due to not visiting this shadow of it's former self of a forum in a while
Ya'know what? Fuck it. A New Frontier was a disappointment, not going to lie about that, but that doesn't mean The Final Season is doomed to sub par quality like a lot of people here are saying. It seems like the Telltale staff that made A New Frontier really are trying to take into account fan feedback and learn from their mistakes. Sure there's no telling how The Final Season will turn out, but I have faith that Telltale will do their best to make a satisfying conclusion to Clementine's story.
It won't get better. Actually negative comments are better so they realise that it's not acceptable to lie to the community and fans instead of being yes-men and accepting mediocrity or in this case atrocity.
Anyway, the fact is, Season 3 isn't worth the effort on what i would improve about it. I think it would take me a whole year to list things i would improve but I gave you the basics on what TT should bring back to the table and that should be enough.
Yeah, admittedly I hadn't put too many of my thoughts into text yet in part because not only is at least one of my changes bound to rub some people the wrong way no matter which approach I take, but the last two episodes(emphasis on last) really wrote me into a lot of corners that are hard to get around for various reasons. So ultimately, I'm just having a hard time finding the motivation to actually bother posting.
At least with season 2 i made the effort, weeks of writing before making a thread for an entirely different game that I would have done diff… moreerently which is more than what can be said for you and numerous others. I suppose that thread i made was a "shit post" too? Even though i got high praise for my original ideas. Here it is in case you forgot that my posts aren't "shit":
https://telltale.com/community/discussion/107458/what-changes-to-deceased-determinant-unknown-characters-would-you-make-if-you-could-change-things/p7
Anyway, the fact is, Season 3 isn't worth the effort on what i would improve about it. I think it would take me a whole year to list things i would improve but I gave you the basics on what TT should bring back to the table and that should be enough. Funny i haven't seen the things you would improve about it yet you criticise me for it. Did you make a thread? If so I wouldn't have seen it due to not visiting this shadow of it's former self of a forum in a while
uh... From the series most of these seasons i love Season 1 and just a little bit S2 and idk guys but i lost the story in S3 not much but still i lose a little bit of the story for S4 i can't say nothing and i am not excited for the ''Final Season''.....
Yes very excited to play Clem. Also sad that it's the end. I have enjoyed this game very much. I have not yet finished the last season. I decided to go back and start from the beginning and binge in a 2 night Marathon.
I'm excited that players will be playing as Clem that means no forced romance. No stupid crushes and not being forced to like someone, crush on someone, and not being forced to be in a romance with someone. Players will be able to love who they want and hate who they want and hopefully save who they want like in anf. I really hope they get rid of aj. Idc about the baby either way but I just personally wouldn't want to take care of him.
Comments
I agree with Kennyshouladied to an extent that it's been a good few months now since it was over and posts that generically insult the game are pretty pointless at this stage (not that I really care about stopping the posters doing so though). I also agree with Dan though that season 3 was very disappointing and below the required standard fo what a game should be.
Just to add, the posts expressing anger and disappointment were fine when the season was happening and it was in the heat of the moment I didn't agree with the notion that we should stop criticising the game just to create a nice atmosphere on the board. Even more confusing and bizarre to me were the posters that didn't even like s3 much but would defend it for the sake of creating a positive atmposphere, even though that clearly wasn't the general feeling at the time.
[removed]
Ohh so you think i have grabbed onto other ideas from other people eh? Even though i have been suggesting those things even when Season 2 was still releasing episodes but you won't remember that far back i imagine.
What do you expect me to say? I have stated all the things Season 3 needed to have which was basically everything Season 1 had:
Longer episodes - speaks for itself, gives us more of an opportunity to do things, get used to the surrounding, knowing the characters and generally being given more gameplay.
Character interaction and development - you want me to honestly make a story on what to improve? Use your imagination. It would improve this game giving the players chance to ask them questions, learn their life stories, optional choices that carry over and not just the main choices we are forced to go through.
Puzzles, side quests - again this is down to being given longer episodes. There could be more to do at Prescott or other areas, little extra things to spice it up.
I really don't know what else you expect me to say. Everything i and others have previously said about what to improve in this game all speaks for itself.
And finally whatever this strange thing calling me lil Dan you've started, well it's just weird kid. You certainly wouldn't be saying that if you knew how tall i actually was
At least with season 2 i made the effort, weeks of writing before making a thread for an entirely different game that I would have done differently which is more than what can be said for you and numerous others. I suppose that thread i made was a "shit post" too? Even though i got high praise for my original ideas. Here it is in case you forgot that my posts aren't "shit":
https://telltale.com/community/discussion/107458/what-changes-to-deceased-determinant-unknown-characters-would-you-make-if-you-could-change-things/p7
Anyway, the fact is, Season 3 isn't worth the effort on what i would improve about it. I think it would take me a whole year to list things i would improve but I gave you the basics on what TT should bring back to the table and that should be enough. Funny i haven't seen the things you would improve about it yet you criticise me for it. Did you make a thread? If so I wouldn't have seen it due to not visiting this shadow of it's former self of a forum in a while
Ya'know what? Fuck it. A New Frontier was a disappointment, not going to lie about that, but that doesn't mean The Final Season is doomed to sub par quality like a lot of people here are saying. It seems like the Telltale staff that made A New Frontier really are trying to take into account fan feedback and learn from their mistakes. Sure there's no telling how The Final Season will turn out, but I have faith that Telltale will do their best to make a satisfying conclusion to Clementine's story.
So yeah
id say negative comments with constructive critiscism would help instead of just negative comments saying the game sucked.
Nah I was just kidding. I don't mind if you're critical of A New Frontier. I wasn't fond of the season myself.
How anyone likes it is beyond me really especially if they had played the first 2 seasons before it, even more so!
I'm just gonna say: don't set high expectations until the first episode airs, then we'll see, that's it.
Yeah, admittedly I hadn't put too many of my thoughts into text yet in part because not only is at least one of my changes bound to rub some people the wrong way no matter which approach I take, but the last two episodes(emphasis on last) really wrote me into a lot of corners that are hard to get around for various reasons. So ultimately, I'm just having a hard time finding the motivation to actually bother posting.
Just one episode?
Not all of them, as in; the whole game??
I'm very excited for the last season of the walking dead. I really, really hope they don't try to kill Clementine. If they do, I'm gonna stab someone.
uh... From the series most of these seasons i love Season 1 and just a little bit S2 and idk guys but i lost the story in S3 not much but still i lose a little bit of the story for S4 i can't say nothing and i am not excited for the ''Final Season''.....
Yes very excited to play Clem. Also sad that it's the end. I have enjoyed this game very much. I have not yet finished the last season. I decided to go back and start from the beginning and binge in a 2 night Marathon.
i dont know i just want to play with clementine and i want happy end not like Lee dead ;(
I already did. I made a thread about all this.
I'm excited that players will be playing as Clem that means no forced romance. No stupid crushes and not being forced to like someone, crush on someone, and not being forced to be in a romance with someone. Players will be able to love who they want and hate who they want and hopefully save who they want like in anf. I really hope they get rid of aj. Idc about the baby either way but I just personally wouldn't want to take care of him.