Above the Law's determinate Clementine lines
I think a pretty decent amount of people on here are aware that Clementine has different lines after the flashback where she injects AJ and in a few other scenes. Has anyone figured out what causes the change yet? To keep things simple I'll just reference the scene after the inject AJ flashback. She can either say that AJ was the only family she had left, that maybe it was for the best because any place has to be better than the world she lives in now, that's what she gets for trusting people again, or that she survived and he didn't and that's just how it goes sometimes.
From what I've seen on YouTube, most people get the dialogue about trusting people again. I had the stay with Kenny ending and got the line about family. I've seen people on YouTube who have the Kenny ending that got the lines about trusting people again, so I know it's not the s2 endings alone that change what she says. I'm not sure, but I think that some of the choices from s1 and s2 are what effect this. I also know for a fact that whether you use an actual save or use the story generator effect it as well. I picked the same choices I made in my real save in the generator and she mentions trusting people again instead of family.
So, anybody interested in sharing the lines you had in your game, along with the important choices you made in s1 and s2? I had Lee always be nice to Clementine, saved all group members in s1 and s2 except for Lilly, Only killed Duck and the Stranger, Left Lee to turn, always protected AJ, didn't steal from the stranger or Arvo, and wound up with Kenny in the end.
Comments
Honestly without rewind this shit is impossible to find. I appreciate them adding determinate stuff but when they remove rewind it backfires.
I got the trusting people again and I believe that a Clementine who trusted people in season 2 says it. It might also be affected by whether you choose to go with Ava or not.
Hmm, I mostly trusted people in s2 but got the family lines. I don't think s3 choices effect it at all because I have two different saves with opposite choices except I declined Ava both times. She still mentioned family. It's possible albeit unlikey the Ava choice effects it. Regardless, there are four sets of dialouge so there is more to it than that.
I stayed with Kenny but i got the line about trusting people.
I had pretty much lost all faith of choices actually mattering until I played the second Kenny flashback
With the family lines, Clem paraphrases what Kenny says about Sarita in the new flashback. Clem says "Family means something different now, you have to make it for yourself." Whereas Kenny said that Sarita always said "family is what you make it." I think that's pretty cool.
I could be wrong but I think it is determinant for what Lee taught her in season 1 about community, survival and stuff like that. In my season 2 save, my Lee taught her to trust people and stay in groups and in season 3 I got the "that's what I get for trusting other people" line. I might be wrong though but it makes sense, seeing how I've noticed that the Lee's teachings choices are in the story generator.
that makes sense but idk
I think that it's a mix of what Lee taught her and what you make her do in s2. I know for sure that choices that aren't in the generator can effect s3, because Kenny mentioned me killing the zombie that bit Sarita in the new flashback. He also mentioned me holding Aj in s2. Those choices obviously aren't in the generator. I think what effects her is more complex than we realize.
maybe
Really? Kenny didn't mention that to me. He only mentioned me not watching him kill carver.
he told me that he never thanked me for trying to save her (by cutting off the arm)
I didn't watch either, but he didn't mention Carver at all for me. He did tell me that Lee was a good man though, and he should have treated him better. What does Kenny say about not watching him kill Carver?
He said that Lee thing to me as well. He says something like: I'm glad you didn't have to see me to that to carver. And I think I remember him talking about how he was In the heat of the moment and had no control over himself.
I always wondered if he ever felt any remorse about that. I'm glad that I finally heard his justification for it. The way Kenny and Clem act in that flashback was how I wanted this season to be.