Can we actually Kill Ben?

Listen to me good, Persuasion mode ON, Can we really keep this up?

Like we always say we'd kill Larry when we get the chance
but instead the majority of us chose to try and rescue him.

And with Duck, we talked about how annoying he was, but in the end it was pretty sad to kill him, i'm actually not sure of this one because some people might have wanted to shoot him or not.

Now we've got this "Kill Ben" thread up because of Carley's death, when Lilly killed her in the first place, we all know it's all for Carley, but think reality, Carley got mad that Lilly wanted to throw Ben off the RV or even kill him, would Carley want you to Avenge her death by Killing Ben, the kid she tried to protect, or would you rather have her death be in vein and kill off Ben anyways?

It's our choice guys, Telltale Listens to us, I know it's a game, but some or most of you pretend like Carley's the only human being here, and not the other characters, I just wanted to let you guys know, before we make another regret.

Comments

  • edited September 2012
    I don't think Telltale killed off Duck because anyone found him annoying. I do think they made Duck a little annoying so you felt that much worse when he died.

    If I were going to go gunning for anyone, it'd be Lilly; put her down like a rabid dog.
  • edited September 2012
    Cyreen wrote: »
    I don't think Telltale killed off Duck because anyone found him annoying. I do think they made Duck a little annoying so you felt that much worse when he died.

    If I were going to go gunning for anyone, it'd be Lilly; put her down like a rabid dog.

    Oh, well at the time I was writing this, I guess it was just a coincidence, I didn't consider that at the moment, but thanks for saying that.
  • edited September 2012
    Meh, I say let him stay around and use him for walker bait. Send him into the blindspots first at gunpoint.
  • edited September 2012
    I wanted to push him off the train as soon as he said it was him. I killed Larry, I think I took a nano second to shoot duck when given the chance and I left Lilly behind without a second thought. If the option comes to kill him I'll take it without hesitation...
  • edited September 2012
    Thraxas wrote: »
    I wanted to push him off the train as soon as he said it was him. I killed Larry, I think I took a nano second to shoot duck when given the chance and I left Lilly behind without a second thought. If the option comes to kill him I'll take it without hesitation...

    Renegade... lol
  • edited September 2012
    Not happy with Ben at the moment, but I would never kill him.
  • edited September 2012
    Kill him. I thought that i could at the train, but turns out i didnt have a choice to do that.

    I never wanted Larry or Duck to die, so yea, not everyone wanted them dead. I doubt TTG listened to fans and killed them off
  • edited September 2012
    I will kill him or use as a walker bait .I was a bit disapointed that i couldn't push him off the train.
  • edited September 2012
    Why go after the small fry? I don't even care what will happen to Ben anymore. All I want is Lilly's life.
  • edited September 2012
    He is a coward and has destroyed the group. If he just told that he was the one who took the supplies, Carley & Lilly would still be on the group. Don't know about Katjaa, but Duck would've died anyway.
  • edited September 2012
    yea he ruined everything but those bandits weren't going to to stay out forever, we have lost enough people because of this, him having to live knowing what he did is enough punishment
  • edited September 2012
    He's a coward, He can't prove to any use to the group. I say feed him to Clementine.
    :CannibalLaugh:
    No really, Kill him off already. But the stupid guys like him always survive, So...
  • edited September 2012
    just wanted to throw out that Carley didn't know Ben was the traitor.
  • edited September 2012
    ttg should at least change the mo for hated characters..

    make ben pay by having him suffer in slow painfull agony..by letting him live..

    anything else is too easy..
  • edited September 2012
    At first I was all for killing Ben due to Carley's death. But then I thought about the fact that Lilly killed Carley because of Carley sticking up for Ben and saying things like she was a bitch that should take a page out of Lee's book etc. By killing Ben, Carley's death is in vain. She was trying to protect a scared teenager and if we kill that scared teenager then what did Carley die for?
  • edited September 2012
    United 23 wrote: »
    At first I was all for killing Ben due to Carley's death. But then I thought about the fact that Lilly killed Carley because of Carley sticking up for Ben and saying things like she was a bitch that should take a page out of Lee's book etc. By killing Ben, Carley's death is in vain. She was trying to protect a scared teenager and if we kill that scared teenager then what did Carley die for?

    F' you, but god damn, you're right..I'll still kill him once or twice and then replay, though.
  • edited September 2012
    Carley died so he could live, it'd be insulting to murder him yourself. I don't like him but I'm trying to save as many people as I can in my main play.
  • edited September 2012
    I actually wanted to kill him on the train when he confessed but since changed my mind. However, I won't be able to forgive him and his stupidity.
  • edited September 2012
    I will tear out his intestines!!!

    after Carley died my Lee doesn't give a shit about anyone now except for Clem . Screw everyone else!
  • edited September 2012
    IMO , If Ben tells Kenny or Kenny finds out via Lee , Ben's getting murdered by Kenny
  • edited September 2012
    Freeze wrote: »
    IMO , If Ben tells Kenny or Kenny finds out via Lee , Ben's getting murdered by Kenny


    I will gladly help Kenny to rip his head off :D
  • edited September 2012
    Definitely.

    He'll rage the poor kid into a bloody pulp.
  • edited September 2012
    It's not about the sidekick character he got killed off, its the fact that he cant be trusted.
    Weak link, if allowed I would have tossed him off the train after his admission.
  • edited September 2012
    He was doing the wrong thing for the right reasons, and as much as it pissed me off that everything, in the end, was caused by that, I can't kill him. I still like him, and it's more interesting to have him around then not to.
  • edited September 2012
    I was so pissed when he told me that he gave the meds to the bandits. I thought of him as the weird son that I never really wanted but I didn't mind having him around. All I have left is Clem and maybe Chuck. Lee is a jerk who can't be trusted and the other 2 i don't really care for.
  • edited September 2012
    Lee is a jerk who can't be trusted and the other 2 i don't really care for.
    if Lee is the jerk then who have you been playing as? :confused:
  • edited September 2012
    mukhlisz wrote: »
    if Lee is the jerk then who have you been playing as? :confused:

    Larry.
  • edited September 2012
    Larry.

    How did Lily take it, seeing her old man up and about?
    She must have been like 'I TOLD YOU!' at the beginning of Ep 3
  • edited September 2012
    Xarne wrote: »
    How did Lily take it, seeing her old man up and about?
    She must have been like 'I TOLD YOU!' at the beginning of Ep 3

    The lack of a head made her a bit uneasy, but after she figured out how to translate my gurgling noises, everything went smoothly. As in I beat Kenny's ass for trying to kill me.
  • edited September 2012
    The lack of a head made her a bit uneasy, but after she figured out how to translate my gurgling noises, everything went smoothly. As in I beat Kenny's ass for trying to kill me.

    Well its good to see a little headache didnt keep you down. A little toss of salt over the shoulder for good luck and all that
  • edited September 2012
    Telltale is going to give him plot armour just to piss us off.
  • edited September 2012
    Telltale is going to give him plot armour just to piss us off.

    I dont know man, usually, once the bloodlust is high enough around here that char gets the axe...and this guy killed of everyone's e-girlfriend haha. TTG might have to develop a uniquely gruesome death for Ben or face riots on the forums
  • edited September 2012
    No such thing as plot armor in this game, Clem and Lee only being exemptions to the rule for obvious reasons
This discussion has been closed.