Do you mean for Season 2 (to capture an developing voice from a little girl to a teenager)? Or for Season 3? Or from the very beginning?
I would obviously still play from the very beginning because I wouldn't have known Melissa. Season 2, would still play since it doesn't really matter and brings more realism to her character. Though it might be a little hard to adjust. For season 3, same as Season 2 reasoning.
I would. However, I want to see what Melissa has talent wise. She gave Clem some expressive range in Season 1. Season 2 was more monotone sounding, but I can understand that approach, especially considering that the monotone voicing started after the 16 month time jump. If she does Clem in Season 3, I want TellTale to have her push her boundaries. Since we can assume her voice will be changing again due to puberty, this might allow Melissa to express more character range as she won't be as limited with Clem's kid-like pitch. Again, this is all assuming Clem is in Season 3. If not, give Melissa an adult character and let her do something different. I'm sure she has range; why limit her to kid roles? Let her show off.
Ok, excuse my tangent there. Back to your question; yes, I would play if Clem had a different voice actress.
Comments
I don't know why Melissa would decline, but yeah I would still play it.
God it would take me so long to get used to it, but yeah, I eventually would.
I would still play but it would be weird.
I need more context here.
Do you mean for Season 2 (to capture an developing voice from a little girl to a teenager)? Or for Season 3? Or from the very beginning?
I would obviously still play from the very beginning because I wouldn't have known Melissa. Season 2, would still play since it doesn't really matter and brings more realism to her character. Though it might be a little hard to adjust. For season 3, same as Season 2 reasoning.
Would I play it without Melissa? Yeah I would. But I would resent it.
Play it, but would find it too weird. It would feel uncomfortable every time she spoke.
I would. However, I want to see what Melissa has talent wise. She gave Clem some expressive range in Season 1. Season 2 was more monotone sounding, but I can understand that approach, especially considering that the monotone voicing started after the 16 month time jump. If she does Clem in Season 3, I want TellTale to have her push her boundaries. Since we can assume her voice will be changing again due to puberty, this might allow Melissa to express more character range as she won't be as limited with Clem's kid-like pitch. Again, this is all assuming Clem is in Season 3. If not, give Melissa an adult character and let her do something different. I'm sure she has range; why limit her to kid roles? Let her show off.
Ok, excuse my tangent there. Back to your question; yes, I would play if Clem had a different voice actress.
It would be exactly what happened with MGSV