What was more impactful? EPISODE 5 SPOILERS

Do you guys think Gabe/David's death was more emotional or was Kate's?

Comments

  • Definitely Gabe's, no question about it. Kate's offscreen death was lazy and David's onscreen death was sad, but not on Gabe level.

    Just watching him slowly die covered in blood while it rains makes it extremely hard to watch. Add Clem and Javi crying and Gabe telling Javi he was a good Father to him, it makes it even harder.

  • edited May 2017

    Very true, although Javi's scream when he shot Kate got to me.

    MRSHYGUY45 posted: »

    Definitely Gabe's, no question about it. Kate's offscreen death was lazy and David's onscreen death was sad, but not on Gabe level. Just

  • Gabe's death had that TWD feeling that I haven't had since Duck and Lee.

    Classic tragedy. It was a lot more meaningful imo.

  • Me too. But seeing Clem cry like when Kenny died got to me much much more.

    Very true, although Javi's scream when he shot Kate got to me.

  • Yeah it did remind me of Duck sitting next to the tree

    xXOldKingXx posted: »

    Gabe's death had that TWD feeling that I haven't had since Duck and Lee. Classic tragedy. It was a lot more meaningful imo.

  • gabe's death was very impactful for a lot of people. ive seen people that hated his guts that said they felt bad and actually cried

  • Reading the comments, I kinda want Gabe to die only to experience this. The last time I caught myself crying was when Kenny said his goodbye to Clem in Wellington ending, I wonder if ANF can make me emotional at all.

  • It's probably because they somehow managed to turn his character around in the span of an episode (seriously HATED his guts when he told Tripp about Conrad, but I did feel sad.)

    gabe's death was very impactful for a lot of people. ive seen people that hated his guts that said they felt bad and actually cried

  • I think that might've been what they were going for, now that I think about it. Either way, it was effective.

    Yeah it did remind me of Duck sitting next to the tree

  • edited May 2017

    Gabe's death was the most impactful obviously. There was an option to shoot him yourself or let him shoot himself. Also, Javi's and Gabe's last goodbyes nearly brought tears into my eyes and I'm sure lots of others too.

    David's death was also very sad, if you get the ending where you find David who just got bit and has blood out pouring out his throat but he's still alive. That one was especially sad compared to the more common ending where you just find him dead in the car.

    As in comparison, Kate died off screen. We only had to put her down since she was a walker. Sure, it was sad and especially sad when you hear Javier cry out in pain, but we didn't have any sort of emotional goodbye speech or something like that with her. It was literally just shooting her down. That's it. Sad as hell, but obviously not just as sad compared to Gabe & David.

    Also, what's even more sad about David's on-screen death is his last words. "Te quiero, Gabriel. Te quiero, Mariana. Te quiero, Javier." Te quiero is Spanish and it just means "I love you". Made my goddamn heart melt.

  • Well, I think that's what happens when the character is not only just a confused kid, but one that actually had quite a bit going on with him despite still being pretty tame.

    gabe's death was very impactful for a lot of people. ive seen people that hated his guts that said they felt bad and actually cried

  • How do you get to see David onscreen death.

    MRSHYGUY45 posted: »

    Definitely Gabe's, no question about it. Kate's offscreen death was lazy and David's onscreen death was sad, but not on Gabe level. Just

  • Gabe's. I haven't actually seen anything implying a death scene for David, though I doubt it'll leave much of an impact with me personally.

    Kate's is just short of being a total case of "Wtf?".

  • edited May 2017

    Choose Save David & Gabe instead of Save Richmond...

    I think Clem can't go with you though.

    BigGazMan posted: »

    How do you get to see David onscreen death.

  • Wow, I had no idea David had an on-screen death scene! Those last words sound heartbreaking too.

    Findagon posted: »

    Gabe's death was the most impactful obviously. There was an option to shoot him yourself or let him shoot himself. Also, Javi's and Gabe's l

  • DeltinoDeltino Moderator

    Honestly, I think my favorite one was the one where you find David already dead, and bury his dog tags. It's sad, but at the same time, there's some level of heartwarming to it as well; even if David died, he got the kind of death he wanted-- a soldier's death.

  • Thanks pal

    MRSHYGUY45 posted: »

    Choose Save David & Gabe instead of Save Richmond... I think Clem can't go with you though.

  • Also in the same death when Kate leaves her ring on the grave I thought was a nice moment.

    Deltino posted: »

    Honestly, I think my favorite one was the one where you find David already dead, and bury his dog tags. It's sad, but at the same time, ther

  • Yeah, I definitely prefer that one as well.

    Deltino posted: »

    Honestly, I think my favorite one was the one where you find David already dead, and bury his dog tags. It's sad, but at the same time, ther

  • edited May 2017

    Do you guys think Gabe/David's death was more emotional or was Kate's?

    I feel like Clementine's new hairdo might cause some emotions.

    cough cough seizures.
  • Gabe's death hit me straight in the heart. I felt nothing for David and Kate.

  • it really did

    TheMPerson posted: »

    Do you guys think Gabe/David's death was more emotional or was Kate's? I feel like Clementine's new hairdo might cause some emotions. cough cough seizures.

  • clem died

    TheMPerson posted: »

    Do you guys think Gabe/David's death was more emotional or was Kate's? I feel like Clementine's new hairdo might cause some emotions. cough cough seizures.

  • but HER STORY WILL CONTINUE IF YOU BUY OUR NEW SEASON "CLEM ADVENTURE PASS"

    clem died

  • i'm kinda upset that they had to kill him after he 180'd though. he still had a lot of potential. like my favorite moment of him is when he puts down his father and doesnt even cry. damn he deserved better

    It's probably because they somehow managed to turn his character around in the span of an episode (seriously HATED his guts when he told Tripp about Conrad, but I did feel sad.)

  • felt more like lee honestly

    DabigRG posted: »

    I think that might've been what they were going for, now that I think about it. Either way, it was effective.

  • does somebody have the david on screen death video?

  • Well he is determinant so hopefully he gets some more moments in season 4/dlc (can't believe I'm actually wanting more Gabe, gg telltale)

    i'm kinda upset that they had to kill him after he 180'd though. he still had a lot of potential. like my favorite moment of him is when he puts down his father and doesnt even cry. damn he deserved better

  • but the cheapest part of all of this is that javi is the only nondeterminant survivor and he might not even appear in the next installment. like if they just made gabe/kate live with javi and then have them all leave richmond together so that they could actually find him, it would be much more impactful. or, they couldve not had the garcia family at all and had a clem based season

    but HER STORY WILL CONTINUE IF YOU BUY OUR NEW SEASON "CLEM ADVENTURE PASS"

  • Although if he does appear in a further installment it would be a blessing in disguise for him to be the only one. I mean look at this season, a whole gaggle of side characters with almost none of the relationships fleshed out. Clem with Javi as a sidekick would simplify it all and give us more development. I'd take it over the tangled mess we got this season.

    but the cheapest part of all of this is that javi is the only nondeterminant survivor and he might not even appear in the next installment.

  • GABE NOOOOO!! DON'T DIE I LIKED U SINCE THE BEGINING EVEN IF YOU WERE A LITTLE SHIT (just like me tbh) WHY DID YOU HAVE TO GIVE ME THE LEE FEELS GODDAMMIT GABE

  • mkiceandfire's alternate choices

    does somebody have the david on screen death video?

Sign in to comment in this discussion.