What would you do? [Scenario for Ep 5]
Here's a little scenario we could discuss. I've been thinking about it for a couple days.
Everyone survived the shootout and is being tied up by the russians.
Arvo walks up to Clem and tells her to choose a group member to be shot dead this instant, the baby is also an option.
Who would you choose and why?
There is no good solution for this, somebody must die, and it's going to be a hard decision.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I would let the timer run out... also, I don't think that would be the case since it seems Clementine will be alone for most of the episode, but it could still happen
I think it's very unlikely for this to happen, I just wanted to start a hypothetical discussion about it, because I wouldn't know what to do. I'd love to hear some opinions from the community
yea… well… I would without hesitation get the baby killed.
Had no character development whatsoever. And let's face it… Given the conditions, he's not gonna make it either way.
Before i answer...Why is Arvo killing people ''Carver style'' for no reason? What an asshole...
That's what I was thinking at first, but imagine what the group must think. Especially Kenny.
I'd choose the baby.
man fuck kenny…. I fucking chopped his girlfriends arm off and axed her in the head. Kenny's has gone completely nuts!
Yeah, he has, because of shit like this. Clementine deciding to kill a baby wouldn't help. I think he'd rather be killed himself before letting the baby get shot.
If that happened in the game, I would be so stressed. I'd have to pause it and take a break. If I had to choose, I guess it would be the baby (I know I'm a horrible person) only cause I love everyone else in our group. But god could you imagine if you don't choose someone before the timer runs out you'd die and have to start the scene over XD
Plot twist: He's Carver's bastard son.
Exactly! OR if you remain silent, someone is randomly chosen by the game.
I'd tell him to shoot Clementine.
Clementines immortal BITCH
I wouldn't be able to handle that stress XD
I guess if it didn't have a timer.... I wouldn't pick Mike since he hasn't actually done anything bad.... or the baby, who kills babies?! Bonnie seems nice although she is kind of the reason we're all at this point, Kenny was angry at Clementine, with good reason though and Luke was having some Jane time when he was supposed to be looking out for Walkers, therefore, he endangered the group...
Rebecca's child will die. It's the most useless member of the group.
Maybe it would make more sense if Buricko made Clementine do it and Arvo translated.
i feel like killing the baby would ruin all Rebecca was living for and piss off Kenny.. i guess id kill Kenny or Luke.
This gif makes me uncomfortable
Sadly, this wouldn't happen because it would make everyone except Clem determinant.
Yes, that'd make more sense
And that's true, it would piss everyone off, I think.
Glad I'm not the only one...
The baby.
True, Clem is immortal, so if you want to kill her, you'd have to restart the scene for all eternity...
Yeah, that'd be some real interesting twist.
I'm having trouble believing this would work.
See, Kenny would never let the baby die. Ever. Mike would (probably) protect Bonnie, Luke to Clem, and so on.
So maybe It's just Mike, Kenny, and Luke who's determinant.
[Shoot Mike] Bonnie pleads, but Mike dies.
[Shoot Bonnie] Mike throws himself in front of Bonnie and orders his own death. Mike dies.
[Shoot Kenny] Kenny is surprised but angry, the group is visibly disturbed. Kenny dies.
[Shoot Luke] Luke is surprised and sad that Clem would do such a thing. The group is visibly disturbed. Luke dies.
[Volunteer yourself] Luke is angry and puts himself between Clem and Arvo. He orders his own death. Luke dies.
[Shoot baby] Kenny asks in a very angry tone "what the FUCK are you doing?!" he stands up and orders his own death. Kenny dies.
What do you think? (Bonnie is not determinant in this situation.)
Orr
[Shoot Buricko, Maud and Vitali] Clementine acts like she will shoot Kenny then she quickly turns around and shoots those three and Kenny gets up and pushes Arvo on the group and put him on gunpoint
But in my situation Arvo is the shooter...sooo...
Oh, then Clementine says "Let me shoot him, He's my friend." or She just takes the gun from him and shoots the bad guys
This is a hostage situation. I'm thinking Arvo won't be that willing to untie her, unless you didn't steal the pills. But she'd get shot before she killed the 2nd guy.
Arvo wouldnt do something as evil as that. He's probably shoot his own team and save Clementines team :P
Who knows what Arvo would do. We don't know him that well. He may not be willing to shoot the baby or Clem, but an adult? That may not be a problem. That's why the baby and Clem can't die.
Hm you're probably right. But if Clem tells him to shoot the baby and he doesnt, Buricko will take the gun from him and shoot the baby himself or Clem so yeah
He'll give his orders. I hope Arvo is the one in charge. They argue in their [Speaking Russian] way until Kenny/Luke/Mike steps up in front of the baby/Clem/Bonnie.
HE WANTS TO KILL THE SECOND SON.
The baby probably. At least, the other members can actually do things.
...Kenny or Luke. BUT NO ONE LAYS A HAND ON BIKE.