The real Clem would never like Gabe

A crybaby like him!? are you serious? Clem would find him annoying. This writing is not true to Clem's character.

«134

Comments

  • ANF's writing is not true to the series.

  • edited July 2017

    enter image description here
    enter image description here
    enter image description here
    enter image description here

    Chyeah, she totally wouldn't care about anyone with emotional problems or fatal flaws.

  • Hell sure the writing is bad in this season
    the last time i checked clem didn not want to be close to any person cause she don't want to lose more.
    And I looked to gabe looking for any thing that may make clem love him his not a handsome I can tell his face is one of the most ugliest faces in this season so far, and he had a Terrible personality for sure so there is nothing you can love about him
    Last time I checked clem see the love or kissing stuff as a gross shit

    Thats not the clem I know for sure that the clem only the writers of this season want to force me to know.

  • At least he can dies

  • There's a difference between "Javentine" Love and Love that makes you trust someone to the end of the earth. Javentine has nothing to do with this game or discussion.

    FORTLEE posted: »

    Hell sure the writing is bad in this season the last time i checked clem didn not want to be close to any person cause she don't want to l

  • Javintine?
    what are you talking about.

    There's a difference between "Javentine" Love and Love that makes you trust someone to the end of the earth. Javentine has nothing to do with this game or discussion.

  • MrJavaMrJava Banned

    Definitely true. Clem is a smart girl and has been going through some shit and I just cant find a good explanation about how she can fall in love with someone so dumb ?

  • Yeah, I think this is true for a Clem that went with Jane, she learned that most of the time people became a liability and can basically put anyone else in danger. She also learned that relationship in the apocalypse can be super painful if one of them dies and look where that aftermath went i.e Kenny,Christa,etc. The part which doesn't make a whole lot of sense is that going with Jane in s2 makes Clem kiss Gabe like wtf did some telltale staff fucked it up and it wasn't supposed to be for Jane's ending!? I'd imagine it would be the alone ending since literally Clem was alone and all that alone time made you do that stuff.

  • Why do people care so much about this? Geez, talk about something else.

    There is no "real Clem" anymore, anyway. That's the risk you take with making an established NPC character playable in the first place.

  • This^ It's getting really annoying

    DabigRG posted: »

    Why do people care so much about this? Geez, talk about something else. There is no "real Clem" anymore, anyway. That's the risk you take with making an established NPC character playable in the first place.

  • Okay. That was a missread. My bad.

    FORTLEE posted: »

    Javintine? what are you talking about.

  • What is true to Clementine's character then? Heck, my Lee and Clementine have always been moral, never killed unless they had to and were nice to everyone, even strangers. I know that hardly anything in ANF doesn't reflects my Clementine.

  • Everything is badly-written in A New Frontier.

  • edited July 2017

    Yes, being in love and caring about someone are the same./s

    I could see her trying to help gabe, like she did sarah, but falling in love? No.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Chyeah, she totally wouldn't care about anyone with emotional problems or fatal flaws.

  • She totally wouldn't care about anyone with emotional problems or fatal flaws

    Maybe S1 Clem (and I'd argue not even that Clem wouldn't be a good fit for Gabe), but S2 Clem could be pretty callous at times.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Chyeah, she totally wouldn't care about anyone with emotional problems or fatal flaws.

  • Here's an easy choice for you. Don't Click The Thread

    This^ It's getting really annoying

  • And that's part of why I wasn't a fan of that whole "Edgy!Clem" thing.

    Cocoa2736 posted: »

    She totally wouldn't care about anyone with emotional problems or fatal flaws Maybe S1 Clem (and I'd argue not even that Clem wouldn't be a good fit for Gabe), but S2 Clem could be pretty callous at times.

  • but falling in love? No.

    It definitely shouldn't have been that way on his end either.

    Jimayo posted: »

    Yes, being in love and caring about someone are the same./s I could see her trying to help gabe, like she did sarah, but falling in love? No.

  • well from a certain perspective, this thread's topic can be subjective depending on what your clementine was like. i think my clem would've liked gabe and saw he was actually trying to help and contribute, unlike sarah who was hopeless and useless.

  • Lemme tell you all what is happening here.

    I'll preface it by saying that THIS ISN'T YOUR FAULT. "You" as in, "The fans who didn't like Clementine's characterization". This always happens when fans go without content for a while.

    Your headcanon doesn't match canon.

    Yes, that's it. And that doesn't make canon "wrong". That doesn't mean Clementine acted "out of character". Your vision of her character didn't match the writers' vision. This happens A LOT, and it happens more often the longer people go without content and the bigger are the gaps in canon the fans end up filling with their own canon.

