i made a thread about lilly and forgiving her if she comes back take a look guys tell me what u think
http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/78895/did-any1-else-feel-sorry-for-lilly
There's at least two interviews out there where Gavin mentioned he had recorded audio for Lilly's return with the RV back in season 1, but t… morehen >Telltale cut it for some reason in the last moment.
I haven't said this, actually, because we didn't. I mentioned in an interview that I thought she should come back (still do) and that there was talk about her coming back as she was being written out of Season 1. That didn't happen though... It wasn't cut, it was never recorded. And I have no comment about Nicki's tweet beyond this--she works a lot!
On the subject of tweets and revealing info about games, it's not necessarily a question of NDAs (though I don't believe I've ever signed one for TTG) but it's SUPER bad business to talk about a game you're working on before it's released. It's basically like begging a developer and all the developers they're friends with to never hire you again. It's their product, so it's very uncool to try and steal their thunder by revealing details about it before they do.
I was thinking of something similar to Kenny's conversation with Clementine in the lodge, if Lee was Kenny's friend Kenny would say "he was a hell of a guy" but if you where not friends he would say "sure we had our differences". Lilly would probably have a similar line depending on leaving or taking her.
I really have reservations about Lily in Season 2. The 400 days characters and Kenny are already stretching disbelief.
But it can't make the season any worse after Amid the Ruins.
I was thinking of something similar to Kenny's conversation with Clementine in the lodge, if Lee was Kenny's friend Kenny would say "he was … morea hell of a guy" but if you where not friends he would say "sure we had our differences". Lilly would probably have a similar line depending on leaving or taking her.
This is just me, considering this I completely missed the whole RV reference in the game. If Lilly indeed does come back, then I think the reused RV model was in the game just to be a subliminal hint toward Lilly's return. Like everyone said, TellTale didn't have to use the RV from Season 1. They would have used anything or nothing at all and still have Lilly return. So like a said, I think the RV was just a hint for people who are very observant to the little details in the game.
As for Lilly returning, I have no problem with it. Sure it seems to convenient, but then again, I've run into people by chance years after seeing them, too. I think having Lilly return can work, but I think it will only work if she shows up towards the end of the episode. She might be able to warn us if Wellington is a trap. I highly doubt she is working with Russians or the leader of Wellington (the leader of Wellington idea would give me a feeling as if she was always right about her decisions in Season 1 and will take away from the dynamic and tension that was between her and Kenny). Plus, this is TellTale. If there is a time for a major mind blowing moment, now is it. I'm sure that whatever they do with Lilly, Lilly fans and Lilly haters will all not see it coming... and I'm still unsure if that is a good or a bad thing. We will see eventually.
Actually they kind of do have control of it (jn that sense) , okay so its not the most telling tweet ever but if she does come back her cont… moreract likely says she cant announce Lilly is returning as a spoiler, the guy who played Kenny couldn't do it either. That could stretch to not even announcing she was recording.
She didn't announce it, she just said "I did some recordings I think you all will like." If anything, that is very similar if not just like the vague hints Telltale's people like to give out to increase hype for episodes of their games. So I don't think she would be not allowed to mention it.
Freedom of speech can come with consequences. You have the freedom to say things, that doesn't mean there will not be any punishment if you abuse that freedom. Whether or not that's the right way to handle it is beside the point, that's how it works.
Aside from that, they might make everyone involved in making their games sign confidentiality agreements so they can't talk about things early. But she never mentioned the game so it's fine, the agreement she very likely signed probably doesn't include vague hints.
I'm not sure how to feel about this.....even if she comes back and she has a mind blowing moment, the only thing that would be on my mind is just how convenient the fact that Clem somehow managed to "reunite" with two persons she most likely thought they were dead in a week is. Will people not scream "bad writing" then? And rightfully so if this turns out to be the case.
If this would happen in the third season I'd be okay with it, but it's way too soon now. Bring Christa back instead.
Man things have happened since I last visited this thread but Nikki Rapp is defo gonna be in episode 5 whether she's talking about Lily or not also keep checking in on her twitter she gave us another hint on her returning with her talking about the picture of kenny with a saltlick!?!
What if i dumped Lilly? Her still getting the RV would make no sense.
Honestly i really hope this doesn't happen. Randomly bumping in to … moresomeone we last saw a hundred miles away once is bad writing (regardless of whether or not you like the character). Twice in one season would be enough to make me consider not buying season 3.
