She also wouldnt seem way so suprised i think, On episode 3 picture you can see clem with that pregnant women(rebecca i think) so not much time has passed, i dont think she would be suprised she would be happy and like you said enthusiastic not suprised...
I doubt its Christa, Clem didn't appear to seem overly happy when she said: "I thought you were dead"
It would be a valid response towards Kenny. Imo. You would just expect a more enthusiastic Clem when she said it if it would be Christa.
I read in another thread, that this might be a slight slip-up by TTG. It appears that they only ask "Did you kill both brothers?" And if you let both live it shows so, if you killed both it shows so. But if you kill only one, the game gets a "you didn't kill both brothers" and shows both not being killed.
I am only repeating here, can't contribute myself, since I left both brothers alive, and it showed so in the opening.
Anyone here, who killed one brother, and one brother only, who could say something about that?
Molly can die if lee dosen't save her, at some point in ep 4 you need to shoot some zombies attacking Molly, if you do not i "think" she dies,… more you can also shoot her while she is fighting the zombies and then you can see her die.
Edit: Don't read, im dumb and wrong.
Molly can die if lee dosen't save her, at some point in ep 4 you need to shoot some zombies attacking Molly, if you do not i "think" she dies,… more you can also shoot her while she is fighting the zombies and then you can see her die.
Edit: Don't read, im dumb and wrong.
We also don't know what's going to happen inbetween now and that moment. Maybe something will happen to give Clem a reason to think Christa is dead- I.e. we meet these mysterious bad guys who say they killed her or some such. Nick could go out hunting or something and say "I found your friend dead" or any number of things could happen. I think it's fun playing detective but at the end of the day it's gonna be who it is and some people will be happy and others will not be lol.
I DO think we shouldn't read too much in to Clems reaction though. Just because she didn't run gleefully at them like she was happy to see them doesn't mean she's afraid of whoever it is. She could just be shocked and that shocked face turns into a smile as someone friendly is revealed.
She also wouldnt seem way so suprised i think, On episode 3 picture you can see clem with that pregnant women(rebecca i think) so not much tim… moree has passed, i dont think she would be suprised she would be happy and like you said enthusiastic not suprised...
She's not so close to Kenny either, to be honest.
The only person she'd be happy to meet again (that is certainly alive) is Christa. Also w… morehy do you keep saying "Kenny fans" I'm just arguing with you, not saying "Kenny is the guy" because I can't totally tell, neither can you tell it's not him, truly.
I'd just have it be Kenny instead of Lilly because personally I like Kenny more.
(By the way have you looked at Tyreese in the TV show? He's fat lol). Also, where did you get that Tyreese is physically able and Kenny isn't? Anyone that doesn't have a six pack can't fight? That's just dumb.
We never said she cant die, theres too many posibilities to try out, if u would be nice enough to tell me details of when, how and where to kill her(or let her die), ill be pleased to admit youre right, cos just like i said im about to start 4 episode again in a bit but i want it to go veeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerry different than others!!!
I saw it. In my playthrough, I accidentally shot her in the arm and wasn't given another chance to shoot the walker(instead of the usual route of missing Molly and the walker). Instead of running away, she fell to her knees and got chomped. Or at least, I seem to remember that. I could be wrong...
Yes but where?? Molly is with us nearly whole 4th season? Are we comig back from crawford? Is it near garage?? I belive I have the battery, so on the way back from crawford?
I saw it. In my playthrough, I accidentally shot her in the arm and wasn't given another chance to shoot the walker(instead of the usual route… more of missing Molly and the walker). Instead of running away, she fell to her knees and got chomped. Or at least, I seem to remember that. I could be wrong...
So "your" Lilly had your back, was angry with her dad for trying to kill you, didn't kill an innocent person you were friends with and didn't leave you and Clementine for dead by taking the RV?
Because the game is in the same universe as the comic and you never see this people in the comic book (I'm up to date, never saw any of this folks).
And I doubt Kirkman would want a video game to show stuff that might just happen in the comic in 6 months, that doesn't seem too realistic. In my opinion.
