Lilly and Clementine enemies ?
Let's say that Lilly and Clem return in season 2 do you guys think that their reunion would be hugs and kisses because i can't see that happening i can imagine Clem always pointing the gun at her and telling her that if she harms one of her new friends she is going to die by her hands and pay for what she has done . If they both appear in season 2 will they be friends or enemies ?
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
I read somewhere that Clem says Lilly must be punished if Lee talks to her at the train, but i haven't tried that yet(never took Lilly with me) so I'm not sure. If it's true though... i don't think Clem would forgive her, at least initially.
I don't think Clementine would want Lilly near her. She wouldn't kill her but she'd avoid her, probably.
It would also depend on the type of Lee that took care of her. Was your Lee a pragmatic ass who never shied away from being blunt and abrasive? Clem will probably hold a major grudge, if not outright threaten Lilly. Was your Lee compassionate and one to cling to humanity even if it would get people killed? Clem would probably give Lilly a second chance.
I think that if Lee was there and things hadn't turned out so bad, Clementine and Lilly could have worked it out. Now... I think Clementine has lost much of her innocence and naivety, and her trust of others(especially a traitor...), should be very low. I think it wouldn't be a grand reunion, and they'd either split or their bonds simply wouldn't be repaired. Clem may be young, but she isn't stupid, and she has had to adapt to survive. She was alone at the start of the apocalypse, and she was alone when the season ended. She has to think on her own what is a good idea and what is not. I have to say don't expect a handshake between the two or anything close to it.
I remember at the train that Clem asked Lee about Lilly. Maybe the response the player chose will be carried over to season 2 and affect how Clem reacts to Lilly. If you talk to Clem before going to the RV to get the pencil I think that's when Clem asks Lee his opinion of Lilly.
Anyways, I think both need to appear in season 2 in order to carry our choices over to the next season.
Clem is still innocent and she would not like Lilly afer what she's done but if there is someone capable of forgiving her it is Clem
Whether she is hateful (perhaps even to the extent of shooting) or more forgiving is something that would be a great thing to have be based on Lee's example as role model.
The same thing can be said for the Stranger, she thought he was a nice guy that wanted to help but then he showed his true colors, Do you see Clem forgiving him after seeing how much of a monster he really is? same goes for Lilly.
From what we've seen, Clem will only kill if someone she cares about is in danger as we saw what she does when the Stranger was strangling Lee. I can see her making a threat to Lilly.
Lilly is broken in a different way and Clementine will probably forgive her as she has lost so many friends and allies and she would not kill for vengeance
She trusted the Stranger enough to tell him everything over the walkie-talkies, she thought he was someone trying to help, she saw Lilly the same way, as someone trying to help but then she goes and guns down a fellow survivor which Clem realized she wasn't a good person she believed she was just as she realized The Stranger wasn't a good person when he kidnapped her.
If you hadn't noticed, The Stranger is also a broken man that lost his family just like Lilly's a broken woman that lost her father but Clem would see Lilly as the bigger monster because the Stranger didn't know the people he was trying to kill but Lilly did know the person she killed and though Clementine did lose a lot of friends, don't forget that she lost one of those friends to Lilly. The one thing I do agree is that Clem would not kill for vengeance but she would kill if someone she cares about is in danger of being murdered, if there was a choice between letting Lilly kill someone she cares about or killing Lilly, I'm sure she'll make the same decision she did with the Stranger.
Of course Clem would do what is necessary if there was no other choice however Lilly isn't that type of killer...
Lilly either killed someone she thought was a traitor or Accidentally shot an innocent man when shooting at the traitor...
Either way Lilly isn't likely to be that kind of risk again if she ever turned up again...
Either way she isn't going to go around shooting just anyone...
Just as Kenny isn't going to start throwing salt Licks at anyone who coughs...
I've made my stance on Kenny clear but I did everything I could to help him despite difference of opinion as long as they aren't an actual threat there is no need to hold grudges that will only lead to more death and suffering...
What type of killer is she then? Bandits & the St Johns do it for food and The Stranger did it for revenge but Lilly did it for the heck of it.
Lilly didn't only kill Carley for being a "traitor" but she mostly killed her because Carley refused to be harassed by her. The thought that she can go off if someone calls her a bitch says a lot about her.
There's no way Clem would trust her after the hell she put the group through.
If killing someone without any proof is the way things need to be done then how is she not a danger to others as you seem to be convinced she's not?
Carley begs to differ.
You are a little bit obsessed with Lilly aren't you?