Wait a min .. If Kenny had only one shot in the gun and he used it at Ben to kill him ,,, How did the gun had ammo if you killed the stranger / Clementine killed the stranger??? ...
He may have had ammo in his car. Also, if you choke the stranger and then shoot him in the head, you only have one bullet remaining. If you choke the stranger and just leave him, you still only have one bullet remaining. Telltale's attention to detail in situations like this is pretty lacking.
Wait a min .. If Kenny had only one shot in the gun and he used it at Ben to kill him ,,, How did the gun had ammo if you killed the stranger / Clementine killed the stranger??? ...
Regarding the stranger's hiding spot: Actually, the Stranger was hiding in the bathroom before Lee showed up. You can just about see the bathroom door when he talks to Lee for the first time. It's basically a fourth door
1) I never said the walker was in the room with Campman. That wouldn't make sense. The stranger would drag himself, maybe under the bed? I dou… morebt he could just walk down there, and he was clearly hiding somewhere. The door, that's interesting though. Not enough for that gif, but... Interesting.
2) But she'd been with Ken for 3 months. She knows what he looks like. And if you're saying the spot that I think you're saying, then Clem would've seen him.
3) Thank you.
4) On a side note, how would Ken have gotten to the motel from inside that one building in the Christa death?
Regarding the stranger's hiding spot: Actually, the Stranger was hiding in the bathroom before Lee showed up. You can just about see the bathroom door when he talks to Lee for the first time. It's basically a fourth door
You are absolutely right. Any logical person could see that. A whole theory based off hearing a noise. Insane. I honestly just can not believe people are buying into this. Its a cool STORY but people are praising this theory like they are now certain this happened.
Hmmm, I dunno, the gun seems to be the only evidence here.
The rest is just a story made up to fit the sounds.
The same can be done with L… moreilly really.
While following the group the stranger saves Lilly.
They both decide to take revenge, but at the last minute when Lee shows up Lilly changes her mind. The stranger and Lilly struggle, etc.
Clem doesn't want Lee to open the door because she doesn't want him to hurt Lilly.
(no, I'm not in the Lilly camp, or the Kenny camp. Just saying it could have been anything)
1) Wherever he was, it wasn't in the adjoining room. Lee has some peripheral vision, and woulda seen him. Wait, which door was to the adjoinin… moreg room? That keeps throwing me off.
2) I don't think we're thinking of the same door.
4) Before Lee could climb over some buildings and jump down? And in the pitch black dark? I don't think so.
You are absolutely right. Any logical person could see that. A whole theory based off hearing a noise. Insane. I honestly just can not believe… more people are buying into this. Its a cool STORY but people are praising this theory like they are now certain this happened.
than*
Ok why is it worse? Because its absolutely hilarious. Do you honestly think that telltale would add a noise (which is clearly just hi… morem closing the door on Clem, or hiding since you don't see the stranger when you enter the room) and hope that fans would imply that people think "Oh its obvi Kennys unconscious body!" LOL don't get me started.
Absolutely hilarity. Its fine if everyone was looking at it from the point of "cool story" but people are actually looking at it as a potential realistic solution.
He may have had ammo in his car. Also, if you choke the stranger and then shoot him in the head, you only have one bullet remaining. If you … morechoke the stranger and just leave him, you still only have one bullet remaining. Telltale's attention to detail in situations like this is pretty lacking.
But, that room he's talking about. Isn't that the room Clem enters from to hit the stranger in the back? Why wouldn't she tell Lee that Kenny's back there?
Not sure if people are trolling or actually believe this. I think its both. Im not saying Kenny won't return but I am 100% that if he does it was not through this story.
than*
Ok why is it worse? Because its absolutely hilarious. Do you honestly think that telltale would add a noise (which is clearly just hi… morem closing the door on Clem, or hiding since you don't see the stranger when you enter the room) and hope that fans would imply that people think "Oh its obvi Kennys unconscious body!" LOL don't get me started.
Absolutely hilarity. Its fine if everyone was looking at it from the point of "cool story" but people are actually looking at it as a potential realistic solution.
I am so close to being done with this forum. How on earth is this theory gaining ANY credibility? Its hilarious. Its worse than the people who… more are creating stories on how Kenny survived. This theory is actually hilarious. I actually laughed when I read it and I thought it was getting thumbs up because of the stupidity / humor. Oh god this is funny. You realize this is a completely made up story using no facts or anything besides a sound Lee hears in the hallway. Insane. Once again, the fact this theory is even gaining any sort of acceptance is proof that as a forum and fan base we have literally exhausted everything to talk about.
