What if there was another adult stuck in the locker besides Lilly, Lee, and Kenny?
How would that affect the element of the situation? You have to figure if Ben, Carley, or Katcha (sp?) were locked up too none would have favored killing Larry.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Ben and Carley would have realized that Larry was going to turn. Katjaa would oppose just because. Regardless of how anyone else felt about it they would die if Larry was not put down.
You really think they would die? Why?
Because Larry was a 6'4 and 300 pounds brick shithouse. He was an absolute monster of a person and his walker would be ridiculously tough to kill.
Telltale confirmed that Larry was alive. Nicki Rapp, voice of Lilly confirmed that too. Even fact that Larry started to talking after CPR....
They all would survive. Kenny was just a scared pussy that didnt cared about life of Lilly, ans Larry.
But yeah... Fact that because of him Katja, Ben, Clementine and Lee can die when he wont stop the train confirms that he was worse than Lilly in meatlocker. Pathetic man.
There was.
I mean, obviously.
The issue is really more a matter of for how much longer.
Nah Telltale said they left it intentionally ambiguous about whether he was dead or not in order to make the player rethink their decision. Also CPR doesn't resuscitate a heart attack victim, it only keeps their heart beating for a bit while they wait for a defibrillator/medical personnel. But wow tone down the hatred and negativity lol
Honestly between Ben and Carly. Neither were alphas. Lee and Kenny ran shit. What Lee and Kenny said went. The only time Kenny's plans would be foiled is if Lee said no. But if they were on the same page then nothing was stopping them. I think Carly might be undecided but I think she might take Lee and Kenny's side. I think Ben might be undecided and either stay out of it or whimper and cry. Katja is a piece of shit. She'd probably steer Kenny out of it and we'd have a 300 pound pissed off ex military walker trapped in a confined space like Kenny predicted. Everyone was against it but Kenny was so right in that situation. The man was gone.
As for other adults, Michonne woulda supported it, Jesus probably not, Javier probably would, Gabe probably not, grown up Clementine would be in the middle but I think she'd lean towards what Lee thought her, probably not do it. I think Violet woulda off'd his ass, I think AJ certainly would off'd his ass. Carver would killed him alive lol. Alvin Sr. would have supported it with some convincing (what if he kills rebecca type deal) and Sarah would have cried in the corner.
My main thing here is, any other fucking person aside from her dad, Lilly would have done the same exact thing. She would have convinced Lee to finish off a dead Kenny corpse. She would have killed a Lee corpse before it turnt. Fuck her.
Oh yeah, Larry was tap dancing, he was alive and well. He was actually playing poker and laughing about the good old days right before the salt hit him. BULLSHIT. He was mid stroke/heart attack, in a meat locker, with no defibulator, no medicine at 60+ years old in a zombie apacolypse with various heart conditions. DEAD.
Also we really need to stop taking what voice actors say as confirmation about the plot no offense to the voice actors. they aren't devs and they aren't the ones writing the plot. Their is a giant team deciding the story and even those people can't be accept as confirmation as so many devs working on the game and so many have their own opinion on things. Voice Actors can call a turd a cupcake and it doesn't mean it's so. Larry clearly didn't talk during that CPR. Nobody seen him talk and nobody heard him talk in this entire community.
The fact of the matter is, that situation called for a brave and composed adult decision. Not standing there waiting for the 300 pound walker to appear. Kenny is a man and their are kids involved. It sucks for Lilly. I get that 100 percent. But it had to be done. Too bad, too sad. Kenny did the right thing. Larry was not alive. Their is a huge difference between "He's still alive" and "he's going to live" if he was alive, he was a goner.
Larry would have died regardless of what happened and it would have happened sooner then later. With Larry's anger issues and his severe heart condition, it was the worse combination. Not to mention that you don't just spring back from having 2 heart attacks within a 3 month span as Larry had sustained especially at over 60+ years old in the apocalypse.
Regarding your point of Kenny, he was scared which is why he did what he did because from his perspective, Larry was going to reanimate with them in a trapped meat locker who would've killed or bit Lily at minimum as she was as close to him which would've created two immediate problems.
Duck was a stupid kid, he propably would die sooner or later too. Is this giving anyone a power to killing him? Really?
All the cancer group was dying anyway, why we wont kill them in the first place to stop them causing troubles? Nice point of view.
And they did steal and betray the group that helped them as well. And even if the members were dying there was no reason for the group to have to kill them as they did with Larry. Lee and company were stuck in a sealed meat locker with a relatively formidable adult who if he had reanimated could have caused a more dangerous situation then they already were in.
And duck wasn't a 60 year old man with uncontrollable anger issues that exacerbated a severe heart condition that had caused 2 heart attacks in a 3 month span. You don't just bounce back from having a heart attack to begin with not mentioning that Larry was reliant on nitroglycerin pills to manage the condition which the group did not have as the season progressed. Had Larry lived, he would've died sooner and possibly had posed an even worse problem for the group at a later point.
Duck and the cancer group did not pose an immediate or imminent threat to the group as Larry did incapacited in the meat locker which did warrant immediate action.
They should've tied him up.
With what
It doesn't matter. Kenny was right.
He can still bite with his arms tied not to mention he probably would've bitten or killed Lily since she was right over him when he was incapacitated.