TWD Michonne vs ANF
Considered the two worst TWD games,
Which one do you think is better in terms of quality? Characters, storyline, writing, etc...
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Considered the two worst TWD games,
Which one do you think is better in terms of quality? Characters, storyline, writing, etc...
Comments
I’d say The Walking Dead Michonne is better, The character models were better, it had a unique menu, had its own intro. The Story was decent too.
Michonne was better cause there was no hanging or windshield flying in it
Michonne had season two animations style still. But I think the story and action was far better there than in A New Frontier. Don't see how anyone can possibly think any other walking dead game other than survival instinct is below or on par with New Frontier.
Both are really bad, however Id say Michonne was better but not really for the story and characters...
Michonne was a mini-series, so it fell flat and didnt work. It was annoying that it was pretty trash at the end, but because it was a mini-series that didnt effect the mainline of games it didnt leave a super bad taste in my mouth. Sadly, after playing Michonne I was worried Season 3 would go in a similar direction and well...
ANF is "season 3" it had a ton of hype and was apparently in development for 2 1/2 years (although this is an obvious lie) but it still fell short and was just terrible. It basically took everything I feared would happen to season 3 after playing Michonne and put it to the max. Its funny, you can actually see similar mistakes in Michonne and ANF. Both have parts the player has no connection to, Michonne's kids and Javi's family. Both use cheap bullet in the back of the head shock vaule, characters who are worthless and die with us to be expected to care( anyone remember Buerto? My man said "excuse me" or something once in this whole god damn game and then he dies and we are suppose to care?")
Although both were trash, Michonne I think just beat ANF simply because there was only one thing in the story that made 0 sense and because it failing didnt hurt the main series. Michonne's only real problem is if Randal is alive and you do the deal they just make Randal start to strangle Michonne (with all 10 broken fingers and all) just so we kill him and have to fight. It was dumb. ANF on the other hand is just filled with idiotic situations and characters whos motivations change 24/7. "Hi Im Kate and I need to fucking LEAVE RICHMOND RIGHT FUCKING NOW!" "Hey Im David we never leaving Richmond." "Hi Im Kate im NEVER leaving Richmond" "holy shit its me DAVID and we are LEAVING Richmond!' Its filled with worthless characters who die and we dont care about them, we have to follow some new character and barely see Clem, and I can go on and on, I think we all know everyones main problems with ANF. So I would say ANF is worst than Michonne, especially considering all the lies surrounding ANF, it definitely helps taint everything about it.
Michonne was really good for the people who read the comics.ANF had good ideas,but killing Kenny and Jane was a huge mistake,and Clem should have been the protagonist like in season 2.
Michonne. While ANF had more characters(despite the minimalist main cast) with more time and effort put into doing things with them, Michonne had a better grip on itself for the most part and did what it set out to do.
And this is coming from someone who hasn't played Michonne and both likes and remembers more characters from ANF. (I think.)