If you don't see someone die onscreen there is a very good chance that they can come back later alive, especially in a story like the Walking Dead.
Hell, sometimes even them dying does nothing to dissuade fans from theorizing about their return. I could bring up the subject of Lee's very unlikely survival sometimes brought up on the forums, but I personally enjoy my friend's take on Omid: The bullet wound didn't kill him, but he became moody and withdrawn afterward and with the possible death of his child he left Christa and Clementine alone and is now surviving somewhere in the woods.
If you left Lilly on the road Lilly: Clementine, come in Wellington you are welcome here!!! Kenny: What about me? Lilly: Just like you left me on the road, now I leave you on the road.
If you let Lilly on the RV Lilly: Clementine, Come in please! Kenny im so sorry for killing Carley please come in! Kenny: Im also sorry for killing your father (Now Lilly and Kenny are together )
Okay, I have thought about this a bit. At first I was opposed to the idea of Lilly returning, but now I am more open to it, but only if it is done right. Meeting Kenny in Virginia after 20 months or so apart, just by chance, was pushing the disbelief factor a bit. Don't get me wrong, I like Kenny, even with all his flaws. It makes him a very human character. But if we meet Lilly at Wellington I could certainly believe that more readily. Everyone is heading there apparently. Everybody hears about it. If it exists and is still up and running, it would be believable that she could be there. Along with maybe Christa, or the 400 days characters who didn't go with Tavia. That is a lot more realistic and believable than "hey I just randomly stumbled across you guys like I did with Kenny".
If it's done in a way that isn't too contrived or silly, then I will be all for it. I liked Lilly's character, it would be nice to see her again.
I havent liked her when she shot Carley/Doug but she was nice to Clem if you remember when she mentioned Clem if she gets sick she even gave her the "hair thingies" for sleep. Gosh i hope she comes back she will bring back s1 memories
Because it was overly coincidental and badly explained ("I got lucky"). Kenny's a pretty interesting character to have around though, so i was able to forgive it. To pull the same trick again in such a shot space of time would be really pushing the realms of believably for me. It just makes things feel contrived.
That's only my opinion though. Evidently from the down votes people here disagree. It will be intesting to see how people outside of the core fanbase react if is this is true.
I hope this happens...
If you left Lilly on the road Lilly: Clementine, come in Wellington you are welcome here!!! Kenny: What about me? … moreLilly: Just like you left me on the road, now I leave you on the road.
If you let Lilly on the RV Lilly: Clementine, Come in please! Kenny im so sorry for killing Carley please come in! Kenny: Im also sorry for killing your father (Now Lilly and Kenny are together )
Comments
It'd be great if you didn't advertise your thread on mine? Thanks.
"Shit's gonna get so fucking real."
I'd want to meet Lilly, then she takes them back to Wellington where she is the leader and she knows Christa/Saved Christa's life from the bandits?
I KNOW I KNOW I KNOW
The fact that you even commented on my thread is making me fangirl.
I THOUGHT WE WERE FRIENDS
I was thinking of something similar to Kenny's conversation with Clementine in the lodge, if Lee was Kenny's friend Kenny would say "he was a hell of a guy" but if you where not friends he would say "sure we had our differences". Lilly would probably have a similar line depending on leaving or taking her.
More like Kenny is gonna hate Lily.
How are the 400 days characters unbelievable?
That seems likely
The "Asshole" Line is determinant (it only appears if your Lee called her an asshole the first time you met her in the drug store)
OH MY GOD! IT'S THE REAL KENNY! Kenny is love, Kenny is life.
So she will be in EP5? or not?
This is just me, considering this I completely missed the whole RV reference in the game. If Lilly indeed does come back, then I think the reused RV model was in the game just to be a subliminal hint toward Lilly's return. Like everyone said, TellTale didn't have to use the RV from Season 1. They would have used anything or nothing at all and still have Lilly return. So like a said, I think the RV was just a hint for people who are very observant to the little details in the game.
As for Lilly returning, I have no problem with it. Sure it seems to convenient, but then again, I've run into people by chance years after seeing them, too. I think having Lilly return can work, but I think it will only work if she shows up towards the end of the episode. She might be able to warn us if Wellington is a trap. I highly doubt she is working with Russians or the leader of Wellington (the leader of Wellington idea would give me a feeling as if she was always right about her decisions in Season 1 and will take away from the dynamic and tension that was between her and Kenny). Plus, this is TellTale. If there is a time for a major mind blowing moment, now is it. I'm sure that whatever they do with Lilly, Lilly fans and Lilly haters will all not see it coming... and I'm still unsure if that is a good or a bad thing. We will see eventually.
