›

What was your decision in Episode 3 for Lilly's killing Carley/Doug?

Joshua1991Joshua1991
in The Walking Dead

Did you leave her on the side of the road like Walker Bait or did you bring her back into the group? Every save of mine has my Lee bringing her back into the group on probation. I feel like if we had left her on the side of the road we'd be hypocrites.

I mean we did help kill her father. We would be no better. Lilly only did what she thought was best for the group. Plus we already lost Larry, Mark, Carley/Doug. We couldn't afford to lose anymore members.

Comments

  • Divided_We_FallDivided_We_Fall

    Left her. I don't consider leaving her on the side of the road a sentence to death, she can survive that, but she has no place in the group anymore.

  • prink34320prink34320

    I kept her with the group, what Lilly did was uncalled for but I cant blame her for the state she was in, she overexerted herself for the group and lost her father having practically no one left for moral support. I kept Kenny with me despite him leaving Lee to die and killing Larry and Im not going to treat Lilly any differently.

  • enzeruanimefanenzeruanimefan

    I keep Lilly around unless I feel like either seeing how the choice will affect a current game's playthrough or just to see the scene differences... but probably moreso because she's one of my favorites than out of fairness (and it does seem more fair to keep her around).

  • cutupuss-cutupuss- Banned

    Well if you saved doug she tries to kill ben, and would actually be right, besides ya'll kenny lovers can't claim you loved ben when he tried to attack him multiple times

  • ChusetsChusets

    I left her. She could not keep it together and had someone killed because of that, there was no excuse for what she did.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.