Jane or the Group??
At the very end of the episode, Jane tell's Clem something like "they're all going to die, don't let yourself get dragged down with them".
That to me is a very important statement I keep pondering. Would I choose to keep Clem with the group of friend's she trust's or go off with Jane who know's how to survive in this world?
My morality and loyalty want's me to stay with the group, but my instincts say go with Jane, she'll teach Clem better how to survive.
I think as of right now, if I were playing EP4 and was given the choice between the group and Jane, I would choose to go with Jane. It's not easy, I'm still struggling with the whole idea right now, but in the long run, I see that as the wisest decision!
What would you choose? Group or Jane?
That to me is a very important statement I keep pondering. Would I choose to keep Clem with the group of friend's she trust's or go off with Jane who know's how to survive in this world?
My morality and loyalty want's me to stay with the group, but my instincts say go with Jane, she'll teach Clem better how to survive.
I think as of right now, if I were playing EP4 and was given the choice between the group and Jane, I would choose to go with Jane. It's not easy, I'm still struggling with the whole idea right now, but in the long run, I see that as the wisest decision!
What would you choose? Group or Jane?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I don't even have to think about it, I am going with the group, If the option comes I'll mash the hell out of it in a heartbeat.
I'd never leave Nick and Luke ;)
1. Safety in Numbers. Yeah, I know Jane is a badass, but a whole group is still safer.
2. I don't trust Jane. She is cold as ice, just shoots someone's dick off (although he deserved it) and tells Clem to leave them all for death. Not the start of a healty relationship for me.
3. I trust the cabin group (more or less). And I grew to like them, nearly as much as Season 1 cast. Jane...not so much. She's just a generic Mary Sue to me for the time being.
4. Like someone already said, Jane might just decide Clementine isn't of any use to her anymore...Kenn or Luke would never do that.
1. Safety in numbers.. Of course.. but how safe is Rebecca with a baby on the way? All that crying to come! (ever see the final episode of M*A*S*H)
you'll know what I mean if you have.
2. I don't trust Jane like I do Kenny or the group, but then we've only known Jane for a day or two at most. She is a bit cold hearted but IMO that's a good trait to have at times like this. She could tech Clem alot!
3. I'm not sure how big of a role Jane will have in the future, Molly had most of an episode and I was hoping she would have become part of the group. We have some 'good' people with us now but we could really use a badass like Molly or Jane so I hope Jane sticks around and doesnt just take off.
4. That's right.. Knowing Jane for just a day doesn't allow us to get to know her very well and for all I know, she would be willing to pull an Otis on Clem. (shoot her leg leavng her for the walkers while Jane escapes.. Very possible.
I just got the vibe from her that Jane see's the strength in Clem, when she told her good job in getting the radio's. They both know about smearing walker gut's to pass through herd's, She know's Clem (in my playthrough) was strong enough to watch Kenny bash Carver's head in and even took th time to tell Clem the others will die and not to get dragged down with them.. If Jane is such a lone-wolf, why even bother?
And in the EP4 preview, she is teaching Clem how to get past one walker without attracting the others. She obviously see's something in Clem to want to help her.
As I said when I made this post, I am still a bit torn myself with this decision but I'm trying to think what would benefit Clem the most in the long-run. A possible friend and badass like Jane, or a group of people just trying to survive with a newborn baby on the way.
Our current group (depending on your own EP3) One eyed Kenny, bitten or armless Sarita, Mike, Luke and maybe Nick, Rebecca about to go into labor. Carlos is dead, Sarah missing.
Yes is safety in numbers, but our number are dwindling and those we have are in bad shape.
Or Jane. Just the two of us can move faster, Clem will get good training and no worries about the group.
I couldn't leave my boys Nick, Kenny, Luke etc...
That is...if most people are wrong and she doesn't die. Which would be great, but... :/
If it's leaving the group to certain death I might have second thoughts though.
Every playthrough of season one I've decided to split off from the group when Lee and Clem were making a plan.
From day one it's been nothing but dumbass group members making dumbass decisions. Clem shouldn't need to babysit anyone.