›

Kill one, save two.

MauglyMaugly
edited September 2012 in The Walking Dead
Interesting thought crossed my mind. Carley and Clementine appears to be crowd favourite. So, if there were a situation, where you have to decide who of three (Carley, Clementine, Lee) dies to save other two, whom would you chose?
I know there's already a poll about Lee vs Clem, but I believe I put a question little bit differently here.

Comments

  • StrawberryRainPopStrawberryRainPop
    edited September 2012
    wow...i dont know. Depends on how much clem has lied to me. But i go with Carley. Thats the only person i fully trusted
  • ForgottenKnightForgottenKnight
    edited September 2012
    StrawberryRainPop wrote: »
    wow...i dont know. Depends on how much clem has lied to me.

    You would kill Clem if she lied to you a lot? She's just a kid D:

    By the way, is that Dodger in your avatar?
  • ZombieGoBoomZombieGoBoom
    edited September 2012
    Women and children first.
  • StrawberryRainPopStrawberryRainPop
    edited September 2012
    ForgottenKnight wrote: »
    You would kill Clem if she lied to you a lot? She's just a kid D:

    By the way, is that Dodger in your avatar?

    oh nonono it depends on HOW MUCH clem has been lying to me. And personall,y Carley is the only one i trust.


    And yes, that is the lovely Brooke in my Avatar :p
  • MauglyMaugly
    edited September 2012
    I am actually upset to see how people are so biased toward children :(
  • YamiRazielYamiRaziel
    edited September 2012
    I couldn't care less about Carley.
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited September 2012
    aren't these choices MOOT ?

    carley is dead already, clem and lee won't die till ep5 final act

    and yes we have ducks death but MOST people love clem and lee is the player so has plot armor till the end of the game..
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited September 2012
    Lee seems the heroic sacrifice type....
  • StrawberryRainPopStrawberryRainPop
    edited September 2012
    DreadMagus wrote: »
    Lee seems the heroic sacrifice type....

    your avatar....

    I APPROVEEEEE:)
  • RafaelBrasileiroRafaelBrasileiro
    edited September 2012
    Carley is my favorite character Several reasons Why then did not want her to die, Clem is a child I'm caring, is one of my favorite characters too, I'm Lee in the game!
    Suicide is not a simple thing!
    Killing a child is not either!
    And I would never kill Carley!
    I Do not Know What to choose!
  • sloughslough
    edited September 2012
    YamiRaziel wrote: »
    I couldn't care less about Carley.

    ^That. But even if one of my other favorites, like Kenny, got in the way between Clem and Lee? Even if it was an earlier episode? ...Yeah. I am not gonna watch one of my favorite child/adult relationships in recent memory disintegrate before my eyes when I have a choice about it.
  • Gratefully DeadGratefully Dead
    edited September 2012
    Carley is already gone. Easiest question I've answered. xD

    I'd still pick her anyway though. Lee dies, we don't play anymore. Clem dies? We lose the biggest narrative spark for the game... Carley dies? People whine but the game goes on!
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited September 2012
    StrawberryRainPop wrote: »
    your avatar....

    I APPROVEEEEE:)

    Thanks :)
  • MurasakiMurasaki
    edited September 2012
    Ouch! Selfishly and perhaps in the heat of the moment, I would instinctively chose Carley/Lee and sacrifice Clem. However, despite the amount of potential between those two, I doubt I'd feel very comfortable, and Lee even less so. Carley would probably scorn Lee too for not doing more to save her.

    Nah, it has to be Carley/Clem, sacrifice Lee.
  • Trickybuz93Trickybuz93
    edited September 2012
    Sorry Clem, but with Carley, we could always make more of you ;)
  • XarneXarne
    edited September 2012
    ZombieGoBoom wrote: »
    Women and children first.

    to die or...
  • NessaTNessaT
    edited September 2012
    Without Lee, there's no story. :( And I can't let go of Clem... so... sorry Carly.

    But Lee has Christa now. :D
  • XarneXarne
    edited September 2012
    Hi, have you met my friend Omid?
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited September 2012
    Xarne wrote: »
    Hi, have you met my friend Omid?

    you mean the "lost all capacity to be funny since injury and not really funny from the start expendable comedy sidekick" Omid
  • Wilder41Wilder41
    edited September 2012
    Simple for me. Sacrifice Lee, I'd gladly continue on as Clem or Carly.
This discussion has been closed.