Christa's Baby
cutupuss
Banned
In episode 5 of season 2 when jane hides AJ and Clementine and Kenny think he's dead, clementine says,"Not again." Some people think she's referring to Christa's "miscarriage" but then why would she say that when the baby is already been born and healthy? So maybe Christa's baby was born, and it was killed?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
That's what I think happened.
I don't think so, she is probably just refering to another baby dying, I don't belive that Christa would be irresponsible enough to let her baby be killed.
Jane killed Christa's baby. That's why Clementine said "not again".
I thought Clementine was referring to Kenng becoming reckless again, to the point where he could kill somebody? That's much more likely, since Clem herself could end up harmed and therefore it worried her, than some parallel connecting Christa's baby's death with the supposed death of this baby who she hasn't grown attached to yet.
I don't think so. I think it was either about Christa's baby, or about Kenny losing someone else that he loved. Clementine never showed fear of Kenny. If she showed it then it would make sense, but she didn't ever show fear.
It wouldn't be fear as much as it would be worry and anxiety over not being able to stop him if something happened. That's my opinion; yours is just as valid of course, since we're just speculating.
That's an interesting point, but at this time Kenny hadn't really made an attachment to the baby, and Kenny had just come around from his outburst over Sarita, so it's unlikely she'd think that now and not after Sarita. It's an interesting point but I think it's at the wrong time for 'Not again' to be referring to Kenny, Everyone there, Clem included, was looking at the baby, rather than at Kenny
I think this can be interpreted in 2 ways either
or
2.. The fact Kenny lost Duck, Sarita and Kajja and in some way his irresponsibility lead to these things and Clem thinks this is being repeated.
I'm pretty sure she's referring to Christa's baby. I think it's likely that the baby was killed later after being born.
She was just like "for fucks sake! More crazy outlandish shit, really?"
It's never been confirmed that Christa had a miscarriage, all we know is that the baby is dead. So it either died sometime after being born which would make most sense when Clementine says "not again", or it was a stillbirth and Clementine was referring to another baby dying when she says "not again."
Or maybe that was meant for kenny as he had already suffered so much and aj dying would make him completely mad
I can only comment about how I felt about that scene, I 100% thought that she had a miscarriage. or maybe died during childbirth? I feel things like these does not need an explanation. its a sad story anyway.
I think Christa's baby wasn't able to breathe after it was born and died that way. Remember , AJ didn't move for a second after he was born.
There's no guarantee the baby's dead, we only know it wasn't with Christa and Clem. Implied death isn't quite confirmed death.
I feel like, the baby was born.
With how Clem says 'no, not again', in regards to Jane showing up after being seperated from Clem, then returning without the kid.
I feel like Clem is having Major deja-vu right then. That that scene, (minus the Kenny of it all), is how it played out with Christa and her child. But, i don't think we will ever know for certain
Do you honestly think that the baby is alive? It's obviously dead, come on.
She didn't know jane before they met each over at carvers camp though..
....
It was a joke.
.-.
I thought Clem saying "not again" was her thinking of how she'd already lost Kenny that one time in S1, and she doesn't want to lose him again by him just running out in the blizzard.
I reiterate; implied death isn't confirmed death. Hey, we all thought Kenny was dead for what, a year?
It's likely but not definite.
In Season 2 - Episode 1, Clementine says in the Still. Not. Bitten scene (
) ''And now, just like last time. Just how Christa showed me.''
My theory is that Christa gave birth to her baby by caesarean and Clementine had to suture Christa.
I think Christa and Clem ate the baby. They look pretty healthy for being on such hard times, they had to get that strength from somewhere and as everyone knows babies taste like macaroni & cheese wrapped in candy mystery solved your welcome.
I think Christa would be willing to do a lot to survive, but not THAT, especially with Clem.
First thing I though was, "a newborn baby can't have that many calories."
Then realized that you were being sarcastic, but I went ahead and did some research—no experimentation of fucking course—about how many calories one could expect a newborn baby to have. Found literally nothing on that. Just panicking parents who didn't know what to feed their children.
A c-section is major abdominal surgery. Completely different than stitching up an arm. Christa would never survive it outside of an operating room, especially if her only help was a 10 year old girl. Christa probably showed Clem how to patch up a skinned knee or something similar.
As for the baby, it was most likely stillborn or died soon after birth. It's not very important to the story but I would like to know.
Yes, I do think that she would be mature enough to comprehend something like that. She's had to grow up and deal w/a lot of shit herelf. Clem's old enough to remember how much Kenny changed after losing Duck; maybe not right away, but def by the time they reached the mansion. It was obvious, given the dialogue choices, that Kenny had become attached to the baby. At one point Kenny even says to Clementine that he's gonna raise A.j right & better than he did Duck. I think that was enough information for her to link the loss of A.j with the loss of Duck.