What If That's Not AJ (Crazy Theory)
I was just thinking, if clementine had been separated from AJ for a while (she says in the story generator that it'd been so long she almost gave up) he would obviously have aged a bit more. What if AJ died, (perhaps from his sickness) and the mc carol ranch gave her the wrong child, kinda like DBH, the ending is that you find out that's not your AJ and the final choice is to tell him or leave it. And it cuts to black before that can happen.
Or even, what if Tenn is the real AJ..
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I really hope this is not going to happen
So awful I could see it happen.
Why does everyone feel the need to be edgy about AJ?
tfw you notice that Aj should only be like 6 years old max but he looks and acts 10, and Tenn looks 6 and acts like hes 6 so now you're worried Telltale will actually pull an awful twist
Telltale writer: dammit back to the doodle board guys! ? gonna have to explore that potential alien abduction plot twist after all.
lol Jane let the real baby AJ die and get eaten by walkers (well, face eaten) and so when she was saying he's dead she thought they were talking about the real AJ but then clem finds a baby crying in the car and isn't mad at Jane anymore so Jane's like "fuck it whatever yeah yeah, that's AJ" and then even after that the mc carol ranch thing happens so there has been 3 aj's
That theory is both brilliant and stupid at the same time
Fuck that will totally happen.
Sound like something the Joker would pull. "You just fell for the FAKE AJ GAG Clementine!"
Does this mean Fake AJ is actually a giant Clum Baby?
Got a better idea - Clementine went crazy and he now only exists in her imagination. Maybe she never actually found him at the end of season 3 or she found him dead. Is there any videos of him interacting with other characters? Even if there is, I still quite like the idea.
at the end of the demo, he's picked up by Marlon
Uuugh....
Nine times out of Ten. (pun intended)
Wild fan theories tend to be incorrect. But if it was correct. I would have my doubts that as much time as Clem spent with AJ and the time away in comparison would not be enough for her to mistakenly take the wrong toddler. Almost sounds a bit racial if you think about it the wrong way. "Oh we'll just toss her another black baby and she'll never know haha." If Ten was AJ why would he never say anything until the end to come forth and reveal himself to Clem? and I'm sure he'd remember what Clem looks like at least to make some reference saying how familiar she looks way before the end..also with as clever a girl as Clem is she'd deduce that it would be AJ. The character that is AJ looks just how AJ should look though I agree he looks aged too far but you do have big 6 and 7 year olds. So I think that developmental "twist" should be impossible and thank the fuck Christ if so. Because that'd be god awful. If you want a twist have AJ be Lee's wife's nephew if Rebecca/Alvin could be Lee's wife's sibling. Or perhaps Lee's cousin by marriage.. Then in some odd way of fate Clementine paid Lee back for watching over her several years ago.
What if Aj kills Clem at the end
Or maybe...not only is Ten the real AJ, BUT the AJ we have now is Christas missing child
Tryin to decide how I'd feel about that.
Tenn looks more like AJ then s4 AJ though
...
Absolutely extremely unlikely - I don't think Telltale would pull off a twist of such proportions.
Are you saying that Telltale is good at being horrible when it comes to plots?