TWDG Characters Ranked by Episode: MVPs and POSs
As you might recall, I had a thread that allowed everyone to list and track their rankings of the characters throughout A New Frontier. In the very late posts of that thread after the Installment wrapped up, I proposed this fun little exercise: Pick your best and least favorite character(s) in each episode and make a post listing them!
Flash forward, this thread is dedicated to expanding on that format for any and every episode of any given Season/Installment.
Title and/or Season plus Episode Number
Best:
Honorable mention:
Least:
mention:
Or, if you want to make a [separate] post regarding your feelings about the game series in general, go right ahead! It's been a while since we had a thread like this, as far as I tell, so list away!
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
TWD 400 Days. DLC
Best: Eddie
Honorable mention: Nate
Least: Bonnie
Mention: Wyatt
Think that's right. If not let me know and I'll edit.
Nah, that's perfect.
Here's my ANF awards, since they already existed for the most part.
Ties that Bind Part 1
Best: Kate
Honorable mention: Max and to an extent Gabe and maybe Eleanor
Least: Tossup between Mariana and ANF!Clementine
mention: The other one
Part 2
Best: Ava
Honorable mention: Max, though Conrad and Gabe were growing on me
Least: Badger
mention: I guess Paul
Above the Law
Best: Tough to pick, but of the seven candidates, I suppose Gabe
Honorable mention: Ava had to be next, with the other candidates being Conrad, Joan, Max, Dr. Lingard, and I believe Kate
Least: Badger by default
mention: I guess Tripp, plus Clementine and maybe Lonnie
Thicker Than Water
Best: Gabe/Ava
Honorable mention: The other one
Least: Tripp
mention: Idk, Kenny/Jane? I got nothing.
From the Gallows
Best: Gabe
Honorable mention: Kate, who I wish got more love
Least: David
mention: I guess Tripp again, with a special "nomination" retroactively for ANF!Clementine. Also, That-Paul-Guy
Why did you feel the way you did about those characters at the time?
Lee for most of season 1, Clems a close second followed by Kenny.
S2, Obviously Clem. It went beyond our comfort zone and actually put us in her shoes.
ANF, David? Xavier was a poor imitation of a good mans Negan, David was actually kind of developed well as a character who clings to his past, and suffers identification issues when returning to society. Of course it all boiled down to a simplistic y u love my wife(even if you choose against it) so that kind of ruined it.
Eddie was best because to me he was funniest. I am always on the look out for a good laugh.
Nate was quite the opposite of honorable in most situations you may say.. however he is what he is in my book because of the way he comes off as a wild card. I couldn't sense bad nor good in him just no fucks given type of guy. I think if you fused the qualities of Carver and Nate you'd probably come close to Negan's personality as far as Telltale characters go.
Least is Bonnie because she always gave off those double crossing weasel vibes and this becomes a self fulfilling prophecy after her appearance throughout the second season. She is given the option if I remember correctly to lie to Leland about accidentally killing Dee and I didn't like that about Bonnie's character she just always been known to be someone you cannot rely on completely and is portrayed as a weak willed person in my perspective which is odd given her rank as one of Carver's "guards" or whatever they were suppose to had been.
I mentioned Wyatt because even though he wasn't that cool I would of liked to find out more about his adventures with Eddie before Nate came and separated them for good.. Eddie was never heard of again after 400 days in spite of being one of the episode 4 silhouettes behind Clem for Amid The Ruins. I wanted so much for Eddie to maybe be involved with the group of Russians that ambushed Clem and Kenny's group. Or better yet be living out in one of the trailers at the trailer park Sarah got killed at. Every character cannot realistically reappear more than once though.
Season 1:
A New Day
Best: Carley
Honorable mention: Glenn
Least: Larry
mention: Doug
Starved for Help
Best: Lee
Honorable mention: Lily
Least: Larry
mention: Mark
Long Road Ahead
Best: Lee
Honorable mention: Chuck
Least: Ben
mention: Clementine
Around Every Corner
Best: Molly
Honorable mention: Christa
Least: Brie
mention: Omid
No Time Left
Best: Lee
Honorable mention: Kenny
Least: The Stranger
mention: Clementine
Why did you feel the way you did about those characters at the time?
Okay, time for a small throwback to Season 2! No, I didn't forget about this thread, why do you ask?
All That Remains
Best: Alvin
Honorable mention: Michelle and Sarah
Least: Rebecca by default
mention: I guess Winston
A House Divided
Best: Sarah
Honorable mention: Alvin
Least: I guess Carver
mention: Idk
In Harm's Way
Best: Sarah
Honorable mention: Troy and Luke
Least: Carver
mention: Kenny
Amid the Ruins
Best: Sarah
Honorable mention: Arvo
Least: Jane
mention: I guess Buricko
No Going Back
Best: Luke
Honorable mention: Bonnie
Least: Jane
mention: I guess Kenny
What would the "mention" category stand for? Anyways here it goes.
Season 1
A New Day
Best: Lee
Honorable Mention: Lilly
Least: Doug
Starved For Help
Best: Lilly
Honorable Mention: Larry
Least: Kenny
Long Road Ahead
Best: Lilly
Honorable Mention: Clementine
Least: Kenny
Around Every Corner
Best:
Honorable Mention: Chuck
Least: Clementine
No Time Left
Best: Christa
Honorable Mention: Kenny
Least: The Stranger
400 Days
Best: Shell
Honorable Mention: Bonnie
Least: Vince
Season 2
All That Remains
Best: Nick
Honorable Mention: Clementine
Least: Pete
A House Divided
Best: Carver
Honorable Mention: Clementine
Least: Nick
In Harm's Way
Best: Carver
Honorable Mention: Clementine
Least: Kenny
Amid The Ruins
Best: Jane
Honorable Mention: Clementine
Least: The Russians
No Going Back
Best: Clementine
Honorable Mention: Jane
Least: Kenny
Michonne
In Too Deep
Best: Norma
Honorable Mention: Randall
Least: Gregg
Give No Shelter
Best: Randall
Honorable Mention: Pete
Least: Sam
What We Deserve
Best: Paige
Honorable Mention: Norma
Least: Sam
I forgot to find an antonym for honorable.
I'll do a review later.
Season 1
A New Day
Best: Lee
Honorable Mention: Kenny
Least: Larry
mention: Doug
Starved for Help
Best: Lee
Honorable Mention: Andy St. John
Least: Larry
mention: Mark
Long Road Ahead
Best: Lee
Honorable Mention: Omid
Least: Kenny
mention: Lilly
Around Every Corner
Best: Clem
Honorable Mention: Lee
Least: Kenny
mention: Molly
No Time Left
Best: Lee
Honorable Mention: Clem
Least: Kenny
mention: Stranger
400 Days
Best: Nate
Honorable Mention: Nate
Least: Nate
mention: Nate
Nate is all!