Kill or let go Roberto?

edited January 2014 in The Walking Dead

Hi, according to you, is better kill roberto or let him go? If you kill him, Boyd live, but if u let him go he kill boyd... What choise is better?

Comments

  • This was really hard for me, you know.
    First time: i didn't kill him, cause i couldn't. But then they say that Boyd died because of that... So i replayed this episode and kiledl the boy. But it was hard, you know...

  • I let him go, I dont care about Boyd he and his buddies stole Kennys boat...

  • edited January 2014

    Normally I would actually agree with you, I love revenge. But in this case I just feel bad for Boyd. He was the only one of the surviving cancer group members that could at least see why their group fell apart and who actually felt bad for beating up whoever was in the garage.

    It doesn't make their actions any less bad, but Boyd just deserved better.

    Vegetto posted: »

    I let him go, I dont care about Boyd he and his buddies stole Kennys boat...

  • Killing him is obviously the better outcome for the group, but based on what we knew at the time I stuck with my choice of letting him go.

  • Yeah, same here. Killing him just because you know the outcome is rather meta-gamey.

    Mikejames posted: »

    Killing him is obviously the better outcome for the group, but based on what we knew at the time I stuck with my choice of letting him go.

  • Killed him first time, obvious threat to the group. If id been in charge and maybe locked him up and interrogated him.

    Guess I made the right call considering Boyd survived

  • I let him go at first, which I regreted after. But the fact that I made this decision is a bit of TT's fault. I like the story and such, but your choices don't lead onto a bunch of ramifications of endings. Not that I'm against this, actually I prefer that TWD remains this way, but I thought: "Emm, what's the worse that can happen, not that my choice will matter. I'll let him go.". Of course, Boyd died due to my ignorance. Afterwards, I placed a bullet in Steph's head. If I let her go, she would come back to Gil's Pitstop and steal the group's supplies and might even kill Roman. So, I did what I had to...

  • I was going to kill him at first because I felt he was a threat but my conscience got the better of me and I ended up letting him go. If he was an innocent man I would hold myself accountable for his death but I also hold myself accountable for Boyd's death.

  • The first time? I let him go.

    Then Boyd died. I thought "Well, shit, I better kill Stephanie now or something else that's bad could happen." So I shot her.

    Then Shel and Becca refused to go with Tavia at the end of 400 Days. Why can't I win?!

  • Sure you could do that, only if you knew how to speak portuguese, then maybe he would have talked.

    Killed him first time, obvious threat to the group. If id been in charge and maybe locked him up and interrogated him. Guess I made the right call considering Boyd survived

  • sorry who the hell is roberto
    lol

  • this guy from Shel's story in 400days http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Roberto

  • Haha. sounds about right.

    Still holding out for the staying at the camp outcome to not be one-sidedly bad.

    Rock114 posted: »

    The first time? I let him go. Then Boyd died. I thought "Well, shit, I better kill Stephanie now or something else that's bad could happen." So I shot her. Then Shel and Becca refused to go with Tavia at the end of 400 Days. Why can't I win?!

  • Let him go and rode off in the RV.

    Becca better remember that.

  • The only people that went with Tavia in my game were the drug addict and the convicted murderer. Gee, I bet they'll just love the new upstanding members of their community.

    Mikejames posted: »

    Haha. sounds about right. Still holding out for the staying at the camp outcome to not be one-sidedly bad.

  • I guess we've seen our share of baggage... Though I can imagine Tavia's group having a few Nates if they just let anyone in.

    Rock114 posted: »

    The only people that went with Tavia in my game were the drug addict and the convicted murderer. Gee, I bet they'll just love the new upstanding members of their community.

  • Imagine Russell walking through the gates, only to see a familiar figure in a hat turn around and greet him.

    "ASSWIPE, man, I've been looking for you! We've got so much to catch up on!"

    Mikejames posted: »

    I guess we've seen our share of baggage... Though I can imagine Tavia's group having a few Nates if they just let anyone in.

  • Cue Russell and Wyatt's immediate 180.

    Rock114 posted: »

    Imagine Russell walking through the gates, only to see a familiar figure in a hat turn around and greet him. "ASSWIPE, man, I've been looking for you! We've got so much to catch up on!"

  • Hah, Nate even says at Gil's Pitstop "Asswipe got moves.". Man, I want Nate to enter the series.

    Rock114 posted: »

    Imagine Russell walking through the gates, only to see a familiar figure in a hat turn around and greet him. "ASSWIPE, man, I've been looking for you! We've got so much to catch up on!"

  • I

    Killed Roberto - The easier choice, he wasn't going to survive for long in that condition anyway, he wasn't going to be tagging along with anyone who didn't spoke portuguese, and he was unfortunately in America (no racism intended tho).

    killed Stephanie - The harder decision. There was no other choice than either to do it, or leave with the high risk of death in the outside world. I would have chosen to let her go with a few stuff if I could, but I couldn't...

  • maybey if u kill him, then boyd will be in season 2, omg guys we need a boyd confirmed for season 2 gif XD

  • If only I knew how to make .gifs in GIMP... which i'm totally planning to learn right now. But i'm guessing someone's gonna beat me to it...

    Alt text

    dylanvdg posted: »

    maybey if u kill him, then boyd will be in season 2, omg guys we need a boyd confirmed for season 2 gif XD

  • I'm trying, even though I have no experience at all

    If only I knew how to make .gifs in GIMP... which i'm totally planning to learn right now. But i'm guessing someone's gonna beat me to it...

  • Do it, man. I have faith in you.

    Alt text

    SomGuye posted: »

    I'm trying, even though I have no experience at all

  • You don't have to choose. Kill him and he'll go.

  • Yeah your right but Boyd voted to let him go so his death was his own fault. And I agree with you he was the only one in cancer group who seem ok.

    Wuzhles posted: »

    Normally I would actually agree with you, I love revenge. But in this case I just feel bad for Boyd. He was the only one of the surviving canc

  • i killed him straight away.

  • edited March 2015

    Killed him.

    I orginally supported the idea of him staying and finding a way for him to contribute and protect the group, but that wasn't the case. It was one or the other, and I had the groups best interest in mind. I DIDN'T want to kill him, but I DIDNT want him to come back with a gang and kill us all. Turns out, I made the right choice. If you let him go, he brings his buddies back and it results in Boyd getting killed.

  • One year ago.

    Come on people.

    TWDxKenny1 posted: »

    Killed him. I orginally supported the idea of him staying and finding a way for him to contribute and protect the group, but that wasn't

  • Killed Roberto and Left in the RV :p

  • Let him go for Boyd, and Telltale slaps me in the face by making Roberto come back and guess who dies? The one that wanted to let him go... 100% done.

  • lol, I just executed him because it's for the group's safety.

    Let him go for Boyd, and Telltale slaps me in the face by making Roberto come back and guess who dies? The one that wanted to let him go... 100% done.

  • I don't like killing people. :\

    lol, I just executed him because it's for the group's safety.

  • Not killing threats makes others die...As you saw.

    I don't like killing people.

  • Killing them isn't right in my opinion. My morality is a flaw.

    Not killing threats makes others die...As you saw.

  • To each his own.

    Killing them isn't right in my opinion. My morality is a flaw.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.