Are you Armored Titan??
Why do you get dislikes for saying this?!It's like people can't express their opinion anymore without getting hate for it
Yay i found you
Nah, he was only good when he acted as a stand-in for Carver. Omid's the only good one.
Maybe PR signed off on a tweet like that telling her it's okay.
She didn't announce it, she just said "I did some recordings I think you all will like." If anything, that is very similar if not just like the vague hints Telltale's people like to give out to increase hype for episodes of their games. So I don't think she would be not allowed to mention it.
.
Freedom of speech can come with consequences. You have the freedom to say things, that doesn't mean there will not be any punishment if you abuse that freedom. Whether or not that's the right way to handle it is beside the point, that's how it works.
Aside from that, they might make everyone involved in making their games sign confidentiality agreements so they can't talk about things early. But she never mentioned the game so it's fine, the agreement she very likely signed probably doesn't include vague hints.
I'm not sure how to feel about this.....even if she comes back and she has a mind blowing moment, the only thing that would be on my mind is just how convenient the fact that Clem somehow managed to "reunite" with two persons she most likely thought they were dead in a week is. Will people not scream "bad writing" then? And rightfully so if this turns out to be the case.
If this would happen in the third season I'd be okay with it, but it's way too soon now. Bring Christa back instead.
Oh realy?
Lmao, "freedom of speech". Nice one.
Aha I love Kenny's line throughout Episode 3 another one is:
Ben: Maybe we could walk?
Kenny: Thats fucking stupid Ben.
Man things have happened since I last visited this thread but Nikki Rapp is defo gonna be in episode 5 whether she's talking about Lily or not also keep checking in on her twitter she gave us another hint on her returning with her talking about the picture of kenny with a saltlick!?!
How was bumping into Kenny bad writing?
Great
I'll be seeing this gif in my sleep.
If you don't see someone die onscreen there is a very good chance that they can come back later alive, especially in a story like the Walking Dead.
Hell, sometimes even them dying does nothing to dissuade fans from theorizing about their return. I could bring up the subject of Lee's very unlikely survival sometimes brought up on the forums, but I personally enjoy my friend's take on Omid: The bullet wound didn't kill him, but he became moody and withdrawn afterward and with the possible death of his child he left Christa and Clementine alone and is now surviving somewhere in the woods.
I hope it is Lilly, it would be kind of weird if she voiced a new character.
I hope this happens...
If you left Lilly on the road Lilly: Clementine, come in Wellington you are welcome here!!! Kenny: What about me? Lilly: Just like you left me on the road, now I leave you on the road.
If you let Lilly on the RV Lilly: Clementine, Come in please! Kenny im so sorry for killing Carley please come in! Kenny: Im also sorry for killing your father (Now Lilly and Kenny are together
)
Okay, I have thought about this a bit. At first I was opposed to the idea of Lilly returning, but now I am more open to it, but only if it is done right. Meeting Kenny in Virginia after 20 months or so apart, just by chance, was pushing the disbelief factor a bit. Don't get me wrong, I like Kenny, even with all his flaws. It makes him a very human character. But if we meet Lilly at Wellington I could certainly believe that more readily. Everyone is heading there apparently. Everybody hears about it. If it exists and is still up and running, it would be believable that she could be there. Along with maybe Christa, or the 400 days characters who didn't go with Tavia. That is a lot more realistic and believable than "hey I just randomly stumbled across you guys like I did with Kenny".
If it's done in a way that isn't too contrived or silly, then I will be all for it. I liked Lilly's character, it would be nice to see her again.
Kenny: We made it everybody! We've reached Wellington!
Lilly: >=(
Kenny:...Oh fuck.
I hope we have an option to be not super happy with seeing her. R.I.P Carley/Doug
Not sure.
I just go by the philosophy of "fuck it."
It's easier for someone to hit the dislike button than to give a convincing argument
I literally listened to Pendulum Blood sugar while looking at this for 2 minutes.
Because it was overly coincidental and badly explained ("I got lucky"). Kenny's a pretty interesting character to have around though, so i was able to forgive it. To pull the same trick again in such a shot space of time would be really pushing the realms of believably for me. It just makes things feel contrived.
That's only my opinion though. Evidently from the down votes people here disagree. It will be intesting to see how people outside of the core fanbase react if is this is true.
you do realise that its the walking dead there is no place for happy endings/ Beginning