I'm in a dilemma
So I always keep the choices that I did on my first play through as canon, but after seeing that new trailer for season 3 I can't help but regret my decision at the end of season 2. On my first and "canon" play through I chose to go into Wellington resulting in Kenny leaving. I cried hard, like bawling hard. Hours later I just couldn't handle it and changed my ending to staying with Kenny.
Judging by the new season 3 trailer, it seems like our ending choices won't even matter and that our voice of Kenny and Jane will just fizzle out. Leaving Kenny for Wellington makes me think that that was just a way for the writers to get him out of the way. If Kenny's story just ends with him going off alone or him dying at the beginning of season 3 at the beginning, then I want him to still be there in the story, but I still feel that I should go with my original ending of leaving Kenny for Wellington since I never break my rule of never changing my first play through choice. I don't know, can I get some opinions? This has been bothering me for awhile now
Comments
Wow. I didn't know anyone was still affected by TTG choices like that. Its a short game take it as that A GAME its not too serious it shouldn't upset you, replay it time and time again, kill people for lolz. We all know that TTG circle around so deaths are determined the choices are a illusion anyway.
Relax.
Well for one, we have only seen the trailer so it's unfair to say how decisions don't work. Honestly, just do whatever you want, it shouldn't really be too serious of a dilemma. What I like to do is, unless it's a misclick or due to bugs/control issues, I keep all my choices, even if I later come to regret them because that's just how life goes.
They said that the endings will play a part in season 3. How? No idea.
I've been through similar dilemmas and I think that you should stick with your original choice. The regret you feel from making that really difficult choice is part of the tailored story experience, and having to live with that regret with continue to shape your story in a way that is most coherent for you and how you play things.
I don't think you'll regret keeping your original choice because even if you're beating yourself up and questioning yourself that is normal and just shows the effect that the game had on you.
The vibe im getting is that sadly TTG will probably only mention the choices we chose through dialogue and Clem will tell Javier "i was with Kenny" or "i was with Jane" or "i was on my own" which would effectively screw us players with our choices to be honest. I don't want that to be true but it's just what i can see them doing, taking the easy option! I'd love to see them do what they've never done before and that is have determinant characters survive longer than a few episodes AND still have an importsnt role to play in the story and not just become a background character like so many others have before.
I got upset too when I fineshed season 2, I couldn't sleep that night ( Rip Kenny ) and had a headache for the next 2 days...
Everyones a critic. Just be who you are as a gamer! After all you bought the darn thing! This is your mad libs story, make your choice, see how it unfolds!
I have always done the same thing in playing the game and living with the outcome of my choices no matter what. For me, at the end of season 2 I shot Kenny and went with Jane (Only because I felt Clem had a better chance to survive in the world with Jane) but I HATED shooting Kenny, I've regretted that choice every time I think about it. But, I wont ever change it because, like if it were in RL, you couldn't change what was already done. Yes, it's regret but in the moment of having to make a choice, we make it and live with it no matter how hard it may be.
So, my answer is actually the way I believe in that you play the game and keep it the way you played it. Pure! This is a game based on the characters of the story and the choices you make, I think it negates the intent of the game when people go back and replay a scene just because they didnt like the outcome. You can't do that in RL. There is no rewind or do-over. Just live with it and move on.
All that being said, I will say that because we have 3 saves, I have always kept my save1, the first origional play throughs and then replayed the games using my other 2 saves simply to see what happens with the game making different choices, but even with those i've never "changed" a choice.
I am very aware of that, however we are on a gaming forum talking about a game, so I don't really see why you felt the need to say that. Hopefully you weren't intending on insulting me with that comment.
I change my choices all the time. Yeah, I know. The first play through I always do what my gut says. Afterwards, I do a "canon" play through where I make choices that result in the best story.
I personally went into Wellington and left Kenny. I felt like that made for the best ending as well as the best starting point. It's up to you, just do whatever would make you happiest.
I killed Kenny and am with Jane and the family
I was going to do a replay and stay with kenny, But after doing much thinking I decided against it.
Kenny was just to much of a liability towards the end. Dude had to go
Do whatever you want. It's anyone's guess how she loses her finger anyway.
Honestly, I plan on replaying the first two seasons because it's been too damn long and I can't remember any of my decisions. Perhaps you should go back and replay as well? If you regret the decision, then there's nothing wrong with going back and redoing it. You should play the game how you want to. TellTale is all about choice after all.
there isn't enough save slots to explore what our choices actually affect. It seems like the choices matter but if you don't have enough save slots to realize all endings there is no point.