›

Lilly (Season 1) = Lilly Caul (Comics) ??

JordaaNPopeeJordaaNPopee
edited February 2016 in The Walking Dead

This is just me thinking, this probably has been talked about by now and or it's already been debunked so this might be pointless. But here I go anyway...

enter image description here

Both obviously called Lilly, both are around the 30ish age and both have brown hair.

Lilly (S1) current status is unknown so she could be anywhere right now. Now I know both characters have different parents but the way game/tv/comics change the lore it could be the same thing here.

Did our Lilly from season one eventually go to the path of Lilly Caul and find Brian Blake & Rick Grimes? And that's why she may not have appeared again?
Could the game maybe tie in someway to comic as Michonne is currently doing - As we know we already met Glenn in (S1) briefly so we know it's similar to the Comic. Just maybe we might eventually get Rick & Clem... I don't know but it would be cool :)

enter image description here

And of course I probably am wrong but what are the forums for eh? To discuss!

If this is true then we might not see her again - But if i'm wrong (Likely) I would like to see her crop up again in future games :)

Comments

  • AnthornAnthorn
    edited February 2016

    Actually it's not a theory. When TWD came out in 2012 there was an achievement called. Road to Woodbury which happened when Lilly left the group. So it WAS Lilly from the comics. Then they changed it for some reason and patched the achievement out of it.
    Also the game is set in the comic book universe. So everything that happened in the comics happens in the game but Clem and that just don't see it cause they're in a different area.

  • DawnbreakerDawnbreaker

    She WAS Lilly from the comics... until 'The Road to Woodbury' came out and contradicted the Telltale game, causing game Lilly to be considered a separate entity from novel and comic Lilly. So blame the novels and their poor canonical knowledge for this happening, basically.

  • AnthornAnthorn

    Wasn't the novel written by Robert Kirkman though.

    Dawnbreaker posted: »

    She WAS Lilly from the comics... until 'The Road to Woodbury' came out and contradicted the Telltale game, causing game Lilly to be consider

  • JordaaNPopeeJordaaNPopee

    I did not know this. Thanks! :)

    Anthorn posted: »

    Actually it's not a theory. When TWD came out in 2012 there was an achievement called. Road to Woodbury which happened when Lilly left the g

  • JordaaNPopeeJordaaNPopee

    :) I always wondered but I was just basing off Name & similar appearance. Canon is Comic/TV/Games are always different is just gets all tangled.

    Dawnbreaker posted: »

    She WAS Lilly from the comics... until 'The Road to Woodbury' came out and contradicted the Telltale game, causing game Lilly to be consider

  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator

    Like others have said Lilly was supposed to be the same Lilly from the comics but they changed it when Robert Kirkman decided to make the Road to Woodbury novel.

    Just out of interest i went and checked the internet archive website and took a screenshot on the cast page which shows Lilly's character information before and after the novel was released showing what they removed.

    Before the novel

    enter image description here

    After the novel

    enter image description here

  • JordaaNPopeeJordaaNPopee

    Ah, this is quite interesting tbh. I didnt know this, but it's always been a question I wanted answered out of curiosity. And yeah it is a 'Huge Impact' to the Grime family.

    Cheers for this Ozzy

    OzzyUK posted: »

    Like others have said Lilly was supposed to be the same Lilly from the comics but they changed it when Robert Kirkman decided to make the Ro

Sign in to comment in this discussion.