Larry's just a grumpy old man.
Vernon was okay(if you were good to him) until he stole the boat.
Winston and Andy were just trying to survive.(Though Andy is still fucking weird)
Carver's group was mostly a bunch of dickheads though.
Larry and Vernon aren't evil people. They just had an attitude.
Winston,Troy, and Tavia were bad people.
If I had to choose an evil person it would be Andy St. John. For God's sake he ate people.
Larry's just a grumpy old man.
Vernon was okay(if you were good to him) until he stole the boat.
Winston and Andy were just trying to survive.(Though Andy is still fucking weird)
Carver's group was mostly a bunch of dickheads though.
Larry and Vernon aren't evil people. They just had an attitude.
Winston,Troy, and Tavia were bad people.
If I had to choose an evil person it would be Andy St. John. For God's sake he ate people.
Vernon and Larry had their reasons if you think about it (despite them being assholes) Troy was just a dick (and he got his own shot off, lol)'don't know about Winston didn't get to know him,(Jesus are you fucking kidding me?!) Andy St.John was a messed up cannibal, (We go after people who were gonna die anyway!) And I don't know about tavia yet, we'll see
Andy was just a cannibal, I don't think being a cannibal makes one evil. Though, he did unnecessarily kill Mark, but other than that I don't see a reason why he is being considered evil, Troy on the other hand, he isn't evil, just a dick.
Andy was just a cannibal, I don't think being a cannibal makes one evil. Though, he did unnecessarily kill Mark, but other than that I don't see a reason why he is being considered evil, Troy on the other hand, he isn't evil, just a dick.
most of these are victims of circumstance except for the St Johns, they were evil down to thwe goddamned core, and Larry might have been one annoying old fart but he was in it to protect his daughter something we all can understand. Tavia and winston too perhaps were like soldiers caught on the wrong side of the "war".
I don't think any of the people you mentioned are evil, but they are certainly bad people who made bad choices (except for Larry who was just an asshole and a thorn in the side).
You didn't mention Carver, who I believe is evil and a psychopath.
You listed Larry as a possible candidate. Your opinion is automatically invalid to me.
Lol but in all seriousness, my opinions are as followed:
Troy - Is not evil. He was overtly violent, but he didn't go out of his way to be sadistic (noticed when Carver is beating Kenny, even Troy looks disturbed). He just followed whatever Carver told him to do, an average lackey. He was an asshole though.
Larry - Is not evil. He had... good intentions? He just had a horrible way of acting on them, and was just too untrusting to give Lee a chance to prove that he was not the terrible person Larry thought he was (seeing as all Larry knew about Lee was that he murdered a senator, not the best first impression). His mindset was to protect Lilly above all else.
Vernon - Is not evil. He was looking out for his group. If you look at it rationally from his point of view, who's going to have a better chance of making it out of a horde infested city? A group of fit healthy adults, or a group of old men? In Vernon's view the boat theft was justified, and while this doesn't make him a good person or discredit his actions, this also doesn't make him evil.
Winston - N/a. Didn't get to see too much of Winston, besides his signature line and him struggling to beat a child in terms of strength. I'd like to give him the benefit of doubt and just not answer for him, though his willingness to kill a child speaks for itself.
Tavia - Is not evil. Nothing she said in 400 Days was ever a lie, their group did want more people and all you needed to do was work. She just forgot to mention the psychopathic leader that is Carver. We also didn't get to see her too much this episode and what her opinion of Carver as a leader is, but seeing as she seems to be trusted and high up on the ladder she must agree with Carver's methods. This doesn't warrant her as evil, she's more of a bystander, though being a bystander isn't much better.
Carver - Is evil. While left more ambiguous in Ep 2, it seemed throughout Ep 3 all of Carver's appearances were meant just to make us hate him more/show us he's a violent psychopath. Murder for the heck of it, his determination to drag back this group just to force them to complete menial labour (and the baby but whatever), I feel like this is pretty self explanatory.
Personally I enjoyed it in Ep 2 when they left it more ambiguous on who was the bad guy, Carver or the Cabin group, but whatever.
Edit: Wow I don't know how I read Andy St. John as Carver, but here I go.
Andy - Is evil. What crossed the line for me was when they had a clear chance to let Lee's group go, but decided to keep them. Even without this, tricking passerby's into coming to your farm and slaughtering them for meat is sick.
Comments
Troy ,Tavia ,Winston they are bad people but not evil
Maybe Andy ST. John is the closest one to being evil but im not shure he is
I didnt see Larry there sorry, he is ok XD
Vernon was okay(if you were good to him) until he stole the boat.
Winston and Andy were just trying to survive.(Though Andy is still fucking weird)
Carver's group was mostly a bunch of dickheads though.
Vernon and Larry were old and grumpy
Troy was just... stupid.
Winston,Troy, and Tavia were bad people.
If I had to choose an evil person it would be Andy St. John. For God's sake he ate people.
Troy, Winston, Tavia- Bad people
Carver, St. John's- EVIL
Tavia's bad (maybe even just mean but scared) yet still somewhat redeemable, imo. I still retain some of that first impression she gave me in 400D.
Larry's an asshole, but that's it.
Vernon's a lying piece of garbage, but VERY far from what I would consider evil.
You didn't mention Carver, who I believe is evil and a psychopath.
Lol but in all seriousness, my opinions are as followed:
Troy - Is not evil. He was overtly violent, but he didn't go out of his way to be sadistic (noticed when Carver is beating Kenny, even Troy looks disturbed). He just followed whatever Carver told him to do, an average lackey. He was an asshole though.
Larry - Is not evil. He had... good intentions? He just had a horrible way of acting on them, and was just too untrusting to give Lee a chance to prove that he was not the terrible person Larry thought he was (seeing as all Larry knew about Lee was that he murdered a senator, not the best first impression). His mindset was to protect Lilly above all else.
Vernon - Is not evil. He was looking out for his group. If you look at it rationally from his point of view, who's going to have a better chance of making it out of a horde infested city? A group of fit healthy adults, or a group of old men? In Vernon's view the boat theft was justified, and while this doesn't make him a good person or discredit his actions, this also doesn't make him evil.
Winston - N/a. Didn't get to see too much of Winston, besides his signature line and him struggling to beat a child in terms of strength. I'd like to give him the benefit of doubt and just not answer for him, though his willingness to kill a child speaks for itself.
Tavia - Is not evil. Nothing she said in 400 Days was ever a lie, their group did want more people and all you needed to do was work. She just forgot to mention the psychopathic leader that is Carver. We also didn't get to see her too much this episode and what her opinion of Carver as a leader is, but seeing as she seems to be trusted and high up on the ladder she must agree with Carver's methods. This doesn't warrant her as evil, she's more of a bystander, though being a bystander isn't much better.
Carver - Is evil. While left more ambiguous in Ep 2, it seemed throughout Ep 3 all of Carver's appearances were meant just to make us hate him more/show us he's a violent psychopath. Murder for the heck of it, his determination to drag back this group just to force them to complete menial labour (and the baby but whatever), I feel like this is pretty self explanatory.
Personally I enjoyed it in Ep 2 when they left it more ambiguous on who was the bad guy, Carver or the Cabin group, but whatever.
Edit: Wow I don't know how I read Andy St. John as Carver, but here I go.
Andy - Is evil. What crossed the line for me was when they had a clear chance to let Lee's group go, but decided to keep them. Even without this, tricking passerby's into coming to your farm and slaughtering them for meat is sick.