Also, yeah, what AGentleman said (it's a spoiler from the comic book and explains why Glenn can't show up in the game very easily xD).
Canyoushootmyrabbit i like your thinking, they could be getting closer to atlanta, but its getting a bit foggy here. I heard somewhere the gam… moree is gonna close up to tv series but how if Hershel Greene got son not two sexy daughters?? AGentleman, it looks like they are entering some sort of a camp on the wideo, why not Ricks camp?
Yeah, for more detail, when you go into the sewers you see him just sitting there with his guts out, even Lee says "Poor old man, must've been trying to hide here and run out of ammo", or something, anyway.
Wait, wait wait! I just had a thought! Thus far everyone has said something about it being either: Kenny, Christa, Lilly or Molly -- But also … moreargued that the only one Clem would have reason to know was dead would be kenny (if she thought Christa was dead, she wouldn't be asking for her from the guy who wanted water, ect. Lilly either stole the RV or was left on the side of the road, molly left of her own volition if she survived).
WHAT IF ITS CHUCK(?) AKA the homeless man from the train, who saved Clem when Ben was a fuckwit and left her alone? We never see him die, and one of the options later, when looking for boats is to look for him. And Clem WOULD have reason to believe he was dead.
Yeah, I like to think that'll depend on your choices from S2E1, as in, depending on your actions, it's Lilly or Kenny, but I dunno, this seems like a very longshot.
I think it is Lily. I think everyone in Episode 3 considered leaving Lily behind as a death sentence (even Lily herself) and even if she took… more the RV, Kenny said it will only go 15 miles anyway and thus considered her to be in the middle of nowhere anyway.
Its Lily, could be Kenny though. Kenny and Clementine were not that close I think?
What happens if you don't take Clementine to Crawford? I never had the balls to leave her with Omid honestly, in my three playthroughs, even knowing that Omid was gonna be alright xD
We never said she cant die, theres too many posibilities to try out, if u would be nice enough to tell me details of when, how and where to ki… morell her(or let her die), ill be pleased to admit youre right, cos just like i said im about to start 4 episode again in a bit but i want it to go veeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerry different than others!!!
Yes but you can choose to burn it to have more feels value. (I tried burning Lee's photo but she doesn't do it, I don't know about the drawing).
Yeah, the fact TTG kept the drawing of Ken's family has to mean something, even if this isn't Kenny, we'll probably see him again and there will be a huge feels trip about that drawing.
I believe it's in Crawford, while you're still in the school, possibly when you come back :c Ben takes the hatchet that kept one of the doors locked and the place gets flooded with zombies.
Yes but where?? Molly is with us nearly whole 4th season? Are we comig back from crawford? Is it near garage?? I belive I have the battery, so on the way back from crawford?
The more I think about the more options come to mind. Kenny, Lilly, Christa, a bandit that attacked the group in S1E3, Molly, bandits that attacked Clem & Christa from S2E1 or maybe the chick that blasted Omid. It's just sooo many options grrrr
Yes but you can choose to burn it to have more feels value. (I tried burning Lee's photo but she doesn't do it, I don't know about the drawing… more).
Yeah, the fact TTG kept the drawing of Ken's family has to mean something, even if this isn't Kenny, we'll probably see him again and there will be a huge feels trip about that drawing.
Yeah, I believe they added Omid's death as a last second thing because there wasn't enough feels value in the episode, and they had to cope with episode 5 from season 1, to give you the feeling the game was still as ruthless as it was.
Basically they wanted to put us all in a big feels trip
Oh, ew. I always use the blunt weapon, so it just dents his head in, which is bad enough.
I just don't see Christa leaving him to zombify. … moreMy Clem might be torn because my Lee playthrough strongly advised her against doing it to him, and told her killing changes you and stuff like that.
I did like Omid a lot. I guess that's why they got him first. Find the last bright light in the wasteland and snuff that out early to get the despair train a runnin.
No. I won't stop arguing with logic.