Stranger has the same gun because of lazy game makers. In this game there was just one gun for all scenes - Carley's. They were too busy or lazy to draw and program new type of gun.
There's more to it - when you take the walker's gun in the jewelry store, it's Beretta, but when Clementine takes it, it becomes Glock. Magic, perhaps?
Stranger has the same gun because of lazy game makers. In this game there was just one gun for all scenes - Carley's. They were too busy or lazy to draw and program new type of gun.
but in fairness there is still that mysterious noise. It isn't helpful for specific theories but that dragging sound still hasn't been explained. I agree that it is slim evidence for specific particular theories, but it definitely sounds like dragging, and with it being unexplained leaves it open for speculation and possibly further exploration in this Season.
a theory isn't wrong until it's proved wrong, and in the same way it isn't right until it's proved right. The stuff about the adjoining room is still pretty strange, and TellTale won't have blocked access to it unless they had a good reason. I'm not sure the gun thing is evidence of it. I do think that something must have been in the adjoining room, but I'm not exactly sure
Oh, I agree with you.
I didn't mean to suggest that there's no possible importance to the noises.
But until Telltale shows us what they mean, every theory based on them is nothing more than fanfiction, or wishful thinking.
but in fairness there is still that mysterious noise. It isn't helpful for specific theories but that dragging sound still hasn't been explain… moreed. I agree that it is slim evidence for specific particular theories, but it definitely sounds like dragging, and with it being unexplained leaves it open for speculation and possibly further exploration in this Season.
1) Seconds before the Stranger appears, we hear a door closing. The stranger mighta've hid in the adjoining room.
2) Clem was probably insi… morede the closet. She mighta've heard a fight, but she couldn't see anything. Since they were fighting, Kenny mighta've not talked much, since he was so angry, he woulda've walked in and just start kicking his ass.
3) You're welcome.
4) He climbed down the stairs and got out through the door?
5) Sorry, I can't avoid it.
I Agree:D Kenny is to much of a good man and a BIG man and in condition to fight a guy who couldnt leave their daughter or wife.did he rly had to take tht head?i almost vomited :O anyways it might be Lilly!!!!!!!!!!i hope she is and she is dead i dont want to see her again :P
Hmmm, I dunno, the gun seems to be the only evidence here.
The rest is just a story made up to fit the sounds.
The same can be done with L… moreilly really.
While following the group the stranger saves Lilly.
They both decide to take revenge, but at the last minute when Lee shows up Lilly changes her mind. The stranger and Lilly struggle, etc.
Clem doesn't want Lee to open the door because she doesn't want him to hurt Lilly.
(no, I'm not in the Lilly camp, or the Kenny camp. Just saying it could have been anything)
Wait a min .. If Kenny had only one shot in the gun and he used it at Ben to kill him ,,, How did the gun had ammo if you killed the stranger / Clementine killed the stranger??? ...
I don't know if you already know this or not, but if you want more depth to the Stranger, then you might be in interested in knowing that in one of the non-canon Lee death scenes the Stranger actually says "I'm sorry" before shooting Lee in the head, which I found very interesting. (starts at 9:50)
In this video, Clementine isn't wearing the hoodie, but I tested it out on my save in which I stole from the car and I also did the "asshole" options like saying that he looks like a monster, saying he fucked up, etc... and he still said "I'm sorry."
Here's a video (not mine) of the same scene with Clem wearing the hoodie: (starts at 3:06)
If the points given are true (Episode 5 is too emotionally wrecking for me to replay and check), then this is a very good theory. I haven't be… moreen convinced, but this is quite plausible, and if it turns to be the real thing, this person deserves applause. The gun part seems the most sketchy, what with TTG reusing whole people models for corpses in S2E1 from S1E5. It's easily possible they are just reused models. Still, even without that as evidence, the theory still stands quite well. Good job.
Also, if the gun part is true, then it adds some new depth to the Stranger. Kenny probably had no more bullets, and so the stranger may have be using an empty gun all along. Wait, no, Clementine did have bullets in the gun. Oh well, more speculation fodder, at least.
I think Kenny was in the same room as Clementine but the stranger knocked him out and dragged him into the adjoining room. Clementine might of thought he was dead or he had turned into a walker and that is why she told Lee that there was nothing in it. This makes me think that the "I thought you were dead" person is Kenny.
I mean Stranger did have a reason to hate Kenny. "That asshole in the ball cap." You can tell he didn't like him and had motives for the group and Lee.
