Leave with ****** or stay and fight?
What did you choose at the end of Episode 1? I stayed with Clem and kill those bastards because I'm not leaving Clem and I wanted to murder those bastards for what they did to Mariana. I think it's a better choice because:
- You get to give Mariana a proper burial, she didn't deserve a death like that. I don't think Clem buried her herself if you chose to leave. Also, you won't have a choice to give her the cassette.
- You get to learn about the New Frontier for the first time.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
In my first save file and I stayed and fight and in the other one I stayed with family but I like the staying and fight one the best
Me too.
I went back with my family because I wanted to make sure Kate made it back and Gabriel was practically begging me not to leave them.
We got back to Prescott where I allowed Gabriel to help Javier and Eleanor fix up Kate, which he screws up and storms off in panic.
I hear you still do all that when you go with Clem. Do you?
She just turned up on her own after talking with Tripp, Morgan Freeman and Gabriel.
I don't think so. Eleanor already patched her and I don't think I heard Gabe screwing her wound if you choose to stay with Clem.
Okay that's good. I hope it pays off in Gabriel's personality down the line to stay with them.
I chose to stay and fight for three reasons. One, while it could benefit my family to stay with them and help, I thought it would be more beneficial to provide a sort of cover or distraction while they got away, Eleanor was going to be the one doing most of the work, I didn't think there was much Javier could to in that regard. Two, I was pissed at these guys for killing Mariana, I wanted to get some revenge. Three, like hell I was going to just leave Clementine there on her own to fight these bastards off.
I stood and fought. Seeing Mariana die in front of him, and considering how close he was to her, I can totally see him go in a fit of rage and wanting to kill them all. Clem was severely outnumbered and has helped Javier get to his family. And Kate was in good hands.
And suddenly I realized my comment is similar to @MetallicaRules but screw it lol
Had to stay and avenge Mariana.
I stayed and fight. My Javier was in a really dark place the moment he saw his niece die in front of him. He just wanted to throw himself into a senseless fight because that's the only way he can deal with the pain and grief of losing his beloved niece despite any rational and sensible thought at the time.
Stayed and fought. As much as I don't want Clementine involved in a gun fight, I couldn't leave her behind. Kate would be in the same state whether Javier was there or not.
Great minds think alike.
I was one of the few that stayed with the family. I didn't want to get separated again and wanted to help Kate in any way, which was more important to me than killing a few guys. Plus I knew Clem would make it out alive, because she's Clem. And I gave Mari's cassette to Gabe, so at least there's that.
Later it resulted to a weird scene though, because the New Frontier was pretty sure Javi killed their guys even though I didn't kill anyone. Oh well, it's Telltale.
I stayed with my family. I didn't want Javier to lose what little family he had left.
Leave little girl with armed thugs and go... that's cowardice. And why would I go? I wouldn't help Lindsay.
If you chose to go back with family, then the only person Javier would of killed is the man that was guarding him when the other one went to get the cuffs (the fuel incident) and if you chose to return fire or running to your family once Mariana is shot.
Stay and fought. Even if it wasn't Clementine and I liked Gabe or Kate, I like Tripp. He seems like decent guy, he'd be able to get them back to Eleanor, and staying behind myself would ensure the people shooting had to be a bit more worried about what I was doing instead of what the family was.
I chose to stay and fight but when I started up episode 2 it changed my choice to Javi leaving with his family. Anyone else have this problem?
I actually returned to Prescott with my family. I had to ensure that the remaining members made it home alive. I felt an extra pair of hands for assistance would prove beneficial in the endeavor of returning to the community. I just couldn't leave them, especially considering Kate's dire injuries and Gabe's pleas. They needed my hands and my support.
Fighting back almost felt fruitless. It couldn't bring Mariana back, and who knows what could've happened to Kate or Gabe while I was gone. I felt more than a little guilty for leaving a teenager to fight against so many armed enemies, but my focus was channeled onto my family. Fighting also would've helped eliminate some future threats, but it felt too risky.
That dude died? I just thought I knocked him out.
No one was forcing Clem to stay, she did that out of her own free will.
I'm pretty sure he's dead as the man in truck said about shooting Javier for what he did to their man
Where did I say someone forced her?
Stayed to fight. There was no way I was going to just leave Mariana's body, and I wasn't going to leave Clem behind either. Staying to fight and buying the group some time to escape seemed like the right decision to me, even if the game made you feel the opposite.
I honestly expected a fight scene, so I'm very disappointed that Javier is simply knocked out.
I didn't say you did, I was just making a statement as to why one might decide to go.
I wanted to stay, not for Clem's sake but for Mariana. I wanted to be able to bury her and say goodbye but i had a nephew and a sister in law/love interest who were scared and injured. I'd like to think that Mariana would have wanted me to protect them and leave. Clem had no factor in my decision.
Leave with Family. Obviously Clem wasn't going to die. Also, I got to hear Kate scream. I love it when fictional characters scream in agony.
Staying with Clem is better for Episode 2 intro
First playthrough I stayed with Clem but then I thought it made more sense for Javier to stay with his family and support them.
Burying Mariana and learning about The New Frontier seemed better than just helping Eleanor fix Kate's wound in my opinion.
There are pros and cons with both options which I like but then I noticed the one thing the game constantly pointed out since the start is that Javier was mostly absent such as him not being there when his father died and David acting like a jerk about it, then him talking about wanting a "fresh start" which I immediately thought of the zombie apocalypse being exactly that for him.