You can even tell them he probably escaped so No.
Kenny fans are just so stupid, constantly demanding t… moreheir right and fangasaming "KENNY KENNY KENNY OH LOOK A HAT KENNY."
They've been wrong. Twice now.
They wont be right this time.
And that logic doesnt stop Kenny fans from thinking he's dead, why cant Omid and Christa have the same mentality?
Unless you're suggesting that thinking is WRONG
I never read any comics, and i dont really understand what you mean? I think i know what you mean about glenn from comics its been in one of posts here :)Oh shite i think iknow what the problem is here... Is Rick also in comics? (Im into tv show)
Because the game is in the same universe as the comic and you never see this people in the comic book (I'm up to date, never saw any of this f… moreolks).
And I doubt Kirkman would want a video game to show stuff that might just happen in the comic in 6 months, that doesn't seem too realistic. In my opinion.
Also, yeah, what AGentleman said (it's a spoiler from the comic book and explains why Glenn can't show up in the game very easily xD).
Thing is people think it's Christa because that girl's jacket looks like Christa's (the purple one from season 1 and the whole prologue thing in S2E1), but if you pay attention, after the 16 months after thing, Christa has a brown jacket.
The reason I am not at all sold on that being Christa is because she doesn't look like Christa. There is no resemblence except they are the sa… moreme gender.
If that was Christa TT would have used the Christa-model. And not some model from an anonymous woman, we've seen in the last episode.
Yeah, for more detail, when you go into the sewers you see him just sitting there with his guts out, even Lee says "Poor old man, must've been trying to hide here and run out of ammo", or something, anyway.
How did you not notice that? xD
Kenny does say she doesn't have a long way off in the RV, he says "she's got 15 miles on that thing" or something along those lines. Surely Clem overhears that, so yeah.
I guess it depends on how you dealt with her in season one, I could see Clem thinking Lilly died if you left her out on the road with the walkers, not so much if she stole the RV though.
Comments
She also wouldnt seem way so suprised i think, On episode 3 picture you can see clem with that pregnant women(rebecca i think) so not much time has passed, i dont think she would be suprised she would be happy and like you said enthusiastic not suprised...
I read in another thread, that this might be a slight slip-up by TTG. It appears that they only ask "Did you kill both brothers?" And if you let both live it shows so, if you killed both it shows so. But if you kill only one, the game gets a "you didn't kill both brothers" and shows both not being killed.
I am only repeating here, can't contribute myself, since I left both brothers alive, and it showed so in the opening.
Anyone here, who killed one brother, and one brother only, who could say something about that?
Actually she just runs away, no matter what you do you can't kill her.
Micex have you actually seen her die? Cos yeah from what i know she just says to much hassle wiv u guys and your boat im off my own way...
Micex you are indeed wrong, you see Molly run away, you don't physically see her die.
We also don't know what's going to happen inbetween now and that moment. Maybe something will happen to give Clem a reason to think Christa is dead- I.e. we meet these mysterious bad guys who say they killed her or some such. Nick could go out hunting or something and say "I found your friend dead" or any number of things could happen. I think it's fun playing detective but at the end of the day it's gonna be who it is and some people will be happy and others will not be lol.
I DO think we shouldn't read too much in to Clems reaction though. Just because she didn't run gleefully at them like she was happy to see them doesn't mean she's afraid of whoever it is. She could just be shocked and that shocked face turns into a smile as someone friendly is revealed.
Have i just dream't it O_O i swear i have seen it. If you people say so. i feel embaressed
Never mind what i say, i'm just dumb and everything that comes out of my mouth must be taken with a buttload of salt ;_;
Clem dont have a six pack, and she outlived every fucker there...
We never said she cant die, theres too many posibilities to try out, if u would be nice enough to tell me details of when, how and where to kill her(or let her die), ill be pleased to admit youre right, cos just like i said im about to start 4 episode again in a bit but i want it to go veeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerry different than others!!!