I have a feeling that the more we keep posting accurate theories; the longer telltale will take to release the next episode. Same with TWaU. Probably trying to change their story up a bit.
1) When Lee enters, to his left, there's a bed (I think) and then another door. That's the door to the "adjoining room".
2) When Lee examin… morees the rope, the door to the left.
4) Perhaps a fire escape that lead onto the street? BTW, what about Ben's death? We can actually see him running through the horde of zombies.
There are three doors. One that you enter through, one that Clemy Clu enters through, and another that Clem comments on if you approach it. Though now that I think about it, the stranger didn't just materialize out of nowhere. It's likely they added the door so we wouldn't assume he was hiding under the bed when we entered. DAMN IT! I really wanted to see that door in season 2.
But, that room he's talking about. Isn't that the room Clem enters from to hit the stranger in the back? Why wouldn't she tell Lee that Kenny's back there?
4) 4:14 See that row of windows? Kenny could just open a window and escape. Stop at 4:28 and look at Lee's left arm. Play the video again and there you see a figure running away.
1) Interesting, give me a day when I don't feel sick to respond to this.
2) So that would explain why the door opening was so loud, but aga… morein, I'm not in top form today.
4) No you can't. You see him disappear into the zombies, and you never see him again. I kinda wished that it would stay this way.
yeah so just replayed the last episode again and there is definitely something up with the mystery door next the bed. There is blood across it (and the Stranger doesn't appear to be bloodied himself), and when you try to open it the game doesn't let you and Clem tells you that you need to go. You can definitely hear a dragging sound before you enter, and I'm assuming the Stranger comes out from that room to talk to Lee. Don't understand why TellTale would give you the option to open it when you can't, unless there is something up. That was the only door other than the exit that you are given the option to open, so I think there is some significance there. Whether it is Kenny is still unknown, but we can't deny it outright. For all we know it could be a new character who appears in the Season or it could just be a dead walker. I'm guessing Clem didn't hear anything so there must have been a very short scuffle if it was a person. The blood is on the top of the door like "/" across. Don't think it's just a walker, because the Stranger would have really struggled. I'm not a forensic expert so I have no idea how the blood mark could be formed unless with a sharp-edged slash, but then a conscious person would have felt the pain and shouted, so I dunno.
Not sure about the gun thing, but the mystery door is very intriguing.
credible point but you would think that she would at least be curious about it or at least tell Lee, unless the Stranger knocked out the person silently and without them making a sound
Comments
Wait a min .. If Kenny had only one shot in the gun and he used it at Ben to kill him ,,, How did the gun had ammo if you killed the stranger / Clementine killed the stranger??? ...
He may have had ammo in his car. Also, if you choke the stranger and then shoot him in the head, you only have one bullet remaining. If you choke the stranger and just leave him, you still only have one bullet remaining. Telltale's attention to detail in situations like this is pretty lacking.
Regarding the stranger's hiding spot: Actually, the Stranger was hiding in the bathroom before Lee showed up. You can just about see the bathroom door when he talks to Lee for the first time. It's basically a fourth door
Ah, that'd make sense.
Someone needs to make one of these for the juice box. :P
You are absolutely right. Any logical person could see that. A whole theory based off hearing a noise. Insane. I honestly just can not believe people are buying into this. Its a cool STORY but people are praising this theory like they are now certain this happened.
I think the part with the gun isn't true. I think that Telltale made one gun model. Take a look on every gun in the game, they're the same!
1) When Lee enters, to his left, there's a bed (I think) and then another door. That's the door to the "adjoining room".
2) When Lee examines the rope, the door to the left.
4) Perhaps a fire escape that lead onto the street? BTW, what about Ben's death? We can actually see him running through the horde of zombies.
I think the theories unlikely; but I'm damned interested in that door now!
Yeah, there's definately some tunnel vision going on.
Ah well, as long as nobody here gets called for jury duty on some poor guy's trial, there's no real harm done.
Agreed. It's been done in other series though
Funny fact - if you don't shoot him to prevent reanimation, you still have only ONE shot.
please
no more fight
But, that room he's talking about. Isn't that the room Clem enters from to hit the stranger in the back? Why wouldn't she tell Lee that Kenny's back there?
Of all the theories I read so far, this one seems like the most plausible to me.
You obviously doesn't know what 100% means.
This forum will completely explode if this theory turns out to be true.
But still, it's just a theory dude. It may be hilarious to some people. But still...Just a theory.
