At this point in time, Which Rick do you think is tougher?
Comic Rick?
Or TV Rick?
from what I know, Comic Rick has had a lot of fighting experience, but he has also suffered way more physical abuse. From what I've heard, not only has he lost one of his hands - the right one I believe - but is also now walking on a cane now.
TV Rick on the other hand, has all of his limbs, and for the most part has been pretty lucky to have not suffered any real serious injury in his time in the apocalypse, aside from getting shot twice - in the shoulder before the apocalypse began - and the second time in the leg, when the Governor besieged the prison in Season 4.
Given that TV Rick is in much better physical condition, and his level of combat experience, I'd say that TV Rick is more dangerous than his Comic Book Counterpart.
As matter of fact, having played the Last Of Us, TV Rick at this point kinda reminds of Joel - in how vicious of a fighter he is - but unlike Joel - Rick seems to have a little more compassion.
Comments
Comic Rick would MURDER TV Rick like nothing. I've never seen anyone in fiction become a better fighter after losing one of their hands. He's also a more brutal fighter than TV Rick and wouldn't have gotten his ass kicked by The Governor or Shane
Well the Tv show does bring it down a level unfortunately, and one of the reasons Rick isn't loosing his hand in the show is because Robert Kirkman said he regrets doing that to Rick, and it caused plenty of drawing mistakes, and having to remove Rick's hand for every episode would be a hassle.
However, I hope they will still have Negan break Rick's leg.
Well the compassion of AMC Rick would be his losing factor in my opinion. Both RIcks have had their share of beating someone else to a pulp, but AMC Rick is usually much quicker to stop or realize what he's doing. The Skybound Rick seems to keep going and going until his hands are mangled and he's covered in blood.
Pun intended? :P
I'd say as of right now (Issue #155-Episode 6x16) TV Rick is stronger for obvious reasons, although TV Rick had it a bit easier since he didn't suffer as much as his comic counterpart. We'll see how it goes from here. I'm hoping Comic Rick goes back to his survivor self.
At the moment yeah, comic Rick would get killed by TV Rick because of his bum leg.
Left hand
Haven't read the comic, but TV Rick is pretty badass:
Comic Rick has done the very same, and just as gruesomely.