I saw it. In my playthrough, I accidentally shot her in the arm and wasn't given another chance to shoot the walker(instead of the usual route of missing Molly and the walker). Instead of running away, she fell to her knees and got chomped. Or at least, I seem to remember that. I could be wrong...
actually iz dolan
I'm really hoping it's Kenny and not christa
Yes but where?? Molly is with us nearly whole 4th season? Are we comig back from crawford? Is it near garage?? I belive I have the battery, so on the way back from crawford?
Father Christmas
So "your" Lilly had your back, was angry with her dad for trying to kill you, didn't kill an innocent person you were friends with and didn't leave you and Clementine for dead by taking the RV?
Because the game is in the same universe as the comic and you never see this people in the comic book (I'm up to date, never saw any of this folks).
And I doubt Kirkman would want a video game to show stuff that might just happen in the comic in 6 months, that doesn't seem too realistic. In my opinion.
Also, yeah, what AGentleman said (it's a spoiler from the comic book and explains why Glenn can't show up in the game very easily xD).
I just want it to be someone from the old group to be honest.
Lilly probably got over Larry a long ass time ago if she's still alive anyway.
Yeah, for more detail, when you go into the sewers you see him just sitting there with his guts out, even Lee says "Poor old man, must've been trying to hide here and run out of ammo", or something, anyway.
How did you not notice that? xD
Yeah, I like to think that'll depend on your choices from S2E1, as in, depending on your actions, it's Lilly or Kenny, but I dunno, this seems like a very longshot.
I don't think that's christa. TTG wants you to think that way, but I hope Kenny's back, cuz clems painting of his family gotta mean somehow right?
What happens if you don't take Clementine to Crawford? I never had the balls to leave her with Omid honestly, in my three playthroughs, even knowing that Omid was gonna be alright xD
Yes but you can choose to burn it to have more feels value. (I tried burning Lee's photo but she doesn't do it, I don't know about the drawing).
Yeah, the fact TTG kept the drawing of Ken's family has to mean something, even if this isn't Kenny, we'll probably see him again and there will be a huge feels trip about that drawing.
I believe it's in Crawford, while you're still in the school, possibly when you come back :c Ben takes the hatchet that kept one of the doors locked and the place gets flooded with zombies.
The more I think about the more options come to mind. Kenny, Lilly, Christa, a bandit that attacked the group in S1E3, Molly, bandits that attacked Clem & Christa from S2E1 or maybe the chick that blasted Omid. It's just sooo many options grrrr
I bet TTG will show him- "Next time on the walking dead S2 episode 5"
Yeah, I believe they added Omid's death as a last second thing because there wasn't enough feels value in the episode, and they had to cope with episode 5 from season 1, to give you the feeling the game was still as ruthless as it was.
Basically they wanted to put us all in a big feels trip
Yeah, their mother gets bitten by super mother fuckin' zombie Mark.
(Also why did they kill off Mark so quickly back in season 1? He was cool.
)
I burnt that picture to cook a weasel...
Guys what about Glenn?
clem and him were kinda friends back in season 1 ep 1, but im still not sure cuz he went to Atlanta...
Fiction and Logic are not tied together....
clem y u do dis
I never read any comics, and i dont really understand what you mean? I think i know what you mean about glenn from comics its been in one of posts here :)Oh shite i think iknow what the problem is here... Is Rick also in comics? (Im into tv show)
Thing is people think it's Christa because that girl's jacket looks like Christa's (the purple one from season 1 and the whole prologue thing in S2E1), but if you pay attention, after the 16 months after thing, Christa has a brown jacket.
If you read the comics which are canon to the game, he's with Rick's group in Atlanta.
We have to remember, game has many various options. Maybe shootingwhiterabbit just didnt get to see dead chuck...
Kenny does say she doesn't have a long way off in the RV, he says "she's got 15 miles on that thing" or something along those lines. Surely Clem overhears that, so yeah.
"in Atlanta"
Not sure if not trying to spoil the guy or not up-to-date with the comics.
but telltale said kenny is death
You what?!?