    The exact same thing happened in the Overwatch fandom when the lead writter started to sneak in hints of a relationship between two characters that people shipped with other characters (the writer was writing Genji and Mercy, while a very vocal part of the fandom ships Mercy with Pharah and Genji with Zenyatta). People said awful things, they trashed the characters, they trashed the writer, they went as far as to accuse the writer of making Genji into a self-insert, all because their headcanon didn't match canon.

    The Steven Universe fandom went through the same thing recently, too. Two characters called Lapis Lazuli and Peridot were living together and a writer expressed a liking for their "old married couple" dynamic. People who shipped these characters with other characters were so unbelievable mad and said so many awful things, it was absolutely ridiculous. Again, because their headcanon didn't match canon.

    What I am saying is, sometimes we are wrong about characters, especially when we don't have enough information about how they would act in a certain situation, or about who they would feel attracted to and why. And there is a very believable, very real reason for Clem to fall for Gabe: There is no one else around their age. Yes, that can very well be enough, especially when you are a teenager full of hormones.

  • edited July 2017

    doesn't change the fact that there are too many 10 year olds jealous that Gabe got to kiss Clem and they don't.

    enter image description here

    The Gabe hate is getting old now and most of the arguments are stupid.

  • clem already has one baby to deal with

  • Dude, the hate's been old since Part 2--I just think the constant talk about him and Gaybentime in particular gets obnoxious. I mean, I like Gabe, but at the same time, let's talk about something else--he's like the new Kenny in that regard.

  • Yes, he's serious.

    AronDracula posted: »

    doesn't change the fact that there are too many 10 year olds jealous that Gabe got to kiss Clem and they don't. The Gabe hate is getting old now and most of the arguments are stupid.

  • MrJavaMrJava Banned

    Good one :D

    cleminist posted: »

    clem already has one baby to deal with

  • It's kind of hard to, when literally the same thing is being said constant, over and over.

    We get it, you don't like Clem kissing Gabe and besides it's determinate, it's not even that big of a deal.

    AronDracula posted: »

    Here's an easy choice for you. Don't Click The Thread

  • actually, a lot of your gabe arguments truly are fucking stupid. not to mention you're still so butthurt about him and he is pretty much all you talk about at this point. get over it.

    AronDracula posted: »

    doesn't change the fact that there are too many 10 year olds jealous that Gabe got to kiss Clem and they don't. The Gabe hate is getting old now and most of the arguments are stupid.

  • Exactly.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Chyeah, she totally wouldn't care about anyone with emotional problems or fatal flaws.

  • And there are some you cannot justify like Gabe throwing his uncle under the bus, unnecesarily taking on a New Frontier guard, going with his father despite what he said about him in Episode 5 etc.

    actually, a lot of your gabe arguments truly are fucking stupid. not to mention you're still so butthurt about him and he is pretty much all you talk about at this point. get over it.

  • Well, you can justify that last one, but does it really matter?

    AronDracula posted: »

    And there are some you cannot justify like Gabe throwing his uncle under the bus, unnecesarily taking on a New Frontier guard, going with his father despite what he said about him in Episode 5 etc.

  • You know in the zombie apocalypse, you kinda take what you can get not a lot of options for Clem or Gabe, finding other kids your age is rare guys.

  • I.Never.Made.A.Thread.About.His.Bullshit.

  • i seriously wonder how many times you've brought all of those things up. i could justify two of those.

    AronDracula posted: »

    And there are some you cannot justify like Gabe throwing his uncle under the bus, unnecesarily taking on a New Frontier guard, going with his father despite what he said about him in Episode 5 etc.

  • Honestly I agree. I miss S1 Clementine :/

    DabigRG posted: »

    And that's part of why I wasn't a fan of that whole "Edgy!Clem" thing.

  • edited July 2017

    It didn't have to feel so shallow, whishy washy, and generic though.

    Abeille posted: »

    Lemme tell you all what is happening here. I'll preface it by saying that THIS ISN'T YOUR FAULT. "You" as in, "The fans who didn't like C

  • edited July 2017

    Omg Gabe's a crybaby? lmao he don't even cry when his dad dies. Clementine literally spends the whole of s3 whining and complaining, Gabes an annoying shithead but nowhere near as bad as her, seriously why is she seen as badass shes such an annoying little bitch

  • Yeah herself

    cleminist posted: »

    clem already has one baby to deal with

  • We agree on that

    AronDracula posted: »

    Everything is badly-written in A New Frontier.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.