Because Jane nearly joined Sarah in following as the deck collapse and only ended dangling because Luke caught her hand as she slid off what was left of the edge. This made it possible for her to drop down right next to Sarah(just...roll with it) and try to lift the rubble high enough for Sarah to pull herself free.
Kenny was inside helping Rebecca deliver AJ, while Clementine and Luke were on their knees/belly at the edge after catching Jane and watching from that vantage. Mike and Bonnie do very briefly cover her against two approaching walkers to buy more time for her to life as high as she could, but she could only get to a certain height that Sarah still had trouble escaping, likely due to the rest of it still being on her leg.
However, you're absolutely right in thinking that at least Mike should've went down to provide muscle in either lifting the rubble or pulling Sarah free, while Bonnie and Clementine provide cover fire when needed.
I like this situation, it should've been written this way.
I still would've asked Jane to go help her. In that moment, Sarah wanted to li… moreve. It kinda seemed like she finally snapped out of her gloom, and wanted life rather than death.
Out of all the panic, I wasn't thinking about anything other than getting Sarah back to the group. Can't really remember but, why was Jane the only one to go down? I think... everyone was there. They were giving Jane cover fire? Ok, so Clem watches over Rebecca, Bonnie lays the cover fire, Kenny, Mike, and Jane go in. Pretty simple, but plot. (Somebody help me out if I'm remembering wrong)
I would've gone in if there were an option. She deserved more, I think.
Sarah gonna die. She was useless and weird and a literal liability, as seen when she got people eaten escaping Howe's. I left her to die in that trailer when she froze up and wouldn't climb out and I didn't regret it one bit.
I'd sacrifice Jane. She's a good example of why a lone wolf doesn't work in a group. She had some good plans but if you want to execute a plan involving the lives of actual people, you have to have actual good people skills. Her overly hostile attitude towards Arvo is the main reason the ambush started in the first place and, while her attitude towards Kenny was justified, she handled getting rid of him very poorly, which, if you chose not to shoot Kenny, is what causes her own death. Also for a lone wolf she's just very brash and impulsive, so yeah she knew some good tricks but aside from that she wasn't really good at being a survivor when she had to deal with opponents that weren't shambling corpses.
Sarah never really got a chance to prove herself since she was never allowed to by her father and when she is finally free from his overprotective parenting she dies while still suffering from the shock and grief over his death, so she doesn't get a chance to prove herself. I wanted to give her another couple of weeks after her father's death to find out if she's not capable of being built up into the same survivor Clem is. It's a shame the writers never let us find out.
Jane because it was obvious from Sarah's behaviour that she wasn't well and either she'd further endanger the rest of the group or she'd try to end herself later down the road. Jane was at least someone I knew I could've count on... to a certain degree.
You let sentiment like that dictate your actions you won't survive long in an apocalypse situation. You have to make decisions with your head, not your heart.
Jane's several thousand times more valuable to me that Sarah, mainly because Jane knows how to survive. Sarah's seems like a good companion, but not good enough to pick over Jane.
Comments
Because Jane nearly joined Sarah in following as the deck collapse and only ended dangling because Luke caught her hand as she slid off what was left of the edge. This made it possible for her to drop down right next to Sarah(just...roll with it) and try to lift the rubble high enough for Sarah to pull herself free.
Kenny was inside helping Rebecca deliver AJ, while Clementine and Luke were on their knees/belly at the edge after catching Jane and watching from that vantage. Mike and Bonnie do very briefly cover her against two approaching walkers to buy more time for her to life as high as she could, but she could only get to a certain height that Sarah still had trouble escaping, likely due to the rest of it still being on her leg.
However, you're absolutely right in thinking that at least Mike should've went down to provide muscle in either lifting the rubble or pulling Sarah free, while Bonnie and Clementine provide cover fire when needed.
you have a point but to let kid die thats not ok bro
I'd sacrifice Jane. She's a good example of why a lone wolf doesn't work in a group. She had some good plans but if you want to execute a plan involving the lives of actual people, you have to have actual good people skills. Her overly hostile attitude towards Arvo is the main reason the ambush started in the first place and, while her attitude towards Kenny was justified, she handled getting rid of him very poorly, which, if you chose not to shoot Kenny, is what causes her own death. Also for a lone wolf she's just very brash and impulsive, so yeah she knew some good tricks but aside from that she wasn't really good at being a survivor when she had to deal with opponents that weren't shambling corpses.
Sarah never really got a chance to prove herself since she was never allowed to by her father and when she is finally free from his overprotective parenting she dies while still suffering from the shock and grief over his death, so she doesn't get a chance to prove herself. I wanted to give her another couple of weeks after her father's death to find out if she's not capable of being built up into the same survivor Clem is. It's a shame the writers never let us find out.
Jane because it was obvious from Sarah's behaviour that she wasn't well and either she'd further endanger the rest of the group or she'd try to end herself later down the road. Jane was at least someone I knew I could've count on... to a certain degree.
You let sentiment like that dictate your actions you won't survive long in an apocalypse situation. You have to make decisions with your head, not your heart.
The reaper already made you buy that season pass
What Season Pass?
Oh, you mean the Xbox 360 Collection?
Definitely saving Jane. No way i'm passing up a survivalist expert for a semi-seemingly cool nobody.
...What, wait?
Jane's several thousand times more valuable to me that Sarah, mainly because Jane knows how to survive. Sarah's seems like a good companion, but not good enough to pick over Jane.