Is Violet trans?

Maybe she's younger than I thought (16ish) but she seems awfully flat chested. I know not all girls have giant boobs, I've dated all kinds, but every other girl in the series that has been old enough to have boobs has had or does have clearly defined boobs, even if they aren't very large. Violet, however, seems like she doesn't actually have any. Maybe they're just really small and her clothes are completely hiding them, but it just looks like she doesn't have any at all. What if she's trans and that's why she was at the school to begin with? It is the south, after all. As someone who was born in, raised in, and lives in the south, I can tell you that southern people are more likely to be religious and therefore less likely to be accepting of their trans children. "No son of mine is gonna pretend he's a girl! Off to a school for delinquents with you! That'll straighten you out!"

Comments

  • That could be the case. But I just can't see this theory being real from a writing perspective

  • She has a very feminine voice

  • It doesn't matter. What is even the point if this thread? Are you bored?

  • As for the school she probably got there because she looks like the girl that have problem socializing, and also she is gay so that’s that

  • Not sure if this is joking or not, but no she's no trans, and just because she's 'flat chested' doesn't mean she's less of a female than one with larger breast. If that's your main basis of believing she's tran that is a very poor basis of coming to that conclusion. Plus, I highly doubt that a preteen violet over 6-8 years ago was attempting to transition prior to the apocalypse.

  • Yes, she does. Not all trans women sound like a guy trying to sound like a girl. After years of practice they get really good at feminizing their voices, especially if they'd been doing it since before puberty, which would be the case with Violet.

    MrGraffio posted: »

    She has a very feminine voice

  • In TWD the apocalypse started in 2003, there were already trasitioning op?

    Yes, she does. Not all trans women sound like a guy trying to sound like a girl. After years of practice they get really good at feminizing their voices, especially if they'd been doing it since before puberty, which would be the case with Violet.

  • No I had a point... I just don't recall what it was atm lol. I'm sure it'll come back to me in time. Maybe after I eat.

    MosesARose posted: »

    It doesn't matter. What is even the point if this thread? Are you bored?

  • No. She isn't.

  • edited August 2018

    I really don't see how she could be transgender.

  • ''After years of practice they get really good at feminizing their voices''

    Naaah, whenever I hear a trans person talk you just know that they are ''making a voice'', no offense.

    Yes, she does. Not all trans women sound like a guy trying to sound like a girl. After years of practice they get really good at feminizing their voices, especially if they'd been doing it since before puberty, which would be the case with Violet.

  • I agree there are way more important topics that we could be having.

  • I find so annoying that the most popular threads usually are the ones about pointless shipping too.

    I agree there are way more important topics that we could be having.

  • I don’t think violet is trans... but it wouldn’t change much ?‍♀️ Cause she’s still a “she” either way.

  • She does have a serious attitude problem, so maybe that's why she got sent there. If they've been in apocalypse for 8 years, that means she would've been showing signs of being trans from the time she was 12. Most 12 y/o kids just go with their default genders and don't begin questioning themselves until they're like 14 or so, I'm not sure, I didn't get my degree in Transology :D :D :D :D

  • I won't give a fuck cuz I wouldn't want to know this information thank u.

  • Pluse if you look at the photo album you see Violet Minni and Sophie BFFs....Violet is a young girl

  • Woah woah woah woah. WOAH. Everyone needs to chill tf out. It's not that serious. Let the man hypothesise as he pleases without being shot at with unnecessary comments. Either you answer his question, or don't. It's that simple. No need to come in here with all that negativity.

  • I mean, it was confirmed during an AMA that there would be an LGBT character...

  • What has happened to these forums

  • In fact, having just checked the WD Wiki, it is apparently implied that she was, at one point, romantically involved with Minerva.

    I mean, it was confirmed during an AMA that there would be an LGBT character...

  • edited August 2018

    Good(?) observation, but I doubt it.

    EDIT: Fock me, I just remember I made a dickgirl joke already.

  • Da fuq. This thread seems wildly silly considering what I've read from you before. Basically because she wears 'unwomanly' clothing that doesn't show her boobs off she has to be transgendered??? Perplexing.

  • Clementine finds that out herself when you talk to Violet in your room.

    In fact, having just checked the WD Wiki, it is apparently implied that she was, at one point, romantically involved with Minerva.

  • edited August 2018

    Yeah, seriously.

    @Chibikid Not sure if this is joking or not, but no she's no trans, and just because she's 'flat chested' doesn't mean she's less of a female than one with larger breast. If that's your main basis of believing she's tran that is a very poor basis of coming to that conclusion.

    She also has next to nothing in the back, so...

    Plus, I highly doubt that a preteen violet over 6-8 years ago was attempting to transition prior to the apocalypse.

    Ooow-ho-ho-ho-ho...! :lol:

    @Hillbilly_Dave Yes, she does. Not all trans women sound like a guy trying to sound like a girl. After years of practice they get really good at feminizing their voices, especially if they'd been doing it since before puberty, which would be the case with Violet.

    And that scares me
    , * Flashbacks to The Murray Show *

    MrGraffio posted: »

    She has a very feminine voice

  • Dex-StarrDex-Starr Banned
    edited August 2018

    Between 1 and 3 million years, how many eons late are you ? :D

    In fact, having just checked the WD Wiki, it is apparently implied that she was, at one point, romantically involved with Minerva.

  • I doubt she's trans, but it'd be a welcome surprise, and you have a point to the south.

    Her being seemingly flat-chested isn't really an indicator of that, though.

  • To be fair, I didn't realize myself until someone pointed out the :heart:

    Dex-Starr posted: »

    Between 1 and 3 million years, how many eons late are you ?

  • Wow... Lots of people getting rather aggravated by this thread. How bout don't bother with it if its existence offends you all so much? Don't need to treat the person who started it like crap. If this was a legitimate question they had than who are you to get upset over it?

  • I’m a tad slow :D

    Dex-Starr posted: »

    Between 1 and 3 million years, how many eons late are you ?

  • Lol wow this thread blew up way harder than I expected it would.

  • I don't think this thread is going anywhere good, so I'm going to lock it before it inevitably gets out of hand.

    Please remember R-E-S-P-E-C-T too guys.

This discussion has been closed.