Those who chose Jane
deleted9633306
Banned
Those who chose Jane, you do not feel betrayed by it ?
Because, the first time, I did well to choose Kenny. If Jane had forced me to kill Kenny, so that I would be with her, then she would abandon me later by committing suicide ? Because she is pregnant ? And me then ! She leaves me alone with a baby ! If I would be in Clementine's place... I do not see what word would describe what I feel, I would have be so much shocked, I would feel so guilty for Kenny, losing all my friends, be alone, all that for this result... I would lose all hope, I would have let myself die.
For me, choose Jane is the worst choice. It's so sad to abandon Clem and AJ like that. It was not she that I chose but I feel so bad for you, wtf it's so sad [teary-eyed].
I chose to stay with Kenny and thanks it's the best choice for me.
Comments
It made me sigh a depressing sigh of sadness, which is exactly as it should have done.
I'm like "Oh god damnit... this poor kid..."
So I guess I liked it.
I feel more betrayed by that family that stole our food. :P
I made a joke. Lel I'm a sick bastard.
I liked it. It was a fucked up situation she got herself in. She didn't want to have another baby to take care of and she definitely wasn't the type who'd like to go through all this pregnancy.
And I did feel bad for everyone involved.
´´How s it hanging Jane?´´ Lol
I don't feel betrayed. Honestly she really didn't have any options. Have a baby in this world that an 11 year old would have to deliver, they're already taking care of AJ, she doesn't even know if she'll have enough food.
Honestly I think her killing herself avoided more trauma compared to if she kept it. Also I don't expect her to just take abortion pills because "she should have stayed alive for Clementine." No matter how heartless you might think she is, killing her own unborn child would have had such an emotional toll on her. Also, If the baby died inside of her it could have turned. Killing herself was practically her only option. I wouldn't forced her to live through all that.
Oh sure I was sad...very sad...ok I did shed a tear or 3. I was hit by a number of emotions. 1. Poor Clementine...what a fucking thing for an 11 year old to find. 2. Poor Jane...I have in another post written out why it worked for me. Pre-natal Depression hits up to 23% of women in todays's civilized world where there is abundant care options. Care options are pretty scarce in the apocalypse. Sleep deprevation..bad nutrition...the family leaving as they did...fear of the birth (ie Rebecca died) Baby is another mouth to feed. it added up to more than Jane could handle...normally you could talk to a friend..but spilling your guts to an 11 year old kid, no matter how mature she is...not easy. 3. God damn TellTale...it actually works and is understandable...still you took another knife to my heart.
I think that the reason why Jane committed suicide was not because she was pregnant but it is was as a result of the family that robbed/stole from them (depending on what you did in season 2) and she knew that there were not enough supplies to keep herself and Clementine fed alone with AJ and her baby. So in Jane's mind, she did what she thought was the only thing possible to keep, Clementine and AJ going along for at least a few more days at most by committing suicide.
this basically ^^
i still don't like how it was written, but for what it was and her reasoning to do it, i get it.
Ok for the food, but Jane was the last person Clementine had.
Jane should have talked to her at least, explain to her the situation.
Leave Clem like this without saying anything, I do not think it's best choice.
When Clem enters in the room and find her... the shock. This scene is hard.
She must feel abandoned, and wondering what to do now she is alone with AJ.
I don't think Jane have to die immediately.
She could have given to Clem an instructions, or she could have tried find a better place for Clem and AJ, or I don't know.
But I think she has the time to do something for them before she kill herself.
I would have wanted she's to tell Clem, but Clem should not see Jane death. As one last goodbye and Jane commits suicide somewhere.
I know this is not a better alternative, for the scenario it would not have been easy to do in a short flashback and it would have been less violent for the players.
But for me I have the feeling that Jane has abandoned Clem.
[removed]
It'll never be forgotten, mortal!
Too late!
Now the entire world knows and will never forget
You mean stubborn, self-sacrificial, and confrontational? Cause he was "retarded" before that, just not as subdued.
That's one of the things that bothers me on a personal level. Especially given what some Clementines had to sacrifice to be with Jane in the first place.
"Woah, what a necksnapper!"
Oh, so depression is a symptom of pregnancy? Because I thought she was probably depressed long before that started affecting her.
I love my Jane. The Jane in season 3 is a fake one. Jane would never kill herself. She was strong and determined to keep my Clem save. This is bullshit writing.
I don't see Jane giving up that fast. Especially how she dragged her sister across 4 states. Even though Jamie wanted to die. Jane would probably eat a little bit more, but they still had months to prepare and weren't she shelves really really full at Howe's ? I mean even the family doesn't have 10 arms each. The motor inn seemed way worse in comparison
Honestly it went by too fast... it went at breakneck speed.
I'm cool with it. I wasn't really expecting anything from Kenny and Jane this season.
I recall her saying they had enough food to last for at least 2 weeks/months not counting the greenhouse.
She did say she wouldn't want to bring a kid in this world. That's why she asked Rebecca what she wanted to with it.