While I doubt this is true, if it does turn out to be Kenny in episode 2 and this was planned all along by Telltale I might just cream my pants
Stranger has the same gun because of lazy game makers. In this game there was just one gun for all scenes - Carley's. They were too busy or lazy to draw and program new type of gun.
There's more to it - when you take the walker's gun in the jewelry store, it's Beretta, but when Clementine takes it, it becomes Glock. Magic, perhaps?
but in fairness there is still that mysterious noise. It isn't helpful for specific theories but that dragging sound still hasn't been explained. I agree that it is slim evidence for specific particular theories, but it definitely sounds like dragging, and with it being unexplained leaves it open for speculation and possibly further exploration in this Season.
a theory isn't wrong until it's proved wrong, and in the same way it isn't right until it's proved right. The stuff about the adjoining room is still pretty strange, and TellTale won't have blocked access to it unless they had a good reason. I'm not sure the gun thing is evidence of it. I do think that something must have been in the adjoining room, but I'm not exactly sure
Oh, I agree with you.
I didn't mean to suggest that there's no possible importance to the noises.
But until Telltale shows us what they mean, every theory based on them is nothing more than fanfiction, or wishful thinking.
i am replaying here cuz i dont want anywhere :P
so i think it might be Molly but she's one helluva wrestler gurly:D but it might be
I Agree:D Kenny is to much of a good man and a BIG man and in condition to fight a guy who couldnt leave their daughter or wife.did he rly had to take tht head?i almost vomited :O anyways it might be Lilly!!!!!!!!!!i hope she is and she is dead i dont want to see her again :P
the Campman could've had ammo
I don't know if you already know this or not, but if you want more depth to the Stranger, then you might be in interested in knowing that in one of the non-canon Lee death scenes the Stranger actually says "I'm sorry" before shooting Lee in the head, which I found very interesting. (starts at 9:50)
In this video, Clementine isn't wearing the hoodie, but I tested it out on my save in which I stole from the car and I also did the "asshole" options like saying that he looks like a monster, saying he fucked up, etc... and he still said "I'm sorry."
Here's a video (not mine) of the same scene with Clem wearing the hoodie: (starts at 3:06)
I think Kenny was in the same room as Clementine but the stranger knocked him out and dragged him into the adjoining room. Clementine might of thought he was dead or he had turned into a walker and that is why she told Lee that there was nothing in it. This makes me think that the "I thought you were dead" person is Kenny.
I mean Stranger did have a reason to hate Kenny. "That asshole in the ball cap." You can tell he didn't like him and had motives for the group and Lee.
I got something for you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I have a feeling that the more we keep posting accurate theories; the longer telltale will take to release the next episode. Same with TWaU. Probably trying to change their story up a bit.
1) Interesting, give me a day when I don't feel sick to respond to this.
2) So that would explain why the door opening was so loud, but again, I'm not in top form today.
4) No you can't. You see him disappear into the zombies, and you never see him again. I kinda wished that it would stay this way.
There are three doors. One that you enter through, one that Clemy Clu enters through, and another that Clem comments on if you approach it. Though now that I think about it, the stranger didn't just materialize out of nowhere. It's likely they added the door so we wouldn't assume he was hiding under the bed when we entered. DAMN IT! I really wanted to see that door in season 2.
4)
4:14 See that row of windows? Kenny could just open a window and escape. Stop at 4:28 and look at Lee's left arm. Play the video again and there you see a figure running away.
yeah so just replayed the last episode again and there is definitely something up with the mystery door next the bed. There is blood across it (and the Stranger doesn't appear to be bloodied himself), and when you try to open it the game doesn't let you and Clem tells you that you need to go. You can definitely hear a dragging sound before you enter, and I'm assuming the Stranger comes out from that room to talk to Lee. Don't understand why TellTale would give you the option to open it when you can't, unless there is something up. That was the only door other than the exit that you are given the option to open, so I think there is some significance there. Whether it is Kenny is still unknown, but we can't deny it outright. For all we know it could be a new character who appears in the Season or it could just be a dead walker. I'm guessing Clem didn't hear anything so there must have been a very short scuffle if it was a person. The blood is on the top of the door like "/" across. Don't think it's just a walker, because the Stranger would have really struggled. I'm not a forensic expert so I have no idea how the blood mark could be formed unless with a sharp-edged slash, but then a conscious person would have felt the pain and shouted, so I dunno.
Not sure about the gun thing, but the mystery door is very intriguing.
credible point but you would think that she would at least be curious about it or at least tell Lee, unless the Stranger knocked out the person silently and without them making a sound